AI summaryGuildford Borough Council Executive notes community feedback on The Electric Theatre and commits to exploring its future as an arts venue, subject to independent viability assessment. Lost rental income of £145k per year noted.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeNotedCommitted to exploring future as arts venue
Money£145k per annum lost rentPrevious tenant ACM Commercial Ltd rent
What happens nextAppoint specialist consultantTo test viability and operating models
Who it affectsTheatre users and community groupsFuture of Guildford arts venue
What was decided
The Executive noted the insights and feedback from the community survey and stakeholder roundtable held on 17 January 2026. Report 2.1, 6.10, 6.11
The Executive recognised the theatre's importance as an arts, culture and performance venue in Guildford and committed to exploring options for its future use with community access. Report 2.2, 2.3, 11.2
Any future use as a community arts venue is subject to an independent viability assessment and market engagement confirming sustainable delivery. Report 2.3, 3.2, 6.19
Why
The theatre has been vacant since the previous tenant, ACM Commercial Ltd, went into administration in May 2025 and the lease was surrendered in August 2025. Report 1.1, 6.4
Community engagement showed clear agreement that the theatre should continue as an arts and cultural venue with community access, balanced with financial sustainability. Report 6.14, 6.15, 6.18
The Council must meet its Best Value duty and cannot provide ongoing financial support, so independent expert advice is needed to test viability. Report 1.5, 3.2, 6.17, 6.23
What happens next
Complete outstanding building surveys and identify required remedial works to bring the building back into a tenantable condition. Report P16, 6.6, 6.7, 6.8
Carry out a phase 1 assessment to determine whether a community focused arts venue is viable compared with alternatives such as open market letting or sale. Report P17, 6.20, 6.21
If viable, proceed to phase 2 early market engagement to test operating models, then return to the Executive with a recommended route to market. Report P18, 6.22, 6.25
The money
£145k per annum Previous rental income from ACM Commercial Ltd, budgeted by the Council but no longer realised Report 6.3, 6.5
50% Minimum community use (by programme time) committed by ACM under the 2017 lease Report 6.3
Options considered
Chosen: Option 1 (recommended): Recognise the theatre's importance and commit to exploring options for its future use as an arts and performance venue with community access, subject to viability assessment.. Provides clear policy direction, aligns with engagement findings, and supports strategic priorities while ensuring Best Value. Report 11.2, 11.4
Rejected: Option 2 (not recommended): Consider alternative options or potential uses for the building beyond an arts and performance venue. Report 11.3
Implications
Financial: Loss of £145k per annum budgeted rental income; Council now bears business rates, utility costs, insurance, security and maintenance for the vacant building. Report 6.5, 10.1
Financial: Stage 1 review by external consultant will be met from existing budgets; no further financial implications anticipated at this stage.
Legal: Council's legal team informally engaged and will continue involvement to ensure actions and decisions are robust and legally compliant.
Equalities: No equality and diversity implications arising directly from this report. Report 12.3
Climate: No climate change or sustainability implications identified. Report 12.4
Risk: Viability assessment will extend the period the theatre remains without an end user, during which the Council bears ongoing holding costs. Report 10.1
Risk: Local Government Reorganisation and a likely Section 24 direction may require additional approval from a new shadow authority after May 2026 elections, creating delay and uncertainty. Report 8.1, 10.3
Other: The building is registered as an Asset of Community Value, with the current listing set to remain in place until early 2031. Report 6.2
Who and where
Residents and community arts groups in Guildford, including youth theatre and amateur productions Report 6.14
Local arts, culture and performance organisations and stakeholders who attended the 17 January 2026 roundtable Report 6.10, 6.11
Guildford Amateur Theatre Association (GATA), which supported the original 1997 conversion and applied to renew the Asset of Community Value listing Report 6.1, 6.2
The Council as freeholder and ratepayer, now bearing holding costs on the vacant building Report 6.2, 6.5
Timeline
1997: Building converted into a theatre and performing arts space with support from GATA Report 6.1
2017: Theatre let to ACM Commercial Ltd following a procurement exercise Report 6.3
May 2025: ACM went into administration and RSM appointed as administrators Report 6.4
11 August 2025: Lease informally surrendered to the Council by RSM Report 6.4
17 January 2026: Stakeholder roundtable held to discuss the theatre's future Report 6.10
Early 2031: Current Asset of Community Value listing due to expire Report 6.2
After May 2026 elections: Shadow authority may need to give additional approval to any future route-to-market recommendations, depending on Local Government Reorganisation Report 8.1, 10.3
Plain English for the jargon
Best Value duty: Legal duty on local authorities to ensure continuous improvement in the way services are delivered, with regard to economy, efficiency and effectiveness.
Asset of Community Value (AoCV): A building or piece of land listed by the local authority whose use furthers the social well-being or cultural interests of the local community, giving community groups the right to bid if it is sold.
Local Government Reorganisation (LGR): Planned restructuring of local government, which in this area may create a new West Surrey shadow authority following May 2026 elections.
Section 24 direction: A direction expected from the Secretary of State in connection with Local Government Reorganisation, which may affect the Council's decision-making powers over this asset.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemEX130
Resolved
To note the insights and feedback shared by residents and stakeholders through the community survey and roundtable discussion, as set out in Appendices 1 and 2 to this report. 2. To recognise the importance of The Electric Theatre to Guildford and its value as an arts, culture and performance venue in the town. 3. To commit to exploring options for the Theatre’s future use as an arts and performance venue with community access, subject to independent viability assessment and any future market engagement confirming that this can be delivered sustainably. Reason(s): 1. To update the Executive on the situation concerning The Electric Theatre and proposed next steps. 2. To guide next steps for determining the future of The Electric Theatre, subject to viability work ensuring the Council meets its Best Value duty. Other options considered and rejected by the Executive: Option 2 (not recommended): In noting the outcomes of the engagement process, the Executive can choose to consider alternative options or potential uses for the building. Details of any conflict of interest declared by the Leader or lead councillors and any dispensation granted: None.
Word for word from the decision Guildford published for this meeting.Source: democracy.guildford.gov.uk
1.1The Electric Theatre is a Council owned community arts venue situated in Guildford town centre, and has a long history of hosting music, theatre and cultural events. The theatre was leased out to ACM Commercial Ltd until they went into administration in May 2025, with the lease being surrendered to the Council in August 2025. The venue is now vacant.
1.2Various surveys have been commissioned to understand the extent of the repair and maintenance required (and indicative costs thereof) before the property can be re-occupied. To date, an external condition survey has been undertaken with further surveys programmed once clearance of the building has been completed.
1.3The theatre’s closure sparked a strong community reaction. In recognition of its community value and importance, the Council committed to engaging with residents and stakeholders to help define a viable future for the theatre. Engagement activities have included a survey, pop-up events and a stakeholder roundtable.
1.4This report summarises the engagement activities carried out to date and outlines the recommended next steps for the Executive’s consideration.
1.5To move this work forward, it is recommended that external expert advice be sought to support the Council with the next steps on the future of the building. This advice will help validate whether a model for ongoing community use is viable and how this might work in practice, particularly given the Council’s financial constraints and inability to provide ongoing financial support. The advice will also support the Council with selecting a viable way forward for the theatre, which may include procurement of an operator, a lease or a disposal.
Recommendations
That the Executive resolve to:
2.1Note the insights and feedback shared by residents and stakeholders through the community survey and
2 The Electric Theatre – Engagement and Next Steps
roundtable discussion, as set out in Appendices 1 and 2 to this report.
2.2Recognise the importance of The Electric Theatre to Guildford and its value as an arts, culture and performance venue in the town.
2.3Commit to exploring options for the Theatre’s future use as an arts and performance venue with community access, subject to independent viability assessment and any future market engagement confirming that this can be delivered sustainably.
Reasons for recommendation
3.1To update the Executive on the situation concerning The Electric Theatre and proposed next steps.
3.2To guide next steps for determining the future of The Electric Theatre, subject to viability work ensuring the Council meets its Best Value duty.
4 Next steps
4.1The proposed next steps as set out in greater detail later in this report are:
▪ To complete outstanding building surveys and identify required remedial works.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.