To review the rent over The March Hare 2-4 South Hill, Guildford GU1 3SY
ApprovedExecutive1 paper
AI summaryGuildford Executive approved a stepped rent increase on The March Hare pub lease, raising average annual rent from £82,500 to £110,000, a 33.4% uplift backdated to 17 April 2025.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedStepped rent increase on lease agreed
Money£110,000 average per annumUp from £82,500, 33.4% uplift
What happens nextSign rent review memorandumAnd collect backdated increased rent
Who it affectsHeartwood Inns Limited tenantAnd council investment income
What was decided
Approved an increase in rent on the lease to Heartwood Inns Limited from £82,500 per annum to a stepped arrangement averaging £110,000 per annum, with effect from the 17 April 2025 rent review. Report 2.2, P7
The stepped rent is £100,000 from 17 April 2025 to 16 April 2026, £110,000 from 17 April 2026 to 16 April 2028, and £115,000 from 17 April 2028 to 16 April 2030. Report 1.4, P5, P6
Why
The proposed settlement represents best consideration, securing a 33.4% uplift in annual rental income for the council. Report 3.1, 3.2
The external surveyor judged comparable Food and Beverage letting evidence justified an increase, and the stepped arrangement was reached after a substantial period of negotiation. Report 6.2, 6.3
Settling avoids the costs, delays and risk of a lower rent that could follow referral to a third-party expert under the RICS dispute resolution service. Report 10.1, 11.2, P36
What happens next
Officers from the Assets and Property team will arrange a rent review memorandum to be signed by the parties. Report 4.1, P12
Finance officers will budget for and arrange collection of the rental income, including the backdated increase to 17 April 2025. Report 4.2
The next rent review is due in 2030, at which point the starting rent will be £115,000 per annum. Report 6.4
The money
£82,500 per annum Existing rent before review Report 2.2
£100,000 per annum Stepped rent, 17 April 2025 to 16 April 2026 Report 1.4
£110,000 per annum Stepped rent, 17 April 2026 to 16 April 2028 Report P5
£115,000 per annum Stepped rent, 17 April 2028 to 16 April 2030 Report P6
£110,000 per annum Average annual rent over the 5-year review period Report P7
£27,500 per annum Average annual increase in rental income Report P37
£300,000 Cumulative additional income over the remaining lease term Report P38
33.4% Uplift in the annual rental income stream Report 3.2
Options considered
Chosen: Conclude the rent review on the recommended stepped terms. Represents best consideration and delivers a 33.4% uplift while avoiding dispute costs Report 11.1, 3.1, 3.2
Rejected: Refer the matter to a third-party independent expert via the RICS dispute resolution service. Exposes the council to significant delays, costs and a risk of a lower rent Report 11.2, P36
Implications
Financial: Boosts commercial property investment income by an average of £27,500 per annum, with cumulative additional income of £300,000 over the remaining lease term. Report P37, P38
Legal: Complies with Section 123 of the Local Government Act 1972, which requires the council to secure the best consideration reasonably obtainable when disposing of land. Report P42, P43
Risk: If the settlement is not approved, the tenant may withdraw and pursue third-party determination, exposing the council to additional costs, delays and a possible lower outcome. Report 10.1, P41
Equalities: Officers concluded there are no diversity or equality implications arising directly from the report. Report 12.3, P45
Climate: No climate change or sustainability implications identified. Report 12.4, P47
Who and where
Heartwood Inns Limited, the tenant under the lease Report 6.1
Guildford Borough Council's investment property portfolio and the services it funds Report 1.1, 7.1
Timeline
17 April 2015: Lease to Heartwood Inns Limited commenced for a 20-year term Report 6.1
17 April 2026: Stepped rent rises to £110,000 per annum Report P5
17 April 2028: Stepped rent rises to £115,000 per annum Report P6
2030: Next rent review due, starting from £115,000 per annum Report 6.4
Plain English for the jargon
RICS: Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, whose dispute resolution service can appoint an independent expert.
Stepped rent: A rent that increases at agreed dates during the review period, here averaging £110,000 per annum over five years.
Upward-only open market rent review: A rent review clause where the rent can only stay the same or rise, set at the open market rental value on the review date.
Best consideration: The best price reasonably obtainable, the standard the council must meet under Section 123 of the Local Government Act 1972 when disposing of land.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemEX144
Resolved
In relation to the lease of 2-4 South Hill, Guildford (The March Hare) to Heartwood Inns Limited dated 17th April 2015, to approve an increase in the rent from £82,500 per annum to the stepped rent arrangement, with an average annual rent of £110,000 per annum with effect from the 17 April 2025 rent review. Reason(s): The proposed settlement represents best consideration. The proposed annual rent secures a 33.4% uplift in the annual rental income stream for the Council. Other options considered and rejected by the Executive: None. Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None.
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
1.1The Council owns an investment property portfolio comprising industrial, office and retail properties. The properties are held for income generation and capital appreciation to support Council services.
1.2The portfolio requires ongoing active property management to keep the estate in good order. Many of the tenanted investment assets are on leases which include provision for regular rent reviews, either based on open market or indexed/ fixed increases. In the case of open market rent reviews officers will instruct external surveyors to provide a rental valuation report and represent the Council in negotiating a settlement.
1.3All lease agreements – including rent reviews – with an income in excess of £200,000 over the life of the contract are required to be approved by the Executive.
1.4Agreement in principle has been reached (subject to the necessary approvals) to conclude the 2025 rent review on the basis of an increase from £82,500 per annum to the following stepped rent arrangement: From 17 April 2025 to 16 April 2026 - £100,000 per annum exclusive
From 17 April 2026 to 16 April 2028 - £110,000 per annum exclusive
From 17 April 2028 to 16 April 2030 - £115,000 per annum excusive
Which provides an average annual rent of £110,000 per annum with effect from the rent review date of 17 April 2025.
Recommendation
2.1That the Executive resolves:
2.2In relation to the lease of 2-4 South Hill, Guildford (The March Hare) to Heartwood Inns Limited dated 17th April 2015, to approve an increase in the rent from £82,500 per annum to the stepped rent arrangement, with an average annual rent of £110,000 per annum with effect from the 17 April 2025 rent review. 2-4 South Hill – Rent Review
Reasons for recommendation
3.1The proposed settlement represents best consideration.
3.2The proposed annual rent secures a 33.4% uplift in the annual rental income stream for the Council.
4 Next steps
4.1Officers from the Assets and Property team to arrange a rent review memorandum to be signed by the parties.
4.2Finance officers to budget for and arrange collection of the rental income including the backdated increased rent.
5 Exemption from publication
5.1The report is partially exempt for the purposes of the Council’s Access to Information Procedure Rules because it contains commercially sensitive information. Under paragraph 3 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A to the Local Government Act 1972 the indicated paragraphs (Appendix 1) are exempt information as they contain information relating to the financial or business affairs of any particular person (including the authority holding that information). Disclosure of this information could prejudice future negotiations if the proposed arrangement is not completed and the public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighs the public interest in disclosure.
5.2The content is restricted to all councillors.
5.3The exempt information is not expected to be made public because it will remain commercially sensitive indefinitely.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.