RESOLVED To approve the appointment of Contractor C to deliver refurbishment and enhancement works to Hornsey Library for a contract sum of £2,300,370; and 3.2. To approve the issue of a letter of intent prior to the formal contract signature for £230,037 being 10% of the contract sum Reasons for decision To award a contract which will enable the timely mobilisation and construction of works to Hornsey Library. Alternative options considered The authority procured the contractor through the London Construction Programme (LCP) Major Works 2014 Framework Agreement. The authority considered use of the Southern Construction Framework for award of this contract. Upon consideration, the SCF framework was considered not suitable for this size of project.
Word for word from the decision Haringey published for this meeting.Source: www.minutes.haringey.gov.uk
3.1To approve the appointment of Contractor C to deliver refurbishment and enhancement works to Hornsey Library for a contract sum of £2,300,370; and
3.2To approve the issue of a letter of intent prior to the formal contract signature for £230,037 being 10% of the contract sum
Reasons for decision
Page 1 of 6 4.1. To award a contract which will enable the timely mobilisation and construction of works to Hornsey Library.
Alternative options considered
5.1The authority procured the contractor through the London Construction Programme (LCP) Major Works 2014 Framework Agreement. The authority considered use of the Southern Construction Framework for award of this contract. Upon consideration, the SCF framework was considered not suitable for this size of project.
6. Background information
6.1The works have been designed to Stage 4 of the Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA) Plan of Work 2013.
6.2The project was tendered using a lump sum single stage Traditional method of procurement. Other methods of procurement considered included single stage Design and Build, two stage Design and Build and two stage Traditional.
6.3A list of eight companies was generated using Lot 5 of The London Construction Programme (LCP) Major Works 2014 Framework Agreement, and, following an Expression of Interest Exercise, four were invited to submit a proposal in response to an Invitation to Tender. Four responses were received and evaluated.
6.4During the evaluation process, post tender clarifications were sought and fully responded to.
6.5The tender was based on a 60 % quality and 40 % price bid and contract period of 7 months.
6.6A quality assessment was conducted by an Evaluation Panel, comprising the Project Delivery Team Project Manager, Hornsey Library Delivery Manager, Principal Designer, Mechanical & electrical engineering consultant and the Lead Design Consultant. A pre agreed list of questions relevant to this project was included in the tender as part of the Qualitative Delivery Proposals (QDP). Each question was offered a score between 0 (for question not answered) to 5 (excellent) together with a weighted score.
6.7The outcome of the quality and price scores is shown below.
6.7.1. Contractor A scored a total of 82.87% comprising a score of 45.60% for quality and 37.27% for price.
6.7.2. Contractor B scored a total of 85.60% comprising a score of 45.60% for quality and 40.00%for price.
6.7.3. Contractor C scored a total of 99.59% comprising a score of 60.00% for quality and 39.59% for price.
Page 2 of 6 6.7.4. Contractor D scored a total of 94.74% comprising a score of 56.40% for quality and 38.34% for price.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.