Resolved
That this Council calls upon the Mayor of London to listen closely to the returns he receives in respect of the consultation exercise on the proposed extension of the ULEZ to include the outer London Boroughs. Whilst this Council is fully committed to decarbonisation by 2030 and have already taken many steps to reduce our carbon footprint, we are very aware that the introduction of a ULEZ scheme here would have a severely negative effect on both our residents, the businesses situated here and the staff of our partner organisations such as the NHS. This Council asks the Mayor of London to understand that in Hillingdon, residents and businesses alike do not have the ready option of a good public transport alternative to using their cars and that distances are too great to make walking or cycling a sensible option for most. This scheme, if implemented, would be a crippling daily tax on our poorest residents and working population, adding to the already increased costs they have with high fuel prices. 8.2 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR CURLING Councillor Curling moved, and Councillor Mathers seconded, the following motion : “That this Council recognises the concerns raised by both local businesses and residents since the changes in the ‘stop and shop’ scheme came into force, which mean that it is now more difficult for residents, particularly the elderly and vulnerable, to get the 30 minutes free pay and display ticket, and completely removes the incentive for non-residents to ‘stop and shop’, and thereby has a negative impact on the borough’s local businesses and residents. “This Council therefore calls on the Cabinet Member for Resident’s Services and the Older Persons Champion, to engage with residents’ groups, local business forums and elderly people’s groups, to consider alternatives to this change and consult on the future of the ‘stop and shop’ schemes.” Speaking in favour of the motion, Members suggested that the Council needed to enhance the local economy by encouraging people from far and wide to shop in Hillingdon. Requests for ‘Stop and Shop’ schemes had proven very popular but the new pay and display machines had become temperamental and more complicated to use as non-residents were not eligible for 30 minutes free parking so residents were now unable to just press one button for a free 30 minute ticket. This had led to some residents giving up and leaving. It was stated that individuals had less money to spend and that a reinstatement of the 30 minutes free parking for non residents would help the high street to thrive. Many of the business owners were also residents in the Borough. Charging non residents for their first 30 minutes of parking could negatively impact footfall and it was stated that this issue had been raised during a Select Committee meeting. It was important to listen to residents’ concerns and make their lives less complicated as it was now taking longer to get a free 30 minute parking ticket than it took to buy a pint of milk. Members speaking against the motion stated that changes had been made to the eligibility for free 30 minutes of parking in Stop and Shop areas to take the cost burden away from Hillingdon residents. Although the proposal had been included in public reports in December 2021 and January 2022, there had been no opposition raised at that time. It was anticipated that parking charges would raise £690k (£472k from on street parking and £118k from off street parking) and that the situation would be reviewed after 6-12 months alongside any evidence gathered. It was thought important to provide residents with quality goods and services that were readily accessible, but there was a balance between finances and putting residents first and difficult decisions needed to be made. The ability to pay for parking by phone would be introduced and preferential parking rates for residents would be retained. If the machines were not working, this should be reported to the Council. The motion was put to the vote and lost. 8.3 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR NELSON Councillor Nelson moved, and Councillor Dhot seconded, the following motion: “That this Council recognises Black History Month and its importance and significance to the vibrant cultural diversity of this Borough.” Speaking in support of the motion, Members stated that Black History Month was recognised by many other councils and asked that it be recognised in Hillingdon. Just because there was less crime in the UK than there was in the USA was not a reason to ignore Black History Month. Black History Month had been acknowledged by Boris Johnson and the royal family so it was suggested that the administration needed to put residents first so that the black community could celebrate its history. Black History Month and the newly unveiled Windrush Statue celebrated the Windrush generation. The black community had suffered in the past and had faced unemployment and discrimination because of their identity. Black History Month had been deemed important in the calendar of many communities but black history was not limited to a specific month. Black history brought a rich cultural heritage which came with pain and sacrifice. It was part of British history. The recognition of Black History Month would provide an opportunity to break down racial barriers and would have a positive impact that brought value to the community. Opposition Members felt that it was a shame that the administration did not understand the importance of Black History Month to the community and that calls from residents to celebrate their history continued to be ignored. The Leader of the Council stated that the Council rejected all forms of discrimination and that the Council’s policy had been to celebrate throughout the year rather than promoting one group over another during a specific period. To this end, a range of events had taken place throughout the year to celebrate cultural heritage including a poetry event and a panel discussion. The motion was put to a recorded vote: Those voting for: Councillors Abby, Basit, Burles, Curling, Dhot , Farley, Gardner, Garelick, Garg, Islam, Judge Dhot , Kaur, Lakhmana , Mand, Mathers, Nelson, Nelson-West, Punja, Sansarpuri , Singh and Sweeting. Those voting against: The Mayor (Councillor Haggar), the Deputy Mayor (Councillor Ahmad- Wallana ), Councillors Banerjee, Bennett, Bhatt, Bianco, Bridges, Reeta Chamdal, Roy Chamdal, Chapman, Choubedar, Corthorne , Davies, Denys, Edwards, Goddard, Gohil, Higgins, Lavery, Lewis, Makwana, D Mills, R Mills, O’Brien, Palmer, Riley, Smallwood, Sullivan and Tuckwell. Those abstaining: None. The motion was lost. Recorded Vote Title Type Recorded Vote text Result 8.3 Motion from Councillor Nelson Motion Rejected View Recorded Vote for this item