Resolved
The Cabinet endorsed the statements contained within the report as regards the role and operational procedures of the Appeal s Sub-Committee .
Cabinet decided this item on Tuesday 1 June 2010. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
The Cabinet endorsed the statements contained within the report as regards the role and operational procedures of the Appeal s Sub-Committee .
Gravesham Borough Council
Report to: Cabinet
Date: 1 June 2010
Reporting officer: Assistant Director (Business and Law)
Subject: The Role of the Appeals Sub-Committee
Purpose and summary of report:
To advise Cabinet on the role of the Appeals Sub-Committee.
Recommendations: That Cabinet considers the report and endorses the statements contained therein as regards the role and operational procedures of the Appeals Sub-Committee.
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1The Appeals Sub-Committee is the last stage of internal appeal against management decisions in disciplinary matters. Typically the Sub-Committee is concerned with appeals against decisions to dismiss employees. Such matters may concern allegations of gross misconduct or persistent misconduct and the issues may later be referred to an Employment Tribunal in a claim against alleged unfair dismissal. It is accordingly essential that the Council must demonstrably follow fair and equitable procedures. The Sub-Committee is appointed annually by the Regulatory Board.
1.2The appeal is normally a review of the process taken by the Council’s managers. It is not a re-hearing of the matter and the Sub-Committee is principally concerned that policy and procedure have been applied correctly. In rare circumstances relevant newly discovered evidence may come to light which would justify a rehearing of the matter. In such exceptional cases the Sub-Committee should remit the matter for rehearing by management, with a direction to reconsider. A further appeal to the Sub-Committee would of course lie from such a rehearing. It is essential that the process is demonstrably fair and that neither side is given cause to feel disadvantaged by the manner of appeal.
2. THE ROLE OF MEMBERS
2.1The Appeals Sub-Committee must consider:
2.1.1. Whether the management action followed the process of the policy properly 2.1.2. Whether the policy and procedures were fairly and consistently applied 2.1.3. Whether the decision taken by the Council’s managers was reasonable under all the circumstances. 2.2. The Appeals Sub-Committee must decide whether management decisions should be rescinded, upheld or referred back to Management. In order to determine the matter the Sub-Committee should take into account the following factors:-
2.2.1. If fresh evidence that is relevant, is produced at the hearing then the matter should be referred back to management to re-determine.
2.2.2. Whether management have correctly applied the council policies and procedures in a fair way – if they have not then the decision should be referred back to management to reconsider
2.2.3. If due process has been properly followed and applied then the sub-committee have to go on to consider whether the sanction imposed by management falls within “the band of reasonable responses”.
2.2.4. A management decision should not be overturned unless ‘the original decision is outside the band of reasonable responses’, i.e. no reasonable Authority would have imposed that sanction.
2.3In disciplinary cases it is the role of the Sub-Committee to determine whether the decision taken, for example to dismiss, was within the range of reasonable responses open to a reasonable employer. It is further for the Sub-Committee to decide whether in fact the employer acted reasonably in treating this as sufficient reason to take the action it did. As it is not a rehearing it is not open to the Sub-Committee to simply substitute its own verdict for the original decision which was arrived at after hearing all the evidence including any mitigation. Although the burden of proof, which is the balance of probabilities, lies upon the Council it is absolutely clear that a management decision should not be overturned unless the grounds of appeal are upheld and the original decision is outside the band of reasonable responses and justifies a different conclusion.
3. PROCEDURE
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
The Role of the Appeals Sub-CommitteeReport | 54 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Cabinet at Gravesham and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Nov 2026 | Refuse Vehicle ProcurementTo procure three refuse collection vehicles (one new vehicle and two new chassis with replacement body vehicles) to s... | Refused | Open |
| 28 Sep 2026 | Change to Order of BusinessIt was agreed that the order of business, during the meeting, be amended accordingly. | Agreed | Open |
| 28 Sep 2026 | Cygnet Leisure Centre - Wet Side ImprovementsDecision, outlining the intention to part fund the refurbishment, was published on 14 July 2026 GCLL had provided a p... | Noted | Open |
| 28 Sep 2026 | Gravesham Borough Council's response to 'The Shift'· The Council will work with the Shift Committee & young people to explore, design & develop an interim community spa... | Decided | Open |
| 28 Sep 2026 | LGA Corporate Peer Challenge - Progress Review Follow-up· That the content of the LGA Corporate Peer Challenge Progress Review report be noted · That the process for publish... | Noted | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.