CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Mid Devon District Council
Planning Committee, Wednesday 10 February 2016 at 2.15pm

THE PLANS LIST (00-34-39)

Refused Planning 1 paper

Planning Committee refused this item on Wednesday 10 February 2016. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item114

Resolved

RESOLVED that the following application be determined or otherwise dealt with in accordance with the various recommendations contained in the list namely: ( i ) No 2 on the Plans List (15//01672/FULL – Removal of Condition 3 (holiday occupancy condition) of planning permission 05/01218/FULL – The Barn, Pugham Farm, Westleigh , Tiverton) be refused as recommended by the Head of Planning and Regeneration (Proposed by the Chairman) (b) No 1 on the Plans List (15//01622/FULL – Erection of an agricultural work’s dwelling and an agricultural livestock building at land at NGR 316711 110152 (Ten Oaks farm), Clayhidon ). The Principal Planning Officer outlined the contents of the report which had been deferred from a previous meeting so that further information could be obtained with regard to financial sustainability, the water supply and the sufficiency of the land area available for the enterprise. He highlighted the block plan and proposed elevations of the dwelling and additional barn and provided photographs from various aspects of the site. Consideration was given: · To the possible use of a borehole and whether this was feasible · Whether there was a need for the applicant to live on site · Concerns of the local residents with regard to whether the business was financially viable · The absence of effective business plans and financial data · The cost of a borehole · The need for stock movement information to be made available RESOLVED that Members were minded to refuse the application and therefore wished to defer the decision to allow for a report to be received setting out the implications for the proposed reasons for refusal based on the following issues: · Insufficient size of holding to sustain the proposed activity upon which the need for a dwelling was based. · Information to support the applications did not adequately demonstrate that the business will be sustained and financially viable. Members also requested receipt on a confidential basis of the applicant’s stock movement records for the past two years and any audited accounts or financial information in support of the application. (Proposed by Cllr R L Stanley and seconded by Cllr Mrs B M Hull) Notes : i) Cllrs [name removed], K I Busch, [name removed], [name removed], J M Downes, S G Flaws, P J Heal, D J Knowles, F W Letch, B A Moore, J D Squire and R L Stanley made declarations in accordance with the Protocol of Good Practice for Councillors in dealing with Planning matters as they had all received additional information from the applicant; ii) [name removed] (Applicant) spoke; iii) [name removed] (Objector) spoke; iv) Cllr Langford ( Clayhidon Parish Council) spoke; v) Cllr F J Rosamond spoke as Ward Member; vi) Cllr Mrs H Bainbridge ... view the full minutes text for item 114.
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting. Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Mid Devon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

PLANNING COMMITTEE AGENDA - 10th February 2016

Applications of a non-delegated nature

Item No. Description

1. 15/01622/FULL - Erection of an agricultural worker's dwelling and an agricultural livestock building at Land at NGR 316711 110152 (Ten Oaks Farm), Clayhidon, Devon. RECOMMENDATION Subject to the provision of a Section 106 Agreement/Unilateral Undertaking and conditions grant permission.

2. 15/01672/FULL - Removal of Condition 3 (holiday occupancy condition) of Planning Permission 05/01218/FULL at The Barn, Pugham Farm, Westleigh. RECOMMENDATION Refuse permission.

AGENDA 1 Application No. 15/01622/FULL Plans List No. 1

Grid Ref: 316711 : 110152

Applicant: [name removed]: Land at NGR 316711 110152 (Ten Oaks Farm) Clayhidon Devon

Proposal: Erection of an agricultural worker's dwelling and an agricultural livestock building

Date Valid: 20th October 2015

AGENDA 2 Application No. 15/01622/FULL

RECOMMENDATION Subject to the provision of a Section 106 Agreement/Unilateral Undertaking and conditions grant permission.

COUNCILLOR FRANK ROSAMOND HAS REQUESTED THAT THIS APPLICATION BE DETERMINED BY THE PLANNING COMMITTEE FOR THE FOLLOWING REASON:

To consider the absence of an effective business plan sufficient to justify the application, allied to concerns in respect of the water supply.

To update Planning Committee following a request for further information at the meeting on 2nd December 2015.

Updated information

At the Planning Committee held on 2nd December 2015 Members of Planning Committee requested officers to obtain additional information on three matters:

1 Financial sustainability 2 Water supply and sufficiency of the supply, including storage capacity. 3 Sufficiency of the land area available for the enterprise. To show the time livestock is in the building is kept outside

As set out by the applicants agent below in response to your officers request for further information.

The Inspector's decision to grant the Appeal was: 'to facilitate the further expansion and development of the agricultural enterprise'. This application is for that further expansion and development.

1) The documents supporting this application evidence that the agricultural enterprise is currently financially sound. Moreover, approval will increase income as a result of expansion and improved efficiency as set out with the projected financial returns.

Regarding the request by Members for the applicant to divulge private financial funding information; officers will no doubt advise Members about whether or not proof of capital funding for a development proposal is a prerequisite of approval; and if it fulfils any planning purpose. Adopting a rational approach, 'the proof of the pudding is in the eating'. It is self-evident that if finances are not available the proposed development will not occur.

Officer comment: No additional information has been provided over and above the agent's comments above. Your officers have asked for copies of sales and purchase receipts but these have not yet been supplied, although the applicant is considering this further. Should these be provided, Members will be updated on this. Members have been informed that the financial information already provided as to the viability of the unit is available for scrutiny within the planning office, should they wish to consider these figures, but is not replicated in their public officer report due to its confidential nature.

2) Turning to adequacy of 'rainwater harvesting' water supply for the livestock. First and foremost this is a matter that falls under the 'Animal Welfare Act 2006', just as when this Council grants permission for industrial premises the welfare of workers falls under the 'Health and Safety at Work Act'. Thus, the appropriate 'safeguards' exist.

Secondly, 'rainwater harvesting' is recognised as highly sustainable source of both commercial and domestic water supply which should be encouraged, alongside alternative energy sources, independent of 'mains supplies'.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
THE PLANS LIST (00-34-39)Plan 246 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

14 of 23 attended
HB
Councillor Heather BainbridgeCommittee Member, present
KB
Councillor Karl BuschCommittee Member, present
CC
Councillor Christine CollisCommittee Member, present
PC
Councillor Polly ColthorpeCommittee Member, present
JD
Councillor John DownesCommittee Member, present
SF
Councillor Steve FlawsCommittee Member, present
PH
Councillor Peter HealCommittee Member, present
DK
Councillor Dennis KnowlesCommittee Member, present
FL
Councillor Frank LetchCommittee Member, present
AM
Councillor Andrew MooreCommittee Member, present
RR
Councillor Ray RadfordCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
JS
Councillor John SquireCommittee Member, present

All 23 on the meeting page

On this subject at Mid Devon

Search all
  1. THE PLANS LIST (00-34-39)This decision
  2. The plans list (00:15:54)Decided
  3. The plans list (00:07:32)Decided
  4. The plans listDecided
  5. The plans list (00:16:35)Refused
  6. The plans list (00:14:42)Decided

More from Mid Devon Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
9 Sep 2026 The plans list (00:15:54)RESOLVED to grant consent. (Proposed by Cllr G DuChesne and seconded by Cllr B Holdman) 2. 25/01736/MFUL - Demolition... Decided Open
19 Aug 2026 The plans list (00:07:32)RESOLVED that planning permission be granted subject to conditions. (Proposed by Cllr S Clist and seconded by Cllr S ... Decided Open
29 Jul 2026 Election of chair for the municipal year 2026/2027RESOLVED that Cllr L Cruwys be elected Chair of the Planning Committee for the municipal year 2026/2027. (Proposed by... Decided Open
29 Jul 2026 Election of vice-chair for the municipal year 2026/2027RESOLVED that Cllr G Cochran be elected Vice-Chair of the Planning Committee for the municipal year 2026/2027. (Propo... Decided Open
29 Jul 2026 The plans listRESOLVED that planning permission be granted for non-material amendments. (Proposed by Cllr S Clist and seconded by C... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies