Item68
Resolved
Resolved to 1) approve a transfer of service undertakings from Nottingham Revenues and Benefits Ltd to the City Council on 1st April 2023, subject to the services being operated within the constraints of the Council’s budgets and any legal requirements. 2) delegate authority to the Chief Executive, in consultation with the Portfolio Holder for Finance, Chief Financial Officer and Head of Legal, to complete the financial, commercial and legal aspects of a service transfer to the Council on 1st April 2023 3) note that, following the Transfer of Services, the Limited Company will be taken through a managed closure whilst solvent. · Reasons for Decisions The use of a wholly owned company to deliver Revenues and Benefits services is not a commonly found arrangement and the additional structures of operating a company can be simplified through transfer to an in house delivery model. During the period in which the company has been operated as a Teckal arrangement, the governance associated with managing and monitoring a contract between the Council and company has required significant resources but has not demonstrated any greater value than the governance associated with an internal department. In addition, the need for a contractual arrangement has added a degree of inflexibility to the arrangement which, if removed, will allow greater potential for achievement of efficiencies and changes to operational practices. Integration into wider Customer and Business Support transformation programmes can be achieved through Service transfer. Resources are already in place to on-board NRB services into the transformation programme, providing an opportunity to achieve improved access to services for citizens. The Council has recently set out its framework for companies’ governance which required minimum standards of company board governance in line with recognised codes of practice. The company board currently has a number of key vacancies for directorships and in the near-term those standards will be challenging for the company to achieve in full. Investing in additional board directors will take time for both the Council and company, which could alternatively be used to pursue efficiencies and improvements under an in house arrangement. It is anticipated that there is an opportunity for significant cost reduction when the services are brought into the wider Customer and Business Support transformation programme. The transition is considered to be achievable in the time available, the current operating model relies on a number of key enabling services being delivered by the Council, such as payroll, accommodation, business systems, IT and telephony. Therefore, the platforms required to continue services as a Council department are largely in place. · Other Options Considered To retain the separate legal entity, extend the contract between NCC and the Company for the provision of Services and support the company to invest in its governance, Board capability and controls framework. This option is not considered suitable to achieve Best Value of the services to the Council or Citizens. Procurement of an alternative service provider through a market exercise; this option was rejected due to the timeframes associated with such a process and the current challenges the Council has faced in collating robust data on the current service and the business interest of the company. This option is not precluded by a transfer to in house and could be considered at a later date.
Word for word from the decision Nottingham published for this meeting.
Source: committee.nottinghamcity.gov.uk