Cabinet: i. Approved the submission of the Outline Business Case (annexed to this Report) to the Government’s Joint Air Quality Unit thereby meeting the requirements of the Secretary of State’s legal direction of 27 July 2017. ii. Agreed that consultation be undertaken with the public and stakeholders throughout the pre-election period on the potential measures to be implemented to deliver compliance with legal limits for nitrogen dioxide in the Council’s administrative area in the shortest possible time as outlined in the Outline Business Case and in sections 3.10-3.11 of the report. iii. Delegated the approval of the final form of the appropriate consultation materials to be utilised to the Chief Executive in consultation with the Cabinet Member. iv. Agreed that officers be authorised to undertake further detailed analysis of range of measures that might be implemented including non-charging measures and – where appropriate – those highlighted as a result of the consultation process in order to inform a final decision as to which measures to implement. v. Noted that responses received as a result of the consultation process would be considered and further analysis would be undertaken. This would then feed into the preparation of a Full Business Case which would then, subject to Cabinet approval at the time, be submitted to government.
Word for word from the decision Newcastle published for this meeting.Source: democracy.newcastle.gov.uk
AIR QUALITY FEASIBILITY STUDY STRATEGIC CASE TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. STRATEGIC CASE 5 1.1 INTRODUCTION 5 1.2 POLICY CONTEXT 6 1.3 AIM AND ‘SPENDING OBJECTIVES’ 8 1.4 PUBLIC HEALTH, THE ECONOMY, AND ENABLING A FAIRER SOCIETY 8 1.5 ALIGNMENT WITH WIDER SCHEMES, POLICIES AND STRATEGIES 13 1.6 LOCAL TRANSPORT 15 1.7 AIR QUALITY IN THE TYNESIDE AREA 28 1.8 OPTIONS DEVELOPMENT 30 1.9 OPTION TESTING 35 1.10 TRAFFIC MODELLING APPROACH 36 1.11 AIR QUALITY MODELLING APPROACH 37 1.12 RESULTS 37 1.13 RESULTS ANALYSIS – AIR QUALITY 43 1.14 RESULTS ANALYSIS – TRANSPORT 43 1.15 INTEGRATED IMPACT ASSESSMENT 44 1.16 MITIGATION MEASURES FOR A CAZ D 49 1.17 FURTHER MEASURES 51 1.18 BENEFITS, RISKS, CONSTRAINTS AND DEPENDENCIES 51
APPENDICES 55
APPENDIX A1.0 – GLOSSARY 56
APPENDIX A1.1 – STAKEHOLDER LIST 61
APPENDIX A1.2 - TYNESIDE AIR QUALITY FEASIBILITY STUDY OPTIONS LONG-LIST 63
Tyneside Air Quality Feasibility Study Outline Business Case STRATEGIC CASE 15/02/2019 Page 2/67 LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1-1 North East Population by Income and Disability Decile 11 Figure 1-2 Key transport links, areas of high population and key employment areas 15 Figure 1-3 Origin/Destination of movements Northbound across the Tyne Bridge 16 Figure 1-4 Origin/Destination of movements Southbound across the Tyne Bridge 17 Figure 1-5– The Urban Core Distributor Road within Newcastle and Gateshead 18 Figure 1-6– Index of Multiple Deprivation 2015 deciles in Tyneside and the wider area 20 Figure 1-7– Non-compliant car ownership – Data source DVLA Data provided by JAQU, 2018 21 Figure 1-8– Non-compliant LGV ownership- Data source DVLA Data provided by JAQU, 2018 22 Figure 1-9– Household Car Ownership, by Lower Layer Super Output Area, 2011 Census 23 Figure 1-10 Taxi classification by Euro Class for Tyneside Local Authorities (2018) 25 Figure 1-11 Target Determination Area of Exceedance 29 Figure 1-12 Map of CAZ boundaries 35 Figure 1-13 Do Minimum Results 39 Figure 1-14 CAZ B Results 40 Figure 1-15 CAZ C Results 41 Figure 1-16 CAZ D Results 42 Figure 1-17 All CAZ Results – Changes in NO2 Concentration (Map) 45 Figure 1-19 All CAZ Results – Changes in NO2 Concentration (graphical) 46
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1-1 Charged CAZ Classes 7 Table 1-2 Mode split for journeys in the Tyneside Authorities, source 2011 Census 15 Table 1-3: Clean and Dirty Vehicle Breakdown 2017 19 Table 1-4 Percentage of non-compliant cars by IMD quintile 20 Table 1-5 Detailed considerations within Option Development 31 Table 1-6 Long List of Options Summary 32 Table 1-7 Scoring Matrix 33 Table 1-8 Do Something scenarios 34 Table 1-9 Do minimum Scenario 35 Table 1-10 2021 Compliant and Non-Compliant Split for Tyneside Vehicle Classification 37 Table 1-11: Number of LSOAs and population with an improvement or a deterioration of NO2 48 Table 1-12: Modelled NO2 concentration differentiated by IMD quintile 49 Table 1-13 Project Dependencies 52 Table 1-14 Project Constraints 54
Tyneside Air Quality Feasibility Study Outline Business Case STRATEGIC CASE 15/02/2019 Page 3/67 Please note, of the options outlined within government’s Clean Air Zone Framework and tested to date, a charging CAZ level D would bring about the greatest improvement in ground level concentrations of nitrogen dioxide by 2021 on the local roads government has identified. Of those tested, it is this CAZ level that would get the relevant limit values closest to compliance by 2021. As such, at this stage, we have ensured our Outline Business Case considers the implications and outlines the impacts of a Charging CAZ (class D) by 2021, while our consultation will also give consideration to charging levels, geographic scope, and other measures that may be required but which are subject to further analysis as outlined below.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.