CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Gravesham Borough Council
Cabinet, Monday 8 March 2010 at 7.00pm

Review of Scrutiny Procedures

Agreed Executive 2 papers

Cabinet agreed this item on Monday 8 March 2010. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item123

Resolved

The Cabinet agreed that:- (1) the working group be thanked for its work; (2) topics for pre-decision scrutiny be selected from the key decisions listed in the Forward Plan; (3) the value threshold for key decisions be reduced to £100k; (4) the period covered by the Forward Plan be extended to six months; (5) topics for pre-decision scrutiny be jointly agreed between the chairman of a POC and the relevant shadow lead member; (6) pre-decision scrutiny be carried out by the relevant POC and where cross portfolio issues are being scrutinised either by each POC or a combined meeting of the relevant POCs ; (7) officers in the department from which the pre-decision item is chosen will be responsible for providing any additional information required for its scrutiny; (8) the amendments to Article 13 of the Constitution and Annex 2.2 – Access to Information Procedure Rules arising from the changes to the Forward Plan process be submitted to the 27 April 2010 meeting of Council without debate and then to the June meeting for discussion/adoption; (9) a pilot programme of one key partnership per POC be prepared and circulated to Cabinet and POC Chairmen; and (10) a protocol for the scrutiny of partnerships be prepared and together with any necessary amendments to the Constitution, be submitted to Cabinet for consideration.
Word for word from the decision Gravesham published for this meeting. Source: democracy.gravesham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Gravesham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Recommendations

1. the working group be thanked for its work

2. topics for pre-decision scrutiny be selected from the key decisions listed in the Forward Plan

3. the value threshold for key decisions be reduced to £100k

4. the period covered by the Forward Plan be extended to six months.

5. topics for pre-decision scrutiny be jointly agreed between the chairman of a POC and the relevant shadow lead member

6. pre-decision scrutiny be carried out by the relevant POC and where cross portfolio issues are being scrutinised either by each POC or a combined meeting of the relevant POCs.

7. officers in the department from which the pre-decision item is chosen will be responsible for providing any additional information required for its scrutiny.

8. the amendments to Article 13 of the Constitution and Annex 2.2 – Access to Information Procedure Rules arising from the changes to the Forward Plan process be submitted to the 27 April 2010 meeting of Council without debate and then to the June meeting for discussion/adoption.

9. A pilot programme of one key partnership per POC be prepared and circulated to Cabinet and POC Chairmen..

10. A protocol for the scrutiny of partnerships be prepared and together with any necessary amendments to the Constitution, be submitted to Cabinet for consideration. 1. Background

1.1A working group had been set up to carry out a review of GBC’s scrutiny procedures.

1.2The terms of reference for the review were:

To review by various means, including learning visits to other authorities and the involvement of South East Employers, the Overview and Scrutiny function within the Council and identify if the committee could better fulfil its role through

• pre-Cabinet scrutiny of key decisions and the role that the Overview Scrutiny Committee or the Policy Overview Committees may play in this process

• an improved relationship between the Cabinet Overview Scrutiny Committee, and what form this could take

• the development of a clear protocol for use of the call-in tool, and

• enhanced selection and prioritisation of topics for scrutiny review

To submit recommendations to Cabinet and Overview Scrutiny Committee based on the evidence gathered during the review.

1.3The working group submitted its preliminary findings and recommendations to cabinet on 16 November 2009.

1.3One of the recommendations was to further investigate pre-decision scrutiny.

2. Pre-decision scrutiny

2.1At the Working Group meeting on 18 January (notes are attached at Appendix 1) members were advised of the outcome from officer visits to Tunbridge Wells Borough Council and Kent County Council.

2.2Tunbridge Wells includes items other than key decisions on its forward plan from which pre-decision scrutiny items are chosen. Kent County Council on the other hand was looking at the possibility of extending the time period of its own Forward Plan from 4 to 6 months.

2.3The working group concluded that it was not practicable to include all decisions in Gravesham’s Forward Plan nor use divisional service plans as a pre decision aide however it was agreed that the time period covered by the Forward Plan should be extended to six months and the financial limits for inclusion be reduced.

2.4If these changes are implemented Article 13.04 (6) of the Constitution and Paragraph 16.1 of Annex 2.2 – Access to Information Procedure Rules will need to be amended.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Appendix ProposedamendmentstotheConstitutionForwardPlanAppendix ProposedamendmentstotheConstitutionForwardPlan 20 KB Download
PDF
Review of Scrutiny ProceduresReport 39 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

15 of 19 attended
HD
Hardip DhaliwalOfficer, expected
MS
Cllr Michael SnellingChair, present
DT
Cllr David TurnerVice-Chair, present
JC
Cllr John CubittCommittee Member, present
LH
Cllr Laura HryniewiczCommittee Member, absent
AP
Cllr Anthony PritchardCommittee Member, present
AW
Cllr Adrian WarburtonCommittee Member, present
LC
Cllr Lee CroxtonGuest, in attendance
AW
Cllr Andrea WebbGuest, in attendance
NC
Nick ChannonOfficer, present
GT
Glyn ThomsonOfficer, present
MH
Mike HayleyOfficer, present

All 19 on the meeting page

On this subject at Gravesham

Search all
  1. Review of Scrutiny ProceduresThis decision
  2. Scrutiny Review of Street Cleanliness, littering, and Fly-tipping throughout the BoroughAgreed
  3. Scrutiny Review of GBC's Maritime Strategy - Oral UpdateNoted
  4. Scrutiny Reviews Oral UpdateAgreed
  5. Scrutiny Reviews - Oral UpdateAgreed
  6. Scrutiny Review Programme - Future work planAgreed

More from Gravesham Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
2 Nov 2026 Refuse Vehicle ProcurementTo procure three refuse collection vehicles (one new vehicle and two new chassis with replacement body vehicles) to s... Refused Open
28 Sep 2026 Change to Order of BusinessIt was agreed that the order of business, during the meeting, be amended accordingly. Agreed Open
28 Sep 2026 Cygnet Leisure Centre - Wet Side ImprovementsDecision, outlining the intention to part fund the refurbishment, was published on 14 July 2026 GCLL had provided a p... Noted Open
28 Sep 2026 Gravesham Borough Council's response to 'The Shift'· The Council will work with the Shift Committee & young people to explore, design & develop an interim community spa... Decided Open
28 Sep 2026 LGA Corporate Peer Challenge - Progress Review Follow-up· That the content of the LGA Corporate Peer Challenge Progress Review report be noted · That the process for publish... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies