The Cabinet agreed that:- (1) the replacement of existing gas ovens with combination of electric and gas appliances to facilitate health and safety and compliance with gas regulations outlined as option 2 in the report be approved; and (2) the report be referred to the Overview Scrutiny Committee.
Word for word from the decision Gravesham published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gravesham.gov.uk
Subject: Outstanding repairs and maintenance, Woodville Halls Catering, Kitchen Refurbishment Purpose and summary of report: To consider options for Woodville Halls Catering Kitchen Refurbishment.
Recommendations: 1. That Members approve the replacement of existing gas ovens with combination of electric and gas appliances to facilitate health and safety and compliance with gas regulations outlined as option 2 in the report.
1. Introduction
1.1Members have made resources available in recent years to undertake planned maintenance to all the Council's properties. Due to the need for prioritisation Members considered such priorities annually against a scored weighting system. This year the matter was also considered by Overview Scrutiny which at its 25 March 2010 meeting resolved that:-
(1) Cabinet review item 13, Woodville Halls Catering, Kitchen Refurbishment on the required and cyclical maintenance list for 2010/11 in regard of the reasoning, weighting, justification and funding of this item.
2.1This issue breaks down into two distinct areas. Firstly, service need in terms of whether the facility is essential for the needs of the Woodville Hall's business. Secondly, whether the technical solution proposed is cost effective and efficient in terms of meeting the needs of that business. The above must be considered against a backdrop of no significant investment in the kitchen facilities for several years, changes of legislation particularly in relation to health and safety and in particular the gas regulations.
3. Service Need
3.1Discussions have taken place with the Service Manager, Customer & Theatre Services around the requirement for a kitchen to support functions and income to the Woodville Halls. A list has been provided attached at Appendix 1 of recent bookings which show where a specific charge of £750 is made for the kitchen facility. In 2008/09 the hiring fees for the kitchen alone amounted to a total of £11,250. For a similar period in 2009/10 the figure amounted to a total of £13,500. Without the kitchen facility the above hirings would not be possible and it should be noted that a typical wedding generates a total fee of £4,000 plus bar income of approx £700 which, for example, in 2009/10 generated in the region of £75,000 gross income.
3.2In addition, to the above the kitchen is used for other functions, several of which are also listed and where it would not be possible to host the booking without the means to cook/prepare food. The Service Manager has also indicated that a significant number of buffets are catered for, the larger ones of which cannot be dealt with within the Spotlites Cafe needing the main kitchen as backup.
3.3In conclusion the Service Manager recognises that the £30,000 kitchen refurbishment is a significant cost item but if viewed in terms of whole life costing shows a 2.5 year pay back period on direct kitchen lettings alone based on current income. This disregards all other income generated from the main hirings all of which shown in appendix 1 are requiring a kitchen facility that is safe and fit for purpose.
4. Technical Requirements 4.1 As stated above the kitchen refit / refurbishment is necessary to comply with current health and safety requirements, particularly in terms of the gas regulations which require carbon monoxide to be monitored resulting from gas use and a facility to shut down in the event of a level being exceeded. The current kitchen is not fit for purpose and this has caused problems with hirers, in particular those wishing to make use of the full facilities available. In order to comply there were two routes considered within what was considered to be a reasonable cost limit having regard to the ongoing income.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.