Resolved that – (i) the Executive Director (Resources) enter into a contract with Liverpool Direct Limited, with the assistance of LogicaCMG , for the implementation and ongoing support of SAP Financials; and (ii) the Capital Programme for 2006/07 include provision for the phased implementation of e-procurement at a cost of £880,000 as an invest to save initiative to be financed from unsupported borrowing
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
The City Council’s current corporate financial system is CedAr Financials hosted externally by Netstore Ltd form Gateshead. However, the contracts for the use and operation of this suite of systems terminate in June 2006. In recent months therefore a review has been undertaken to identify the most appropriate system for the future.
The objective was not merely to seek a replacement suite of financial systems but to identify a solution that would:
• Meet the Council’s financial and management accounting reporting requirements.
• Enable the Council to respond to changing financial requirements through flexibility of processing, reporting and data accessability.
• Allow for the Council’s customer orientated income strategy.
• Provide the technical capability for the Council to maximise the advantages to be delivered through e-procurement.
• Enable the Council’s financial management solution to be developed as a model of best practice and therefore be attractive to “sell” as a service to other authorities and organisations.
Liverpool Direct Limited (LDL), as the Council’s ICT advisors were engaged to identify the three most appropriate options and to undertake, with finance officers from the Council, a detailed evaluation of the system options identified. The three systems identified were the Council’s current system CedAr, Oracle Financials and SAP Financials.
Proposals were therefore invited from a number of implementation partners in response to the detailed “Invitation To Tender” issued by LDL on behalf of the Council in respect of the three system options identified. The detailed evaluation considered each proposal in respect of the following criteria:
• Functionality – the capability and ease of use of the proposed software to deliver the financial processes required, together with the ease of accessing the data through reporting tools.
• Technical – the robustness of the ICT environment proposed to support the system.
• Implementation Partner – the reliability of the implementation partner to deliver the system proposal put forward.
• Strategic Fit – the ease with which the various system options can interface or integrate with some of the Council’s existing systems and how the systems proposed might replace existing systems.
• Cost – both of implementation and ongoing annual maintenance and support.
The initial phase of the evaluation identified a far closer match to the Council’s specification requirements from the Oracle and SAP solutions. Therefore it was the proposals based upon those two systems that were subject to more detailed consideration and eventually “best and final offers”.
The final conclusion of the evaluation was that, with the exception of “strategic fit”, the proposal from Logica using SAP Financials achieved the highest scores and at a total cost over the proposed seven year contract period of £8.8 million, had a lower cost by approximately £1 million compared with the alternative costed proposals considered from Oracle.
The issue concerning strategic fit centred upon the Council’s current and continued use of the Oracle Human Resource and Payroll system. The implementation of SAP Financials would necessitate the continued use of interface solutions to share data rather than the integration advantages of using Oracle Financials. However, the better match to the Council’s overall requirements, and specifically the data reporting and interrogation facilities, offered by SAP Financials were considered to outweigh the advantage of strategic fit offered by the Oracle solution.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.