Resolved that – (i) on the basis of the report submitted, officers be authorised to proceed with the TUPE transfer of the tourist information service subject to either the receipt of Objective One funding or a written guarantee from TMP to meet the additional costs of TUPE (estimated October 2004 at £80,000 per annum); (ii) the decision be further subject to the receipt of warranties and indemnities from TMP as required by TUPE and outlined in the report submitted; and (iii) a target date for any transfer be set as the 1 October 2005.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
To consider a proposed transfer of Tourist Information Centres to Liverpool City Council as part of the Capital of Culture function.
Background
At its meeting of the 28th November 2003 the Executive Board approved the development of a Capital of Culture ‘front office’ and considered the integrating of the Tourist Information Centres into the operation of the ’08 Place’.
A small project team was then established to consider the issue of the Tourist Information Centre services. Discussions with the Mersey Partnership Group (TMP) did take place to consider this suggestion of integration. Information has been shared and financial implications considered to allow an informed decision to be made on whether the integration should be pursued or not.
On the basis of these discussions a second report was considered by Members (15th October 2004) which recommended the following:
i. The City Council formally approaches The Mersey Partnership with a view to secure the integration of the ‘Tourist Information Centres’ (based within Liverpool) for a period of five years with any financial gap (of any such transfer) be funded through the Capital of Culture Company during its operational life.
ii. Any staff involved in the current Tourist Information Centre operation be managed under a ‘secondment agreement‘ with full negotiations to commence with ‘The Mersey Partnership’ to reach agreement of the details of any such secondment.
iii. Liverpool City Council to develop its own web based hotel booking system to be managed from the Capital of Culture Experience shop. It was clear that the City Council’s preferred option was secondment of any staff. However TMP discounted secondment and asked that a TUPE transfer take place. This had obvious financial and personnel implications which required further consideration. Given this fundamentally changed the model further discussions were required which have been complex and challenging.
PROPOSALS
The proposed integration of Tourist Information Centres remains a robust proposition. The issue raised by TMP whilst disappointing is essentially a matter of increased cost. Put simply, the terms and conditions of employment are more competitive within the City Council and include an occupational pension scheme. TMP frontline employees do not. However TMP have taken legal advice which they state prevents them from seconding. The advice runs counter to the City Council’s own advice in relation to similar actions eg. Merseycare, Liverpool Direct Limited. No progress has been made on this issue since the last report to Members. We now face a clear choice, accept a TUPE transfer or do not integrate these services.
TMP currently employs 35 staff (24 at Queens Square and 11 at John Lennon Airport). This number equates to 15.75 full time equivalent. There is a large number of part-time and ‘casual’ staff. Current salary costs equate to around £250,000 pa.
Any ‘TUPE’ transfer would carry additional costs to the City Council. The key factor is the issue of ‘pensions’. TMP employees are generally not members of the Mersey Superannuation Pension Fund. If all TUPE’d staff took advantage of this benefit (and some levelling of grades) would add around £80,000 pa extra to the cost of the service. Based on these costs the financials of any transfer would be:-
£’000 (pa)
Sales of Centres 505 Cost of Sales 334 ____
Gross profit 170 Administrative costs 456 ____
Net Loss before grant 286 Anticipated Grants Receivable 205 ____
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.