Resolved
That this Council notes that, on 2 November 2017, it resolved to request the Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, to reconsider his plan to close Uxbridge Police station and sell off the site. Council further notes that the minutes of that meeting show Labour Councillors chose not to support the motion. Despite this, discussions were held with MOPAC to try and avoid the closure, but Mayor Khan refused to change his decision to close the Uxbridge Police station. The appointment of a new Metropolitan Police Commissioner has brought about renewed discussions, including with the Leader of the Council and an undertaking of a fresh review of the Police estate. That, consequently, Council now instructs the Leader of the Council to intensify discussions with the Borough Superintendent and members of the Metropolitan Police senior leadership, with the intention of maintaining Uxbridge Police station as a permanent operational base for local policing and the wider geographical area. In addition, this Council rebukes the Mayor of London who is responsible for the policing of London, for failing to listen to or engage with the residents of Hillingdon over the past 6 years since we have been campaigning on this. Noting his dramatic U-turn recently in desperation and panic; he is now looking to go against his own decision of closing this local facility in a political gimmick that will not land with local residents , who know who has been standing up for them since 2017. 7.2 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR SWEETING Councillor Sweeting moved, and Councillor Mand seconded, the following motion: That this Council recognises the vital role and responsibility local authorities have in supporting the attainment and improvement of their schools. This Council is, therefore, concerned at the fall in some standards as detailed in the Annual Standards Report 2021/22. Therefore, this Council calls on the administration to review urgently its approach in supporting our schools. Those speaking in support of the motion noted that everyone wanted what was best for the Borough's children and that schools had been doing what they could since the pandemic. This motion was not about criticising the work that teachers had been doing but was about identifying what else could be done to improve the situation. Although the Borough had borne well against national outcomes for primary key stages, there had been a drop in achievement when comparing to statistical neighbours. These had been worrying results that had been glossed over and blamed on the pandemic despite the pandemic affecting everyone and Hillingdon having been consistently at the bottom even before Covid. The pandemic should not be used as an excuse for poor performance and the Council needed to do better in helping schools to improve their results. Consideration needed to be given to the action that other London boroughs had taken that had helped them to improve, identify what Hillingdon had been doing to support schools in the Borough and produce a levelling up action plan to improve performance. Those speaking against the motion noted that the School Improvement Team had been continuously working with schools. However, there had been some performance issues in relation to Key Stage 5 in 2021/22, with Covid disproportionately affecting children in Hillingdon. As such, it was important that comparisons were not made with previous years. Priorities for the next academic year had been set and training and support had been offered to schools. Work had also been undertaken with the SEND and social care teams along with the provision of advice, guidance and signposting. Councillor O’Brien moved, and Councillor Haggar seconded, an amendment to the motion to the effect that it would read as follows: That this Council recognises the vital role and responsibility local authorities have in supporting the attainment and improvement of all schools within their geographical area. This Council is aware that there has been a dip in a small number of outcomes as detailed within the Annual Standards Report 2021/22 following the impact of the COVID pandemic, a trend that has been recorded across the country. Council also notes that it has been recognised nationally that 2021/22 data cannot be used to give an accurate indication of performance compared to other years, because of the disruption brought about by the pandemic. This Council will continue to review and work closely with all educational settings in targeting support appropriately. Those speaking against the amendment noted that there were schools in the Borough had been deemed inadequate in all areas. Despite the hard work that had been undertaken, schools in Hillingdon still fell behind statistical neighbours that had struggled with the same issues. As such, Covid should not be blamed for this poor performance and action should be taken so that the Council stopped letting these children down. Those speaking in support of the amendment advised that HM Majesty's Inspectors had stated that 2021/22 data should be seen as incomplete. It had been recognised that there had been an increase in the number of children with SEN and action was being taken to meet these needs. This had been the subject of a Council Select Committee review and was an issue that could be reviewed again. The amendment was put to the vote and agreed. The substantive motion was then put to the vote and it was: That this Council recognises the vital role and responsibility local authorities have in supporting the attainment and improvement of all schools within their geographical area. This Council is aware that there has been a dip in a small number of outcomes as detailed within the Annual Standards Report 2021/22 following the impact of the COVID pandemic, a trend that has been recorded across the country. Council also notes that it has been recognised nationally that 2021/22 data cannot be used to give an accurate indication of performance compared to other years, because of the disruption brought about by the pandemic. This Council will continue to review and work closely with all educational settings in targeting support appropriately. 7.3 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR MATHERS Councillor Mathers moved, and Councillor Abby seconded, the following motion: That t his Council affirms our commitment to free weekly bin collections and thanks our Council staff for their dedication to their work. However, this Council recognises that, since the refuse collection routes have been changed, there has been a noticeable difference across the borough in the amount of litter and burst bin bags around the time of collection day. Therefore, this Council calls on the administration to take action for a more synchronised approach to services that keeps our streets clean and restores a sense of pride in our communities. Those speaking in support of the motion noted that, on collection days, rubbish was regularly strewn across the streets and was a blight on the Borough. The refuse team worked hard and Members were grateful for the job that they did but consideration needed to be given to making rubbish collection even easier for residents to prevent rubbish from being blown into their neighbours gardens. It was suggested that there needed to be better synchronisation between refuse collection and street cleaning and litter picks and grass cutting. Action also needed to be taken to address the confusion caused by changes to collection days around bank holidays. Concern was expressed about the Council's lacklustre approach to enforcement, particularly in HMOs, and about how some residents had received fines for trying to help by collecting their rubbish in single big piles. Those speaking against the motion did not recognise the picture that had been painted by the opposition as the majority of litter had been picked up before it had been reported. New properties had been added to routes and a communications campaign had been undertaken to deal with missed collections. The street cleaning team visited roads the day after their bin collection day and the food waste collection service had been offered to more households (767 properties had been approached which had increased participation in the food waste collection scheme). Councillor Lavery moved, and Councillor D Mills seconded, an amendment to the motion to the effect that it would read as follows: That t his Council affirms our commitment to free weekly bin collections, including recycling and green waste collections and thanks our Council staff for their dedication to their work. Council reaffirms that it rejects the idea of charging residents for the collection of garden waste and is concerned that Labour's Camden candidate in the Uxbridge and South Ruislip parliamentary by-election, who is currently a Cabinet Member at the London Borough of Camden has already supported policies that have introduced an annual £75 charge for this service in that borough. Council further recognises that it needs to continue to monitor litter and burst bin bags around the time of collection and notes action that our street cleaning team have already taken to ensure a more synchronised approach to services, ensuring our streets remain clean, continuing to promote a sense of pride in our communities all across the borough. Those speaking in support of the amendment noted that the original motion had had made reference to refuse collection but had made no reference to the other types of waste collected. Hillingdon provided a complete service with weekly collections that included green waste. Concern was expressed that inappropriate inner London solutions, such as those used in Camden, were being proposed for an outer London borough. A coordinated approach had been put in place to deal with the challenges of clearing litter after the refuse collection day and, as a result, there had not been a large number of MEs on the issue. Those speaking against the amendment stated that the Council Chamber was being used for electioneering and that MPs did not set policy for refuse collection. The intent of the original motion had been that it referred to all types of waste collected by the Council. Insofar as MEs were concerned, it was suggested that the new GOSS system for reporting had been challenging and therefore prevented many Members from reporting many instances in their wards. A future Labour administration would commit to the continuation of weekly waste collections. The amendment was put to the vote and agreed. Councillor Curling moved, and Councillor Punja seconded, a further amendment to the substantive motion to the effect that it would read as follows: That t his Council affirms our commitment to free weekly bin collections , including recycling and green waste collections and thanks our Council staff for their dedication to their work. Council reaffirms that it rejects the idea of charging residents for the collection of garden waste. Council further recognises that it needs to continue to monitor litter and burst bin bags around the time of collection and notes action that our street cleaning team have already taken to ensure a more synchronised approach to services, ensuring our streets remain clean, continuing to promote a sense of pride in our communities all across the borough. Those in favour of the amendment noted that residents did not want to pay more for their weekly bin collection and rejected the idea of paying for garden waste collections. As it was not appropriate to vote on what Camden had or had not done, the amendment sought to delete reference to that borough and the upcoming election. The amendment was put to a recorded vote: Those voting for: Councillors Abby, Basit, Burles, Curling, Farley, Gardner, Garelick, Islam, Kaur, Lakhmana , Mand, Mathers, Money, Nelson, Nelson-West, Punja, Sansarpuri and Sweeting. Those voting against: The Mayor (Councillor Ahmad- Wallana ), the Deputy Mayor (Councillor Sullivan), Councillors Banerjee, Bhatt, Bianco, Bridges, Reeta Chamdal, Roy Chamdal, Choubedar, Corthorne , Davies, Denys, Edwards, Goddard, Gohil, Haggar, Higgins, Lavery, Lewis, D Mills, R Mills, O’Brien, Palmer, Riley, Smallwood and Tuckwell. Those abstaining: None. The amendment was lost and the substantive motion was put to the vote and it was: That this Council affirms our commitment to free weekly bin collections including recycling and green waste collections and thanks our Council staff for their dedication to their work. Council reaffirms that it rejects the idea of charging residents for the collection of garden waste and is concerned that Labour's Camden candidate in the Uxbridge and South Ruislip parliamentary by-election, who is currently a Cabinet Member at the London Borough of Camden has already supported policies that have introduced an annual £75 charge for this service in that borough. Council further recognises that it needs to continue to monitor litter and burst bin bags around the time of collection and notes action that our street cleaning team have already taken to ensure a more synchronised approach to services, ensuring our streets remain clean, continuing to promote a sense of pride in our communities all across the borough. 7.4 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR PUNJA Councillor Punja moved, and Councillor Gardner seconded, the following motion: That t his Council recognises the detrimental impact that poor housing standards can have on residents’ well-being and calls on the Cabinet to carry out an immediate review of its current strategies relating to housing to assess the impact on residents’ well-being and to develop a plan to improve the detrimental impact of poor housing on residents’ well-being. Those speaking in support of the motion noted that it was no secret that Hillingdon housing was in crisis and that there was not sufficient housing for residents in need. The cost of building new properties had increased and took time. Consideration needed to be given to housing standards to make existing properties fit for purpose as inadequate housing contributed to poor health conditions, which was exacerbated by poor quality repairs and long waiting times. Residents had been let down by the Council and by Locata and had been unable to speak to a person when calling. Some families were living in cramped and overcrowded conditions which compounded their health conditions but which were still not serious enough to improve their standing on Locata . Concern was expressed that officers had regularly not been responding to enquiries about housing cases which were increasing in seriousness and which could impact on residents' mental health. This was exacerbated by the fact that many residents did not speak English as their first language which caused additional confusion. It was suggested that staff received addition training on how to deliver messages sensitively as each situation and case needed to be handled differently. Housing issues were regularly raised in ward surgeries and residents were sometimes being blamed for the poor conditions that they were living in despite them not doing anything that they shouldn't be doing. Pressure needed to be put on landlords to fix issues that their tenants raised to make them habitable and it was suggested that the Housing Strategy be reviewed. Those speaking against the motion recognised the detrimental impact that poor housing could have on residents' mental wellbeing. Staff tried their best but were required to apply standard criteria across the board. The Housing Strategy had recognised the importance of health and the Council had been making improvements to its housing stock with new roofs, kitchen and bathrooms, etc. Concerns about damp and mould were also being tracked and dealt with but it was recognised that poor ventilation could be exacerbated by efficient new windows. It was noted that the Council was the landlord of approximately 10k properties. £70m of investment had been made in the housing stock in relation to boiler replacement, windows, roofs, sprinkler systems, etc. Approximately 3k repairs were undertaken in the Council's housing stock each month and, although it was thought that the authority was doing well, it was recognised that it could still do better. The motion was put to the vote and lost.