That having considered the recommendations made by the Sustainable Communities Overview and Scrutiny Panel Cabinet agree to note the recommendations at this stage and to take them into account when considering the report setting out the substantive proposals from Merton Priory Homes.
Word for word from the decision Merton published for this meeting.Source: democracy.merton.gov.uk
Merton Council - call-in request form Appendix 1 x Decision to be called in: (required) Merton Regeneration Programme (Cabinet Meeting of 9 July 2013; agenda item 3)
x Which of the principles of decision making in Article 13 of the constitution has not been applied? (required) Required by part 4E Section 16(c)(a)(ii)of the constitution - tick all that apply: (a) proportionality (i.e. the action must be proportionate to the desired outcome); (b) due consultation and the taking of professional advice from X officers; (c) respect for human rights and equalities; (d) a presumption in favour of openness; X (e) clarity of aims and desired outcomes; (f) consideration and evaluation of alternatives; X (g) irrelevant matters must be ignored.
x Desired outcome Part 4E Section 16(f) of the constitution- select one: (a) The Panel/Commission to refer the decision back to the X decision making person or body for reconsideration, setting out in writing the nature of its concerns. (b) To refer the matter to full Council where the Commission/Panel determines that the decision is contrary to the Policy and/or Budget Framework (c) The Panel/Commission to decide not to refer the matter back to the decision making person or body * * If you select (c) please explain the purpose of calling in the decision.
Page 15 3 x Evidence which demonstrates the alleged breach(es) indicated in above (required) Required by part 4E Section 16(c)(a)(ii) of the constitution:
Page 16 4 x Breech of due consultation: Despite the fact that discussions have been ongoing for some time between Merton Council and MPH (Merton Priory Homes) and a presentation made to the Circle Housing Group Management Board in December 2012, no consultation with ward councillors or the scrutiny panels was undertaken. Because the time appeared on the cabinet agenda at late notice (with the paper only published one working day before the cabinet meeting), there was no opportunity for pre-decision scrutiny.
The paper failed to meet the requirements in favour of transparency and the explanation given was inadequate. Given the fact that discussions have been ongoing for well over a year with MPH, the need to commence consultation with residents before consulting ward councillors or the scrutiny panel is unclear. “The legal requirements for Access to Information have not been met. The Chair has agreed the submission of this item to this meeting as a matter of urgency in order that Cabinet is aware of the proposals being put forward By Merton Priory Homes on the engagement they are commencing on the Eastfields, High Path and Ravensbury estates.”
Breech of a presumption in favour of openness: No details of the feasibility study or financial implications have been disclosed (even confidentially); the transfer of the housing properties to MPH in 2010 represented one of the most important financial transactions undertaken by Merton Council and the agreement has financial implications for at least 20 years, particularly in matters concerning regeneration. It would be expected that both Merton Council and MPH would have evaluated the implications of these financial arrangements (even at a high level) at this stage of the process, particularly within the Circle Group. If these arrangements have not been analysed within Merton Council, there is an urgent need to do so and the results reported as part of this report. If MPH is working with Merton Council in an open dialogue, it would be expected that they would have shared details of the December 2012 presentation with Merton Council and these details should have been made available to cabinet and councillors. The cabinet paper asks cabinet to seek to influence MPH but the underlying basis for the powers available to cabinet are not clear.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Morden Town Centre RegenerationCabinet is asked to: A. Note the progress made on the Programme since Cabinet approved the procurement of a developme...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.