Resolved that – (i) the restrictive covenant contained within the conveyance of the freehold interest of 31/33 Cornhill , preventing the use of the premises for retail, residential, hotel or leisure use be lifted; and (ii) the payment of a premium of £20,000 plus surveyors fees of £1000 and legal fees of £600 be accepted.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
To update members in connection with the proposed lifting of a freehold restrictive covenant in respect of 31/33 Cornhill, Liverpool L1.
The premises comprise a two storey building providing 635 sq.m. of accommodation together with a rear yard of approximately 400 sq.m.
The freehold interest was sold by the City Council on 16 March 1990 for £15,000. The conveyance contained a restrictive covenant preventing the use of the premises for retail, residential, hotel or leisure use.
In 2001 the owners of the property were Langley Court Limited, who were marketing it together with a 5 storey warehouse at 29 Cornhill for residential redevelopment. They had identified a potential developer, Armour Homes and requested that the covenant be modified to permit redevelopment of both properties.
Terms were provisionally agreed to vary the restrictive covenant to permit residential development upon payment of a premium of £10,000 plus the Council’s legal and surveyor’s costs in the sum of £700. This was reported to members in report EDR/02/01. The decision taken was to instruct officers to seek an increased premium and to hold discussions with the potential developer.
The owners were not prepared to discuss a variation of the provisionally agreed terms and Armour Homes were not prepared to enter into any agreement allowing the Council any greater level of control over the proposed development than that which could be exercised through the planning process.
Armour Homes purchased both sites without the benefit of the covenant being relaxed. They have obtained outline planning consent for a scheme comprising a 9 storey building with ground floor car parking and 16 – 2 bedroom and 2 – 1 bedroomed flats above. Further negotiations have been held with Armour Homes and an improved offer of £20,000 plus the Council’s legal and surveyors costs of £1600 has now been received.
If consent to lift the covenant were withheld and Armour commenced residential development, legal action could be taken but the Head of Legal Services has advised that our claim would be limited to the level of damage to our adjoining property interests.
It is the opinion of the Operations Manager of Land and Development Services that there will be no quantifiable damage to our interests in surrounding properties, indeed it is arguable that the proposed redevelopment will have a favourable effect on our land values. Any claim for compensation for breach of covenant would be likely to be unsuccessful.
Under the provisions of Section 86 of the Law of Property Act 1925 the developer could apply to the Lands Tribunal for the covenant to be lifted. If they did this and were unsuccessful the only revenue payable to the Council would be as outlined above and the costs of the Tribunal would also be incurred.
Executive Member/Director recommendation (Councillors Peter Millea and Chris Curry/Charlie Parker)
That:
1. The restrictive covenant contained within the conveyance of the freehold interest of 31/33 Cornhill, Liverpool L1 preventing the use of the premises for retail, residential, hotel or leisure use be lifted; and 2. The payment of a premium of £20,000 plus surveyors fees of £1000 and legal fees of £600 be accepted.
Key Decision? No
Forward Plan N/A
Implementation effective from:
6 June 2003
Timescale for action:
Legal documentation to be completed as soon as possible after Executive Board Approval. Reason(s) for Recommendation:
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.