Resolved that application GR/07/0527 be REFUSED on the grounds that the development would result in the loss of an open gap between an end of terrace dwelling and a pair of semi-detached dwellings in a street where there are generally long terraces of dwellings and where such gaps are important in providing relief from the uniformity and enclosure of the street scene; the development would therefore be harmful to the street scene and character of the area and if permitted would set a precedent for the filling of the few remaining gaps in the street and as such would be contrary to policy QL1 of the approved Kent and Medway Structure Plan, policies H3 and TC1 of the Gravesham Local Plan First Review and policies H4 and BE12 of the Gravesham Local Plan Second Review Deposit Version.
Word for word from the decision Gravesham published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gravesham.gov.uk
This application was originally reported to the meeting of the Regulatory Board on Wednesday 5 September 2007.
Planning permission had been recommended subject to conditions. However the Board resolved that it was minded to REFUSE the application.
Members are asked to bring to this meeting a copy of the previous report (Agenda Item 8) of the September Board meeting.
Members are advised that the applicants have indicated to officers that they intend to appeal the application on the grounds of non-determination although to date no such appeal has been received. (NB due to amendments to the red line boundary the application has been revalidated and the statutory period for determination has not yet expired.)
2. Possible Grounds of Refusal
At the September Board meeting Members considered that the development would be harmful to the street scene and that this would set a precedent and was an example of “town cramming” as highlighted in an earlier Kent Structure Plan Policy. There was concern at the loss of the gap which was an “open space”. Members also expressed concern at the problem of heavy on-street parking although they acknowledged that there was no highway objection from Kent Highways.
Members are advised that there may be an argument to suggest that the development would impact on the street scene and therefore contrary to planning policy although it is not a very strong reason for rejecting the proposal and it would be very difficult to defend this at appeal. Members are reminded that the Inspector, in the recent appeal decision in February 2007, had “no objection to the principle of residential development on this plot, or to the dwelling size” and further he stated “The proposed design would not look out of place in the street scene”. The current proposal is identical externally at the front to that which the Planning Inspector had considered in the planning appeal. Whilst potentially a different Inspector could adopt a contrary view it is considered that this may be unlikely.
The applicants have already indicated that they are likely to seek a claim of costs against the Council in an appeal against non-determination.
Should Members still consider that the current development is unacceptable then the following ground of refusal is suggested as being appropriate:
1. The development would result in the loss of an open gap between an end of terrace dwelling and a pair of semi-detached dwellings in a street where there are generally long terraces of dwellings and where such gaps are important in providing relief from the uniformity and enclosure of the street scene; the development would therefore be harmful to the street scene and character of the area and if permitted would set a precedent for the filling of the few remaining gaps in the street and as such would be contrary to policy QL1 of the approved Kent and Medway Structure Plan, policies H3 and TC1 of the Gravesham Local Plan First Review and policies H4 and BE12 of the Gravesham Local Plan Second Review Deposit Version.
A highway ground of refusal is not recommended.
3. Resource implications
The Director (Regeneration and Regulation) had recommended permission for the application. If permission is refused, depending on the type of appeal, it may be necessary to engage an external consultant experienced in planning matters to defend the Council’s decision on appeal.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.