The Executive approved an initial supplementary budget of £350,000 to the Wisley Appeal and for the initial work to prepare for the North Street appeal. Reason(s): To enable a robust defence of the appeal against non-determination of the Wisley appeal and to do the initial work to prepare for the North Street appeal. Other options considered and rejected by the Executive: The Council could decide not to defend either appeal. The implications for doing so would potentially result in inappropriate development being delivered in the area or development that was not supported by appropriate infrastructure. This would also give the appellant strong grounds for an award of costs against the Council on the grounds of unreasonable behaviour. Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None.
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
Guildford Borough Council Report to: Executive Date: 22 June 2023 Ward(s) affected: Stoke; Send & Lovelace Report of Director: Executive Head of Planning Development Author: Claire Upton-Brown Tel: 01483 444316 Email: [email protected] Lead Councillor responsible: George Potter Tel: [phone removed] Email: [email protected] Report Status: Open
Supplementary Estimate for funds in respect of potential appeal against Member overturned item and appeal against non-determination 1. Executive Summary 1.1 Applicants can appeal against a refusal of planning permission, non- determination of a planning application, planning conditions and Enforcement Notices. Where appeals are lodged there is an expectation that the Council will robustly defend its decision. In cases of non-determination, the Council must set out what decision it would have made including reasons for refusal. Non determination appeals must be reported to Planning Committee to seek its views on the decision it would have made had it been able to determine an application.
1.2Appeals can be considered by written representation, Hearings or Public Inquiry. Matters of complexity will normally be dealt with at Public Inquiry. In the case where an officer recommendation has been overturned, the decision may be made to appoint an external planning expert to present the Council’s case. For Public Inquiries Counsel will be appointed there may also be a need for expert witnesses to be appointed.
1.3The Council currently has an appeal by Taylor Wimpey against the non-determination of the planning application relating to the redevelopment of Wisley Airfield. The Council has also been advised that an appeal will be lodged against the refusal of the North Street application. It is understood that the appeal will be lodged at the end of June and will be dealt with by Public Inquiry with a likely date in early 2024. A revised planning application will be submitted at the end of June. If permission is forthcoming for the revised scheme, the applicants have suggested that the appeal would be withdrawn. Work will need to start on the appeal as soon as the start date is confirmed by the Planning Inspectorate. Therefore, there is a need to fund elements of this work, for example Counsel will need to be appointed to advise the Council as it progresses.
1.4This report seeks supplementary budget for the Wisley appeal and for the North Street appeal. As the Planning Committee is yet to consider the appeal application and there are still some outstanding consultation responses it cannot be confirmed the case the Council will be defending or the expert witnesses that may need to be appointed. There is also a suggestion on the North Street refusal that the appellants will seek to substitute some of the submitted plans which will address some of the reasons for refusal. However, at this stage there is no certainty around this matter.
2. Recommendation to Executive 2.1 That the Executive approves an initial supplementary budget of £350,000 to the Wisley Appeal and for the initial work to prepare for the North Street appeal. 3. Reason for Recommendation: 3.1. To enable a robust defence of the appeal against non-determination of the Wisley appeal and to do the initial work to prepare for the North Street appeal.
4. Exemption from publication 4.1. None.
5. Purpose of Report 5.1 The purpose of the report is to seek supplementary budget for the cost of defending the Wisley appeal against non-determination and the North Street appeal. This will result in the appointment of Counsel in both cases together with the appointment of some external consultants. In the case of Wisley, officers will represent the Council as expert planning witnesses. It is likely that an external planning witness will be needed for North Street as there is insufficient internal capacity to deal with the revised application and prepare for the appeal.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.