Resolved that – (i) the report be noted; (ii) the Chief Executive be asked to write to the Minister for the Department of Transport seeking clarification in relation to the timescales involved with regards to the projects to be funded from the £170m and that this money is to be allocated to Merseyside and not the entire Northwest; (iii) this Executive Board deeply regrets the decision taken by the Minister in this respect; and (iv) the Executive Board reiterates its total support for the second Mersey Crossing.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
To advise the Executive Board in relation to the current position concerning Merseytram Line 1.
Recommendation
That the Executive Board note the information contained within this report together with an oral update to be provided at the meeting.
INFORMATION
1. Members will recall the Executive Board Report of 18 November 2005 in which an update on the Merseytram project was presented.
2. Since that meeting, Members will also be aware of the press release dated 29 November 2005 from the Department for Transport. A copy of this is appended as Annex 1 to this report. It is understood that the MPTA will be meeting on Monday 5 December 2005 to consider the implications of this decision.
3. The Minister’s statement is extremely disappointing given the positive work which Merseytravel, the City and Knowsley Councils have made on the funding package. Politicians and officers have continued to meet with Merseytram Team, despite the recent correspondence from the Government, to ensure that the scheme would be delivered within the proposed financial framework. However, the Government has decided that it cannot support the funding plan, but has said that funding would be available for “good value schemes”.
4. Members may wish to note that this is the third light rail project which the Government has chosen not to support within the last month. The Government’s decision on Merseytram also follows recent similar decisions on the South Hampshire Rapid Transit (29 November 2005) and Leeds Supertram (3 November 2005) projects. In all these cases, the Government has said that it is unable to fund more than their original ‘capped’ commitment. Tram promoters in Leeds and Bristol are now considering other more cost-effective transport alternatives.
5. Members consideration is also drawn to recent correspondence between solicitors acting for Merseytravel and the City Council. This is included in a separate Exempt Report.
6. There have been allegations in the media that officers have not been co- operative with Merseytravel. This is emphatically denied. The City Council’s officers have worked and liaised with Merseytravel on the project in an entirely cooperative manner.
Suggested Way Forward
7. Officers are evaluating the consequences of the Government’s decision on other projects within the City Centre and whether there are implications upon the City Council’s capital spending programmes. 8. Members will be aware that there is a special Merseytravel PTA meeting on Monday 5 December 2005, at which, it is understood, options for the future of the project will be discussed. Officers have not seen the agenda or papers for this meeting. However, given the recent Government announcements on light rails this month, this may mean that alternative transport proposals must now need to be considered. As with other schemes detailed in paragraph 4 above, promoters have moved on from the Government’s decision and are beginning to look at alternative transportation projects. In addition, the DfT has recently published a report on the Leeds project1, which suggests that there are willing to consider cost effective alternatives to light rail.
9. The Minster for Transport also concludes his statement by saying that:-
"The Government remains committed to investing in Merseyside. We have committed over £200 million to transport improvements in Merseyside over the last 5 years, and we intend to continue to support good value schemes in the area. If there are good value schemes that can be taken forward quickly to benefit Merseyside - we will look at them."
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.