Resolved that – (i) the donation of an area of land at Allerton Cemetery, sufficient to contain up to 30 graves, for the purpose of burial of the unidentifiable babies from Alder Hey Hospital and the University of Liverpool and the creation of a memorial garden, be approved; and (ii) the powers under which it is proposed to bury the babies, be noted.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
The purpose of this report is to advise members of the proposal to bury approximately 1000 unidentifiable babies currently held at Alder Hey Hospital and the University of Liverpool, under the powers of Section (2) of the Local Government Act 2000.
Liverpool City Council was initially approached by the Cheshire and Merseyside Strategic Health Authority to assist with the preparation and subsequent burial of approximately 1000 unidentifiable babies, most of which are pre 28 weeks gestation, currently held in collections at both Alder Hey Hospital and the University of Liverpool. A number of other organisations have also been involved, including The Retained Organs Commission, the Home Office, Pity 2, and representatives from the Department of Health.
This is an extremely sensitive situation, which has required careful and sensitive planning in order to ensure that all organisations are taking a consistent and approved approach. As part of the process an area of land within Allerton Cemetery has been chosen as the preferred burial area for the babies, which could ultimately be developed as a memorial garden. The area consists of some 30 grave spaces, and a formal request has been made to the City Council for the donation of the grave spaces. It is considered that, if approved, this donation would be seen as a significant gesture of goodwill on behalf of the City Council.
There is an issue with regard to the legality of burial without parental consent, which is obviously not available as the babies are unidentifiable. This was further complicated by the fact that burial law only relates to the burial or cremation of a person above 24 weeks gestation. Therefore, for the vast majority of these babies, burial law does not apply.
A request was made to the City Solicitor to form a legal opinion on whether or not the local authority has the powers to carry out a respectful burial. The resulting legal opinion recommends that the local burial authority does have the necessary powers under Section (2) of the Local Government Act 2000. This legal opinion has been shared with various relevant organisations and they have said that they agree with the view of the City Solicitor. It is therefore proposed to carry out the respectful burials under the relevant powers.
In relation to the financial aspects, the donation of the right of burial to the grave spaces has no direct impact on the Cemeteries & Crematoria Service. The issue relating to the burial process does have a cost implication in relation to the officer time involved throughout the process, the physical work carried out by the grounds maintenance contractor to excavate and reinstate the graves and the statutory registration of the burials by cemetery registrars. In reality this is a real cost to the service and the Strategic Health Authority have confirmed that they are content with the costings, payable by them, for the service provided.
The Cemeteries & Crematoria Service have already received a great deal of praise for the professional manner in which staff have endeavoured to deal with this extremely sensitive situation. The donation of the right of burial to the grave spaces will be seen as a significant gesture by the City Council in accommodating the respectful burial of these unfortunate babies.
Executive Member/Director recommendation Richard Oglethorpe/Charlie Parker
That -
(i) the donation of an area of land at Allerton Cemetery, sufficient to contain up to 30 graves, for the purpose of burial of the unidentifiable babies from Alder Hey Hospital and the University of Liverpool and the creation of a memorial garden, be approved; and (ii) the powers under which it is proposed to bury the babies, be noted.
Key Decision?
Yes
Forward Plan
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.