CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Guildford Borough Council
Executive, Thursday 24 November 2022 at 7.00pm

Supplementary Estimate for funds in respect of planning appeals relating to Member overturn decisions

Noted Executive 1 paper

Executive noted this item on Thursday 24 November 2022. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

ItemEX57

Resolved

That the need for a supplementary estimate for the Development Management service of £535,000 to cover the payments required to defend three significant appeals relating to Member overturn decisions which were subsequently heard at either public inquiry or as a hearing, be noted. 2. That full Council (6 December 2022) be recommended to note the report and to approve the supplementary estimate. Reason(s): To ensure robust defence of planning appeals resulting from Member overturn decisions. Other options considered and rejected by the Executive: None. Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None.
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting. Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Guildford's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive

Executive summary

Appeals against planning decisions are a statutory provision within planning law. An applicant can appeal any decision (or failure to make a decision). Where an appeal is lodged the local planning authority should be prepared to make a robust defence of its decision. For most appeals this is done at officer level. Therefore, whilst there is a time cost to this there is not a cost in terms of appointing consultants to defend the decision on behalf of the Council.

For large scale appeals on complex applications there is a necessity to appoint Counsel and specialist witnesses. However, in these cases there is still the expectation that Council officers will act as the planning witness.

Where an application is refused contrary to the officer’s recommendation these tend to be more controversial. Often such overturns will be considered by either a hearing or inquiry, and this necessitates attendance in person to defend the appeals. Due to conflicts in respect of professional integrity Council officers who have recommended approval cannot professionally defend a refusal. Therefore, it is necessary to appoint external consultants to defend such appeals. There is no budget for such appointments and therefore supplementary budgets are required to secure funds to make such appointments.

This report seeks a supplementary budget for three appeals which have already been considered and to agree the funding of those. Going forward a supplementary estimate will be brought forward at the time an appeal is made to secure agreement for monies to defend the appeal. Given the status of the appeals this report does not present a range of options, however, future reports would include an option not to agree the funding which would necessitate a reconsideration as to whether the appeal should be defended.

Recommendation to Executive

1. That the Executive notes the need for a supplementary estimate for the Development Management service of £535,000 to cover the payments required to defend three significant appeals relating to Member overturn decisions which were subsequently heard at either public inquiry or as a hearing.

2. That the Executive recommends to full Council (6 December 2022) that the report be noted and that the supplementary estimate be approved.

Reason(s) for Recommendation: To ensure robust defence of planning appeals resulting from Member overturn decisions.

Is the report (or part of it) exempt from publication? No

Purpose of report

1.1The purpose of this report is to request a supplementary budget for the costs of defending recent planning appeals resulting from the overturn of a number of officer recommendations to approve. This has resulted in the need to appoint external consultants to handle the appeals as their refusals are against the professional advice of officers meaning those officers are unable to professionally represent the Council’s position at the relevant Hearings/Public Inquiries.

2. Strategic Priorities

2.1This proposal supports delivery of the following key aspects of the Council’s strategic priorities as follows:

• Revive Guildford town centre to unlock its full potential • Provide and facilitate housing that people can afford • Create employment opportunities through regeneration • Support high quality development of strategic sites

Approval of the recommendations within this report will enable the funds to be available to appoint appropriate persons to defend the Council’s position at appeal. Robust defending of appeal decisions ensures that strategic priorities are met at promoting high quality development. 3. Background

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Supplementary Estimate for funds in respect of planning appeals relating to Member overturn decisionsDecisions 94 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

6 of 9 attended
JM
Councillor Julia McShaneChairperson, present
JB
Councillor Joss BigmoreVice-Chairperson, apologies
TA
Councillor Tim AndersonCommittee Member, present
TH
Councillor Tom HuntCommittee Member, present
GP
Councillor George PotterCommittee Member, apologies
JR
Councillor John RedpathCommittee Member, present
JR
Councillor John RiggCommittee Member, present
JS
Councillor James SteelCommittee Member, present
FW
Councillor Fiona WhiteGuest, in attendance, virtual

On this subject at Guildford

Search all
  1. Supplementary Estimate for funds in respect of planning appeals relating to Member overturn decisionsThis decision
  2. Supplementary Estimate for funds in respect of potential appeal against Member overturned item and Appeal against non-determinationApproved
  3. Send Hill Disused Sandpit - Supplementary Estimate - Stage 2 (invasive) contamination surveyApproved
  4. Supplementary Estimate for funds in respect of planning appeals relating to Member overturn itemsApproved
  5. Climate Change and Energy Management - Supplementary EstimateAgreed

More from Guildford Executive

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
17 Sep 2026 MinutesThe minutes of the meeting held on 20 August 2026 were confirmed. The Leader signed the minutes. : The minutes of the... Decided Open
17 Sep 2026 Delivery Plan Progress Report 2025/26 - 2026/27To note the summary of the actions delivered from the 2025/26 Delivery Plan and the progress made in Q1 and Q2 toward... Noted Open
17 Sep 2026 Scrutiny Review of the Council’s Heritage Service and Tourist Information CentreTo develop the strategic direction within the report at Appendix 1 into a fuller strategy for the Heritage Service, i... Approved Open
17 Sep 2026 Homelessness Review DecisionsApprove the contracting out of the Council’s statutory homelessness review function under section 202 of the Housing ... Approved Open
17 Sep 2026 GBC New Build Housing Development - Hurdle RatesTo adopt the proposed hurdle rate framework for affordable housing development schemes across the Borough as an indic... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies