CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Nottingham City Council
Executive Board, Tuesday 22 November 2022 at 2.00pm

Enviroenergy Tariff Increases for 2023

Refused Executive 2 papers

Executive Board refused this item on Tuesday 22 November 2022. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item66

Resolved

Resolved to a) set domestic heat tariffs at a daily standing charge of 0.3572 pence per day, and a Unit Charge of 0.0824 pence per kilowatt hour, applicable from 1st January 2023. b) set domestic electricity tariffs at a daily standing charge of 0.3680 pence per day, and a Unit Charge of 0.2722 pence per kilowatt hour, applicable from 1st January 2023. c) set commercial heat tariffs to rates detailed in the Exempt Appendix, applicable from 1st January 2023, unless otherwise determined by the supply contract in place. d) set commercial electricity tariffs to rates detailed in the Exempt Appendix, applicable from 1st January 2023, unless otherwise determined by the supply contract in place. e) delegate authority to the Director of Environment and Sustainability, in consultation with the Portfolio Holder for Energy, Environment and Waste Services, the Director of Legal and Governance and the Corporate Director for Finance & Resources to vary tariff charges as necessary to achieve statutory compliance with potential future legislative change regarding energy prices. · Reasons for Decisions Energy Prices for customers of the Council’s District Heating and Private Wire Networks are determined and applied annually from 1st January each year. Prices are determined through a combination of contractual indexation mechanisms, benchmarking the cost of energy against counterfactual wholesale energy markets and the expenditure required to operate and maintain the Combined Heat and Power plant and distribution networks providing energy to customers. The decisions also take account of the Council’s fuel poverty and carbon neutrality ambitions and reflect what is considered to fair and reasonable proposals. · Other Options Considered The table below presents options for increasing charges with a rationale for each. All options apply the calculated maximum Standing Charge for gas in line with the Government’s Energy Price Guarantee, with the exception of Option 6 which advocates applying RPI to both the current Enviroenergy Standing Charge and also the current Enviroenergy Unit Charge. Option Description Average % age Increase 1 Apply the OFGEM gas price cap rates announced on 26 th August 2022. 73.56% 2 Apply the Energy Price Guarantees’ maximum calculated Standing Charge and increase the maximum EPG Unit Charge by 15% for district heating efficiency. 58.08% 3 Apply both the Energy Price Guarantees’ maximum calculated Standing Charge and the EPG maximum Unit Charge. 41.60% 4 Apply the calculated “All-In” cost per kWh determined by the Energy Price Guarantee 21.84% 5 Apply the Energy Price Guarantees’ maximum calculated Standing Charge and increase the current Unit Charge by 20% 17.30% 6 Apply the Retail Price Index (RPI) to both the Standing Charge and Unit Charge 8.61% An analysis of these options is presented in the table below: Domestic Heat Tariff Options Standing charge per day (£) Unit Charge per kWh (£) “All in” Rate for average customer* (£) “All in” % age Increase for Average Customer Increase per week for Average Customer 1. OFGEM Price Cap 0.3572 0.1296 0.1586 73.56% £5.82 2. EPG + 15% on Unit Charge 0.3572 0.1155 0.1444 58.08% £4.59 3. Maximum EPG rates 0.3572 0.1004 0.1294 41.60% £3.29 4. Composite EPG All-In Rate 0.3572 0.0824 0.1113 21.84% £1.73 5. EPG Standing Charge + 20% increase on Unit Charge 0.3572 0.0782 0.1072 17.30% £1.37 6. RPI 0.3569 0.0721 0.1011 10.64% £0.84 * Based on average Enviroenergy domestic customer consumption Recommended option The recommendation presented is for Option 4 which price matches the “All In” rate per kWh calculated to match the gas Energy Price Guarantee when applied to an average East Midlands domestic gas consumer. In other words, based on average consumption, Enviroenergy customers would pay the same price per unit of energy as those on gas supply once the Standing Charge cost is factored into the total cost. However, the benefit to district heating customers is the comparative efficiency of district heating and gas boilers, a contributory factor towards why an Enviroenergy customer consumes less heat energy than their gas counterparty, and therefore why their annual heating costs also remain lower than the national average. The additional cost recommended is an additional 3½p per day on the Standing Charge and 1¾p per kWh on the Unit Rate. This represents an overall increase of 22% for the average Enviroenergy customer, with an additional weekly cost of £1.73 per week. If the recommendation is accepted, the average domestic district heating customer will have an annual predicted heating cost of £500, compared to the EPG cost for the same volume of gas, at £582. The fact that the average gas consumer uses 7,500 kWh of energy more per year than the average district heating customer reduces their “All In” costs to the same overall unit rate, despite their overall heating bill being much higher. For district heating customers, a higher than average consumption of district heat would reduce the “All In” unit cost, whilst lower than average consumption would increase it, albeit a higher proportion of this income is still secured as a Standing Charge. Options 1 to 3 are rejected on the basis that the composite “All-In” rates per kWh exceed those of the domestic gas Energy Price Guarantee, and Options 5 and 6 are rejected because they do not generate sufficient additional income to offset rising operating and maintenance costs of the scheme. Options for increasing Domestic Electricity Tariffs Whilst the customer base is relatively small (109 customers), current domestic electricity tariff charges for Enviroenergy customers reside significantly below the government Energy Price Guarantee for electricity. Options to increase domestic electricity tariffs are presented in the table below. Option Description Average % age Increase 1 Apply OFGEM price cap discounted by 15%. 152.2% 2 Apply the calculated “All-In” cost per kWh determined by the Energy Price Guarantee 96.2% 3 Apply a 20% reduction to the Standing Charge and Unit Rate determined by the Energy Price Guarantee 75.7% 4 Apply a 50% uplift to both the current Standing Charge and Unit Rate 50.0% Enviroenergy domestic power customers have no option but to remain with Enviroenergy unless the owners of the Atrium building meet the cost of establishing a separate connection to the National Grid which would enable other market providers to sell them power which would be at the full Energy Price Guarantee detailed in Option 2. The following table presents an analysis of the financial impact of each of the options if applied to the current domestic electricity customer base: Domestic Heat Tariff Options Standing charge per day (£) Unit Charge per kWh (£) “All in” Rate for average customer* (£) “All in” % age Increase for Average Customer Average increase per customer per week 1. OFGEM price cap minus 15% 0.4359 0.4117 0.5117 152.2% £9.45 2. Composite EPG All-In Rate 0.4600 0.2927 0.3982 96.2% £5.98 3. EPG Standing Charge and Unit Rate minus 20% 0.3680 0.2722 0.3566 75.7% £4.70 4. 50% increase on current rates 0.3402 0.2264 0.3044 50.0% £3.10 *Based on average Enviroenergy domestic customer consumption Recommended option The recommended option is Option 3 . Compared to the market, this price increase still provides value for money to customers as it is 20% below the Energy Price Guarantee. The Standing Charge therefore increases by 14p per day and the Unit Rate by 12p per kWh. Overall, this is a 75% increase over current costs, at an additional average weekly cost increase of £4.70.
Word for word from the decision Nottingham published for this meeting. Source: committee.nottinghamcity.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Nottingham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive Board
This report is being read into text

Papers are read newest first, so recent reports come through within hours. Until then, open it at source.

Open the PDF

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
for Enviroenergy Tariff Increases for 2023Appendix B 161 KB Copy on its way
PDF
Enviroenergy Tariff Increases for 2023Report 381 KB Copy on its way

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

13 of 17 attended
CB
Councillor Cheryl BarnardCommittee Member, apologies (on leave)
MB
Mel BarrettOfficer, present
KC
Councillor Kevin ClarkeNon-voting, present
CH
Clive HeaphyOfficer, present
FJ
Frank JordanOfficer, absent
NK
Councillor Neghat KhanCommittee Member, present
PK
Councillor Pavlos KotsonisCommittee Member, present
RL
Councillor Rebecca LangtonCommittee Member, present
SL
Councillor Sally LongfordCommittee Member, apologies (personal reasons)
DM
Councillor David MellenChair, present
TN
Councillor Toby NealCommittee Member, present
SR
Sajeeda RoseOfficer, present

All 17 on the meeting page

On this subject at Nottingham

Search all
  1. Enviroenergy Tariff Increases for 2023This decision
  2. Enviroenergy Tariff Increases for 2024Refused

More from Nottingham Executive Board

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
22 Sep 2026 Corporate Plan Delivery – Tranche 3Resolved to: (1) approve the proposals included within the paper; (2) delegate authority to the Section 151 Officer t... Approved Open
22 Sep 2026 Quarter 1 (Q1) Delivery Plan Performance ReportResolved to: (1) note the Q1 Delivery Plan Performance Update presented at Appendix A; (2) receive future updates of ... Noted Open
22 Sep 2026 Adult Social Care Strategy - Enabling Gloriously Ordinary LivesResolved to: (1) endorse, approve and adopt the Adult Social Care Strategy – Enabling Gloriously Ordinary lives 2026-... Approved Open
22 Sep 2026 HRA funded capital adaptations - Stairlifts, Step lifts, through-floor lifts and hoistsResolved to: (1) approve the request to procure and award a framework for HRA Specialist Equipment – mechanical; stai... Approved Open
22 Sep 2026 Recommissioning of Changing Futures Services in Nottingham - Key DecisionResolved to: (1) note that the Director of Public Health will vary the contract for the Changing Futures Main Deliver... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies