Resolved
Decision : That the Executive r efuses the nomination and determines that the property referred to as Three Farms Meadow, Ockham, should not be added to the Council’s List of Assets of Community Value. Reasons for The application has not demonstrated an actual current or recent use of the building or other land that is not an ancillary use that furthers the social wellbeing or social interests of the local community presently or in the recent past as prescribed in Section 88(1) of the Localism Act 2011. In particular: a) There is no use of the Property as a whole that furthers the social wellbeing or interests. The local authority is to examine only the land, which has been identified by the applicant in the Nomination Form and is not to consider whether only part of the nominated land qualifies as land of community value. On page 7 of the nomination form, the applicant sets out how the nominated land is used. It states that the majority of the Property (70%) is used for agriculture. This use cannot be said to further the social interests of the community because it is a private business, which does not operate for the benefit of the community as a whole. b) In addition, the application refers to the Property being used by members of the public through the Public Rights of Ways (PROWS). These PROWS do not cover the Property in its entirety and so the Property as a whole cannot be said to be in use for that purpose. The use of PROWS for walking and other recreational purposes is, in any event, considered to be subordinate/ancillary to the main use of the nominated land. Further, whilst PROWS are not expressly excluded from the definition of community uses, it is officers’ view that Parliament cannot have intended for them to benefit from the protection offered by the listing process in circumstances where there are existing statutory schemes that ensure the public’s involvement where the diversion or extinguishment of existing PROWS is proposed. c) The application also submits that the site affords sightings of wildlife etc. It is officers’ view that the amenity afforded to users of the PROWS when looking over the remainder of the land is not a physical and actual use of the Property. d) The other reasons submitted on the nomination form such as identity and safeguarding are also not actual uses of the land but instead reasons why the applicant wishes the land to be run by the community. It seems the only material use of the land by the community is its use of the PROWS and, for the reasons set out above, this is not considered to satisfy the criteria for nomination. Alternative options considered and rejected by the Executive: None Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None The application has not demonstrated an actual current or recent use of the building or other land that is not an ancillary use that furthers the social wellbeing or social interests of the local community presently or in the recent past as prescribed in Section 88(1) of the Localism Act 2011 . In particular: a) There is no use of the Property as a whole that furthers the social wellbeing or interests. The local authority is to examine only the land, which has been identified by the applicant in the Nomination Form and is not to consider whether only part of the nominated land qualifies as land of community value. On page 7 of the nomination form, the applicant sets out how the nominated land is used. It states that the majority of the Property (70%) is used for agriculture. This use cannot be said to further the social interests of the community because it is a private business, which does not operate for the benefit of the community as a whole. b) In addition, the application refers to the Property being used ... view the full minutes text for item EX74