Resolved
That this Council opposes the Mayor of London's decision to expand the ULEZ restrictions to outer London as it is wrong on several fronts, not least that it fails to put our residents first and will most adversely impact those on low incomes, at a time when they can least cope with additional expenditure, by being unfairly taxed in the use of their own vehicles and in going about their normal daily business. This Council therefore requests Cabinet to formalise a plan of action to implement this policy of opposition to the ULEZ decision and to establish an appropriate budget to do so. The authority to spend against this budget to be granted to the Leader in consultation with appropriate Cabinet Members. 9.1 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR CURLING Councillor Curling moved, and Councillor Mathers seconded, the following motion: That this Council notes the adverse impact that tax avoidance has on the public purse, and thereby the damaging effect that it has on the services that we can provide for the residents of Hillingdon. This Council also notes that a significant element of such tax avoidance is that of “Corporate tax avoidance”. This Council believes that, as recipients of significant public funding, local authorities, such as Hillingdon, should take the lead in the promotion of exemplary tax conduct. However, we also recognise that UK procurement law restricts councils’ ability to either penalise poor tax conduct, or reward good tax conduct, when buying goods or services. This Council therefore requests the Finance and Corporate Services Select Committee to consider conducting a review into how we can ensure that Hillingdon is a Fair Tax borough. Those speaking in support of the motion believed that, since 2013, tax avoidance had been a public concern and it was suggested that a company’s ethics should be considered by the Council when awarding contracts. Significant losses had been created through multinational tax sharing arrangements which was one form of tax avoidance so it was important to promote a fair tax ethos. Although UK procurement laws prevented organisations from rewarding or penalising tax conduct, it was important that taxpayers’ money was used wisely. The motion had fairness at its heart and sought to address the unfairness and greed around some company practices. It was suggested that being complicit with these companies avoiding tax could put Council services at risk and an in depth Select Committee review would be an ideal way to explore all of the issues. Those speaking against the motion stated that the idea of a fair share of taxation was subjective and questioned how good tax conduct could be identified. Tax avoidance was legal, whereas tax evasion was not, so Members queried why they should challenge a company if HMRC was satisfied. Only contracting with those organisations that had signed up to the Fair Tax Foundation would prove restrictive and tax diligence was not useable in contracts. This issue had not been raised at the recent Finance and Corporate Services Select Committee meetings during Member discussions about procurement. The motion was put to the vote and lost. 9.2 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR FARLEY Councillor Farley moved, and Councillor Punja seconded the following motion: That this Council, as part of Hillingdon Council’s strategy of creating a green and sustainable borough, requests the Cabinet to conduct feasibility studies into the use of further innovative technological solutions as additional ways to reduce London Borough of Hillingdon’s carbon footprint and improve air quality, such as city trees, aquamation and water reclamation, to complement existing schemes. Those speaking in support of the motion noted that Heathrow airport had had an impact on air quality in the Borough and that City trees could be used to mitigate pollution as they absorbed more than regular trees and took up less space. Hillingdon had the second worst air quality in London. Pollution, and the impact of pollution, had been increasing. In November 2022, the London Ambulance Service and Hillingdon Hospital had reported an increase in the number of respiratory related attendances at A&E. With more residents working from home, and therefore using local town centres more, it would be important to consider opportunities to improve air quality in town centre regeneration initiatives. The Council needed to explore options. Those speaking against the motion understood the intent of the motion but it did not take account of the Council’s Climate Change Action Plan, Carbon Offset Strategy, Air Quality Action Plan, etc. Air quality screening had already been put in place around many of the schools across the Borough and sustainable urban drainage initiatives had been undertaken. Surveys would be undertaken in February on the Council’s top 20 energy use buildings and an update on climate change had been scheduled for consideration at the Residents’ Services Select Committee on 8 February 2023. The motion was put to the vote and lost. <caption