The Executive approved the grant of a new 5-year lease at less than best consideration to Yvonne Arnaud Management Limited at Old Town Mill. Reason(s): To support Yvonne Arnaud Management Limited. Other options considered and rejected by the Executive: 1. Terminate the Tenancy at Will with immediate effect. This option did not give YAM Ltd. sufficient time to vacate the property and find suitable alternative accommodation to relocate the facility. The Council would acquire a financial liability because the loss of rent would impact the revenue budget and the works required to prepare the building for reletting would impact the capital budget. 2. Propose a lease to YAM Ltd.at the full market rent of £65,000 per annum. This option exceeded their maximum affordability and restricted their ability to operate the building. As above, the tenant would have to vacate the property and the Council would acquire a financial liability. Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None.
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
Guildford Borough Council Report to: Executive Date: 22 June 2023 Ward(s) affected: Castle Report of Director: Joint Strategic Director - Place Author: Mark Appleton – Asset & Property Manager Tel: 01483 444364 Email: [email protected] Lead Councillor responsible: Richard Lucas Tel: [phone removed] Email: [email protected] Report Status: Open
Granting a lease at less than best consideration to Yvonne Arnaud Management Limited at Old Town Mill 1. Executive Summary 1.1. The Council wishes to grant a new lease to the Yvonne Arnaud Management (YAM) whose financial accounts have been reviewed and their level of affordability exceeds the maximum discount of the estimated annual market rental value that can be approved under officer delegation. Officers are therefore seeking approval from the Executive to grant a new lease to YAM for a term of 5 years at less than best consideration.
2. Recommendation to Executive 2.1. That the Executive approves the grant of a new 5-year lease at less than best consideration to Yvonne Arnaud Management at Old Town Mill. 3. Reason(s) for Recommendation: 3.1. To support Yvonne Arnaud Management Limited.
4. Exemption from publication 4.1. None.
5. Purpose of Report 5.1. To seek approval from the Executive to grant a new lease for a term of 5 years at less than best consideration to Yvonne Arnaud Management Limited (YAM).
6. Strategic Priorities 6.1. In addition to the theatre offering, the studio space within the Old Town Mill supports the Creative Learning Programme which supports disenfranchised and low social economic groups across the borough. The Programme provides targeted activities that specifically engage with those who have limited opportunities to access the Arts. This includes families, children and young people who have a low household income or low socio-economic status; young carers; the unemployed; and adults who may be at risk of harm or social isolation. YAM prioritise groups from the Bellfields & Slyfield and Westborough wards.
6.2Further to theatre performances and their Creative Learning Programme, YAM supports local artist communities. The studio space has accommodated Guildford Arts Summer Exhibition, The Man In the Moon Youth Theatre, Stop Gap Dance, Rare Youth Theatre Productions, and YMCA ‘Downslink’ drama group.
6.3If the Council were to grant a lease to YAM, they would be able to continue their cultural and social activities which seek to help vulnerable residents and tackle inequality in Guildford’s communities thereby directly supporting the Council’s strategic priorities. YAM has provided additional information appended to this report which sets out the charity’s community initiatives and activities.
7. Background 7.1. YAM previously benefitted from a 50% subsidy of the annual market rental value, paying a rent of £22,750 per annum under the former lease which expired in December 2022. The tenant has since been in occupation of the subject property under a Tenancy at Will whilst terms for a new lease are agreed. From a legal perspective, the tenant cannot remain in occupation of the property indefinitely on the current Tenancy at Will and would therefore need to either enter a new lease at an agreed rent or vacate the premises.
7.2The Council recently obtained an independent valuation of the Old Town Mill which indicated an estimated market rental value of £65,000 per annum. YAM’s previous three years’ audited accounts were reviewed together with their business plan and forecast projections which indicate a maximum affordability of £22,750 per annum which remains unchanged since the Council granted the previous lease in 2012. The Council began a phased reduction in grant funding from 2021/22 to 2024/25 and despite efforts to restructure their finances, YAM has been unable to absorb the shortfall due to an increase in costs to operate the building and the lasting impact of Covid-19 on the Performing Arts sector.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.