Recommendations of the Overview & Scrutiny Committee and the Executive approved, subject to the following addition: That, in future, all decisions made by the Council Meeting in Committee or Borough Council may only be amended if brought back to future meetings of the Council Meeting in Committee or Borough Council.
Word for word from the decision Hounslow published for this meeting.Source: democraticservices.hounslow.gov.uk
At its meetings of 27 January and 20 February 2003 committee members considered the findings of KPMG’s review into the work of the Westlift Scrutiny Panel. At its meeting of 20 February, members requested that a commentary from the Overview and Scrutiny Committee accompany the review and be presented to the Executive and full Council at the earliest opportunity. This report outlines the concerns of the Committee regarding the process that commissioned this review from KPMG (the Council’s external auditors) on the work of the Westlift Scrutiny Panel. It also responds to the issues and recommendations contained in KPMG’s review.
Recommendations
1.1Members of the Executive are asked to consider the issues highlighted in section 2 and in particular 2.5 and note Scrutiny’s response to the KPMG Review in section 3.
1.2That this report together with the KPMG review are forwarded to full Council for its consideration at the earliest opportunity.
Background
2.1The Westlift Scrutiny Panel was established in February 2001 at the request of the Council to:
• Consider what measures should be taken to assist the Council to achieve closure on the Westlift project;
• Identify, explore and comment on why the Council become involved in the project;
COM-FS • Explore where and how problems occurred and to comment on the action taken to resolve them; and
• Identify lessons to be learnt for the future.
2.2The Panel concluded its work in July 2001 and presented its report to the Executive, then Committee of the Council on 9 October 2001. A full and lengthy debate took place at Committee of the Council on the report and its recommendations. Committee of the Council agreed the report and its recommendations alongside the Executive’s response to the report. The Executive’s response strengthened some of Scrutiny’s recommendations. These were welcomed and accepted by Scrutiny and full Council.
2.3One such recommendation that was strengthened was Recommendation 4 of the scrutiny report. The Executive response stated:
The Executive, whilst understanding that the Council’s external auditors be requested to carry out a preliminary review, felt the proposal was too broad. The Executive, therefore, AGREED that the recommendation be amended as follows:-
“We recommend that the Council’s external auditors be requested to carry out a preliminary review of the Borough Treasurer’s Department to identify which systems should be included in an audit plan for a further in-depth review.”
2.4Members expectations were that all recommendations would be implemented and that with regard to Recommendation 4, as amended, the Council’s auditors would be commissioned to carry out the above review.
2.5The process for commissioning KPMG
2.5.1 During October and November 2001 discussions took place between the Chief Executive and KPMG about the nature of and the terms of reference for the review. The Chair of Overview and Scrutiny and the Head of Scrutiny and Performance were not involved in these early discussions with KPMG. The Review got underway and interviews with key individuals took place during March and April 2002. KPMG were assisted in the arrangements for interviews by the Head of Scrutiny and Performance.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.