Resolved that the City Council accept a payment of £150,000 in full and final settlement of a dilapidations claim against Punch Taverns (PRGP) Limited in respect of their breach of repairing covenant during the occupation of unit 191/193 London Road, as agreed by 2020 Liverpool Limited and approved by the Client Officer for Property and Asset Management Services. RES/81
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
This report has been prepared by 2020 Liverpool Limited to seek authority to accept a payment of £150,000 in full and final settlement of a dilapidations claim against the outgoing lessee of the property at 191/193 London Road, Liverpool, L6 8JG, as shown on the attached plan.
At the lease expiry in May 2005, the City Council peaceably re-entered the premises as they were vacant and in a derelict condition. Punch Taverns (PRGP) Limited, as original lessee, was responsible for the lease following the bankruptcy of the assignee, [name removed].
The property at 191/193 London Road is included within a proposed development scheme at 191/205 London Road and 6/8 Falkland Street which was reported to members in November 2005 and subsequently approved. The agreed premium of £238,500 in respect of the amalgamated site reflected a value of £75,000 for the property at 191/193 London Road in its present condition. Reference was made in this report that 2020 Liverpool Limited would progress a dilapidations claim against the outgoing tenant.
Punch Taverns, as original lessees, were occupying the property on effectively full repairing and insuring terms as provided for by the terms of the original lease. A full Schedule of Dilapidations was served on the company specifying all the items of disrepair identified by 2020’s Building Surveyor. Following negotiations, it has been provisionally agreed that Punch Taverns will make a payment of £150,000 in full and final settlement of the Council’s claim in this matter.
Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 limits the maximum amount of damages recoverable by the lessee to either the cost of the works or the damage to the landlord’s reversionary interest as a result of the breach of the repairing covenant, whichever is the lesser. 2020 Liverpool Limited has valued the property in good repair and condition at £187,500. Given the building’s proposed change of use and proposed amalgamation into a larger site, it has been accepted that there is little to be gained by fully repairing the building.
Acceptance of the proposed settlement is recommended by 2020 Liverpool Limited who certify that it represents the best consideration reasonably obtainable. The proposed settlement was provisionally agreed on 2nd February 2006.
Executive Member/ Acting Executive Director Recommendation (Councillor Keith Turner/ Ben Dolan)
That the City Council accept a payment of £150,000 in full and final settlement of a dilapidations claim against Punch Taverns (PRGP) Limited in respect of their breach of repairing covenant during the occupation of unit 191/193 London Road, Liverpool, L6 8JG as agreed by 2020 Liverpool Limited and approved by the Client Officer for Property and Asset Management Services.
Key Decision?
No
Forward Plan/ 5 Days Notice/ Special Urgency
No.
Implementation Effective From:
8 May 2006.
Timescale for Action
The dilapidations payment will be collected as soon as possible. Reason(s) for Recommendation
The proposed settlement is the most favourable that can be negotiated in the circumstances. The extent of the council’s claim is limited by statute and it is not considered that progressing action through the legal process would result in a more substantial payment being achieved.
Alternative Options to be Considered:
To refuse to accept the settlement and proceed to make a claim against Punch Taverns (PRGP) through the courts for a higher amount.
Consultation
Liverpool Vision is keen to see the redevelopment of the larger site of which this building forms part.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.