It was agreed: that, save for any further amendments that may be required to be made and approved by the Leader, the Borough Council responds to the Department of Transport consultation questions, supported by the accompanying report, as follows: ( i ) that the case for an additional crossing cannot be made until the tolls are removed and free flow allowed, and the results of the Airport Commission in relation to Estuary airports known; (ii) that it is against route C, East of Gravesend, on environmental and financial cost grounds; (iii) it is against route B because of its poor value for money, limited congestion relief, and the impact on development opportunities; ( iv ) notes that the greatest relief, with the least environmental impact and financial cost, is achieved at the existing Dartford Crossing; (v) any route choice must have a supporting package of highway and environmental mitigation and compensation measures as appropriate to the option.
Word for word from the decision Gravesham published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gravesham.gov.uk
Reporting officer: Director (Housing and Regeneration)
Subject: Lower Thames Crossing
Purpose and summary of report: The Department for Transport (DfT) has issued a consultation on options for additional crossing capacity of the Thames at Dartford, Swanscombe Peninsula and East of Gravesend, which requires a response by 16 July 2013. The extensive evidence produced by the Department has been analysed, and this has highlighted the major impacts and benefits that exist with the three options. Recommendations: That the Borough Council responds to the Department of Transport consultation questions, supported by this report, as follows: (i) that the case for an additional crossing cannot be made until the tolls are removed and free flow allowed, and the results of the Airport Commission in relation to Estuary airports known; (ii) that it is against route C, East of Gravesend, on environmental and financial cost grounds; (iii) it is against route B because of its poor value for money, limited congestion relief, and the impact on development opportunities; (iv) notes that the greatest relief, with the least environmental impact and financial cost, is achieved at the existing Dartford Crossing; (v) any route choice must have a supporting package of highway and environmental mitigation and compensation measures as appropriate to the option.
1. Introduction
1.1On 21 May 2013 the Department for Transport (DfT) issued a consultation on the Options for a New Lower Thames Crossing. This is accompanied by a series of technical reports produced by Aecom (see list in background papers). This work builds on the Parsons Brinckerhoff study of 2009 which identified three corridors worthy of further examination (see plan in Appendix 2), namely:
• A: Dartford Crossing • B: Swanscombe Peninsula
• C: East of Gravesend
o Variant with A229 improvement (Bluebell Hill)
1.2The crossings are all looked at as bridges (54.1m clearance at Dartford, 70m elsewhere), bored tunnel or submersed tube (e.g. Medway Tunnel). Submersed tube is very disruptive to construct and the reports seem to reject it as an option as the Port of London Authority (PLA) has expressed major concerns. The form of crossing does not have a major impact on cost and can be revisited at a later stage.
1.3A technical analysis has been carried out of the options and their implications, attached as Appendix 3, which has been written as a stand-alone document.
1.4The Borough Council’s position was originally set by Cabinet on 1 June 2009 following the publication of the Parsons Brinckerhoff report, that :
(1) the Borough Council welcomes the recently published work on taking the issue of the Lower Thames Crossing forward and that it expects to be centrally involved in any further study work which must look inside as well as outside London; (2) any route on the alignment of route C is not acceptable on environmental grounds, whatever the costs; (3) short term options for boosting capacity of the existing crossing are welcomed and should include abolition of the tolls 1.5 Council on 26 April 2011 passed two motions against a route east of Gravesend and asking that the tolls be removed to allow free movement of vehicles, “which in itself may show the need for the third Crossing to be unnecessary”. On 10 June 2011, whilst considering the Local Transport Plan and associated documents, where the County Council was supporting a route east of Gravesend, Cabinet resolved that “the Borough Council reaffirms its opposition to any Lower Thames Crossing route that runs through east Gravesham”.
1.6The Council has been involved in Stakeholder Advisory Panel meetings held by DfT, attended by the Director (Housing & Regeneration), as the technical work has proceeded but this has not involved any part in the decision making process. The Borough Council’s position has been made clear.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.