(1) That a feasibility and costing report be commissioned for the proposed new build extension to the current Museum buildings and that the vision of developing an updated and exciting museum offering at that site be approved. (2) That the sum of £240,000 be transferred from the provisional capital programme (ED18(p) Museum and Castle Development scheme to the approved capital programme to carry out the work referred to in paragraph (1) above. (3) That the Director of Environment be authorised in consultation with the Lead Councillor for Economic Development, Heritage and Tourism be authorised: (i) to establish a Development Group, consisting of internal representatives and external partners, to assist in the delivery of improvements to the Museum; and (ii) to develop a fundraising strategy and related fundraising committee with a view to identifying and securing external grants and funding for improvements to the Museum (4) That the Museum Working Group be requested to review and make recommendations on the future of the Victorian Schoolroom, including the possible sale of 39½ Castle Street should the Schoolroom be discontinued. (5) That the Action Plan in Appendix 3 to the report submitted to the Executive, be approved and that the Museum Working Group be requested to continue its work to deliver the Action Plan. Reason for To fully review the museum offering for Guildford with a view to improving the service and making it more cost effective. Alternative options considered and rejected by the Executive: The option to move the Museum to another site in the town centre was rejected as an appropriate existing building could not be identified. The option for a new build museum was rejected on cost grounds. Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
Executive Report Ward affected: Holy Trinity Report of Director of Environment Author: James Whiteman Tel: 01483 444701 Email: [email protected] Lead Councillor responsible: Geoff Davis Tel: [phone removed] Email: [email protected] Date: 19 April 2016
Review of Guildford Museum- Second report Executive Summary
This is the second report relating to the review of Guildford Museum. The first report was considered by the Executive on 24 November 2015.
Guildford Museum is based at Quarry Street, Guildford. The site provides public displays and storage of collections owned by the Council and also the Surrey Archaeological Society (SAS) together with offices for the Council’s Heritage team. The buildings in Quarry Street are of significant historical interest but suffer from poor access and visibility. As stated in the previous report, there has been little investment in the Museum for over 25 years and this has left it looking very tired and outdated. Visitor numbers are also low and costs are considered to represent poor value for money. Three failed Heritage Lottery Fund bids have also meant that there has been no additional funding available to address these issues.
The Museum working Group (MWG) has been looking at all aspects of the Museum and its future. The MWG has also visited other museums to learn from their experiences and approaches. Stuart Davies Associates (SDA), museum consultants, have also been carrying out work to inform the review, speaking to stakeholders, partners, public and staff and collating information about other museums. A report outlining their findings and recommendations has been produced and is attached in Appendix 1 and discussed within this report. Their report confirms that our museum offering falls short of current expectations of the type of offering and experience a modern museum should provide. SDA also confirm that Guildford is large enough and historically important enough to warrant a good modern museum and that we have a number of stories that should be told in a refreshed and exciting way.
Alongside the work of SDA, we have also looked for any available sites in the town centre that might be appropriate for a new museum. Searches have confirmed that there are no suitable alternative properties identified for our museum use. The cost of a new build has also been ruled out due to very high costs. As a result, we have also looked at the current site to assess its suitability as the continued and future home of Guildford Museum. An architect has produced some exciting draft plans that suggest an attractive, high quality new build extension to the current site. This would allow for expansive, modern display space along with a café, modern and appropriate access, toilets and an entrance facing into the Castle Grounds. It is suggested that this Council should invest its capital (£2.264 million currently in provisional) into the new extension project. Clearly, this is at very early stages and appropriate feasibility studies and costings will need to be carried out, alongside working with a number of relevant groups and organisations including Historic England and the Council’s own conservation team. To progress this further, we would need scheduled monument consent for alterations to the Kings Chamber, a new build on the historic site and any structural alterations to Castle Arch House. We may also need to involve an archaeological unit to work with us throughout the project. It would also be necessary to seek external funding to adapt and refresh the existing buildings.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.