Resolved that – (i) following a further review of the National Employers’ Organisation, it has been found that the role and value to the City Council of the National Employers’ Organisation has diminished dramatically in recent years. The benefits of the current service are outweighed by the cost (£6,523 2004 / 2005) it is therefore recommended that the City Council’s membership be terminated forthwith; (ii) this decision should not be viewed as any intention on the part of the City Council to move away from the NJC or other national agreements; and (iii) alternative arrangements be developed to supersede the NJC (little used) disputes procedure in line with arrangements put in place with the withdrawal from the North West Employers Organisation.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
A review of the services provided by both the National and Regional Employers Organisations was undertaken in early 2002. The purpose of the review was to consider the value for money these services provided and the contribution they made to the City Council.
At the time the annual cost to the City Council (inclusive of VAT) amounted to around £53,000. This comprised c£37,000 subscription to the North West Employers Organisation (NWE) and c£17,000 to the National Employers Organisation (a part of which funded the IDeA).
It was believed that duplication existed in the services provided by these Organisations. Many of the services were provided in house by the City Council (eg. Legal, HR and Member development teams). Little use was being made of the services these organisations provided. When they had been used the response was frequently equivocal and even open to challenge. On occasions it provided contradictory advice to other parties.
At its meeting of the 24 July 2002 the Community, Equality and Values Select Committee considered these issues and heard submissions from the National Employers’ Organisation, Unison and the North West Provincial Council and supported the Executive Member’s Recommendation that:
i. the membership to the National Employers’ Organisation continue and be reviewed in March 2003 as to their performance; and
ii. the Council’s membership to the North West Employers’ Organisation be terminated forthwith.
The review of the National Employers’ Organisation was not undertaken in March 2003 but with the agreement of the Executive Member was delayed until March 2004. The City Council has continued to subscribe to the Employers’ Organisation following the discussions at the Community, Equality and Values Select Committee on the 24 July 2002.
For 2004 / 2005 the cost of subscribing to the Employer’s Organisation is £6,523. However, it continues to be difficult to establish a value against this financial cost. The Human Resource and Payroll Service has contacted the Employer’s Organisation on the following issues:
¾ The reclassification of certain posts within Supported Living as ‘essential car users’ and the contract of employment implications of such a change for the employees concerned;
¾ The registration of Social Workers with the GSCC and the impact of this requirement upon contracts of employment;
¾ The matter of industrial action and in particular:
1. The deduction of pay to Full Time Convenors as a result of their taking part in the recent supported Living industrial action;
2. The deduction of annual leave, pro rata to completed month’s service, from those employees who took part in the recent Supported Living industrial action;
In general terms, the advice of the Employers’ Organisation is consistent with that of the Council’s in-house HR Service but such advice is not always readily available. Often, a formal response can not be obtained on the same day an enquiry is made. Specialist legal advice is also available in-house, from the Council’s Employment Lawyer. Additional support can also be obtained, for complex legal matters, from Counsel – again in a short space of time.
Overall it has to be said that these in-house avenues of enquiry are speedier and more business focussed than those of the Employers’ Organisation.
A recent study (March 2004) of the Employers’ Organisation (a quinquennial review) found that:
¾ the Employer Organisation is less strongly represented at senior member level
¾ remains politically vulnerable in relation to the Unions and Central Government
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.