CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Lichfield District Council
Cabinet, Tuesday 30 July 2024 at 6.00pm

Civic Matrix – Recommendations from Overview & Scrutiny (O&S) Committee

Agreed Executive 4 papers

Cabinet agreed this item on Tuesday 30 July 2024. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item7

Resolved

Cabinet agreed: 2.1 f) That no determination of events required input from the Leader or Chief Executive as exists in the current matrix. 2.1 g) That the most appropriate Civic Head should attend functions. 2.1 h) To amalgamate the Chair and Vice-Chair’s budgets. 2.1 i) To have a budget for clothing, with a maximum appropriate level to be set by Cabinet. The suggested limit proposed was £200 per person. · That having reviewed the operation of the matrix, Cabinet recommends that the requirement for a civic matrix be withdrawn, with decisions on event invitations to now be determined by the Chair and Vice-Chair, with support from the Civic Officer. · That for transparency and accountability, Cabinet recommends that the Chair include a record of all events the Chair & Vice Chair have attended since last Full Council within the ‘Chair’s Announcements’
Word for word from the decision Lichfield published for this meeting. Source: democracy.lichfielddc.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Lichfield's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Civic Matrix – Recommendations from Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Date: 30/07/2024 Agenda item: 7 Contact: Chair of Overview & Scrutiny Tel number: Email: CABINET Key decision? NO Local ward N/A members

1. Executive summary 1.1 Following the work of the Overview & Scrutiny (O&S) Civic Matrix Task Group, the following changes to the existing Civic Matrix have been suggested by the parent O&S committee to Cabinet for consideration.

2. Recommendations 2.1 That having reviewed the recommended changes to the current Civic Matrix - as proposed by Overview & Scrutiny - Cabinet agree to the following recommendations proposed by the committee: a) A points-based system for determining events to replace the existing matrix. b) The following points system: 1=Low priority; 3=Medium priority; 5=High priority. c) The threshold for acceptance of invitations to be set at 5 points. d) An event that scores 4 points will be decided at the discretion of the Chair and the Civic Officer – the Chair should then record their justification as to why they believe the event that scored 4 to be an acceptable event to attend. e) That use of the car is appropriate for an event scoring 4 or higher but should not be permitted for an event scoring 3 or lower. f) That no determination of events required input from the Leader or Chief Executive as exists in the current matrix. g) That the most appropriate Civic Head should attend functions. h) To amalgamate the Chair and Vice-Chair’s budgets. i) To have a budget for clothing, with a maximum appropriate level to be set by Cabinet. The suggested limit proposed by O&S was £200.

3. Background 3.1 On 14th September 2023, Overview & Scrutiny reviewed the Civic Matrix function and agreed that the matrix was not working effectively in its current form. Members suggested a “points” system instead and established a task and finish group to examine further how this may work. Minutes are included at Appendix A. 3.2 The task group met on 05th March 2024 and produced the following outcomes: • Members unanimously agreed that a points-based system for determining events was preferable to the existing matrix. • Members suggested that the most appropriate Civic Head should attend functions. • The number of criteria to determine invitations were reduced. Some of these were recommended to be merged due to overlap with each other. • Members agreed on the following points system: 1=Low priority; 3=Medium priority; 5=High priority. • Members set the threshold for acceptance of invitations at 5 points. • Members recommended that if an event scores 4 points, this will be decided at the discretion of the Chair and the Civic Officer – the Chair should then record their justification as to why they believe the event that scored 4 to be an acceptable event to attend. • Members were content that there was no score where determination of events required input from the Leader or Chief Executive. • Members agreed use of the car was appropriate for an event scoring 4 or higher but should not be permitted for an event scoring 3 or lower. • Members agreed that it was appropriate to amalgamate the Chair and Vice-Chair’s budgets. • Members concluded it was appropriate to have a budget for clothing, though they believed that there should be a maximum appropriate level set. Notes of the task group are included at Appendix B. 3.3 On 03rd April 2024, Overview & Scrutiny reviewed the work of the task and finish group. Minutes included at Appendix C. Overview & Scrutiny recommended the changes proposed by the task group to Cabinet. 3.4 The changes proposed relate only to the function of the existing civic matrix in determining what events the Chair and Vice-Chair may attend. It does not make a judgement or recommendation on the value of the civic function itself.

Alternative options Cabinet may choose to reject the suggestions of Overview & Scrutiny committee. Cabinet may choose an alternative method to the civic matrix.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Minutes of O&S 14.09.2023.docxAppendix A 53 KB Download
PDF
Notes of Task Group meeting 05.03.2024Appendix B 178 KB Download
PDF
Minutes of O&S 03.04.2024Appendix C 46 KB Download
PDF
Civic Matrix: Recommendations from Overview & Scrutiny (O&S) CommitteeReport 119 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

0 of 10 attended
RC
Councillor Richard CoxCommittee Member, expected
AF
Councillor Alex FarrellCommittee Member, expected
RH
Councillor Richard HollandCommittee Member, apologies
DP
Councillor Doug PullenChair, expected
JS
Councillor Janice Silvester-HallCommittee Member, expected
AS
Councillor Andrew SmithCommittee Member, apologies
RS
Councillor Rob StrachanCommittee Member, expected
PW
Councillor Phil WhitehouseCommittee Member, expected
KD
Kerry DoveSecretary, expected
MH
Mark HooperClerk, expected

On this subject at Lichfield

Search all
  1. Civic Matrix – Recommendations from Overview & Scrutiny (O&S) CommitteeThis decision
  2. Notes and Revised Matrix from the Civic Matrix Task GroupAgreed
  3. Review of Civic Function MatrixDecided

More from Lichfield Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
13 Jul 2026 Year-End Performance and Delivery Report 2025/26The Cabinet: 2.1 Discussed and approved the Q4 Year 2 Delivery Plan outturn of the Lichfield District 2050 Strategy a... Approved Open
13 Jul 2026 Confirmation of Scheme of Delegation for New Local PlanThe Cabinet: Delegated authority to the Cabinet Member for Housing and Local Plan in conjunction with the Chief Execu... Decided Open
13 Jul 2026 Community infrastructure Levy (CIL) Allocations 2026The Cabinet: 2.1 Approved the following CIL allocations: · £100,000 to Wigginton and Hopwas Parish council towards th... Approved Open
13 Jul 2026 Money Matters: 2025/26 Financial MonitoringThe Cabinet: 2.1. Reviewed the report including the level of general and earmarked reserves and issues raised within ... Approved Open
13 Jul 2026 Procurement Matters Update 2025/26The Cabinet: 2.1. Reviewed the contents of this report and the progress against planned actions in the Action Plan fo... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies