Item75
Resolved
Resolved to (1) support the establishment, membership and resourcing of a Waste Transformation Board providing officer and external oversight and governance to the development of waste operations, waste disposal, depot, fleet and district heating services for the Council; (2) approve the key principles upon which the Waste Transformation Board will consider, direct and recommend actions to develop these services within the formal decision-making processes of the Council; (3) consider the future recommendations of the Board and to allocate appropriate financial resources within the 2024-25 MTFP to enable the activities and actions set out in the report to progress, cognisant of the critical programme path. Reasons for decision: · The Council is a statutory Waste Collection Authority (WCA) and Waste Disposal Authority (WDA), requiring it to collect and dispose of municipal waste, including household waste, within its administrative boundary. Its statutory obligation as a WCA/WDA extends to complying with specific regulations and statutory guidance which set out acceptable minimum standards of performance, but the Council also retains a level of flexibility in determining how to ensure that it complies with such obligations. Historically, WCA obligations have been delivered as an in-house service, whilst through legislative requirement, WDA functions have been externally commissioned. · Following extensive public consultation, in March 2023, the Council formally adopted a Municipal Resources and Waste Strategy setting out its key objectives in delivering its obligations as a WCA and WDA, including the delivery of high quality, customer focused waste management services that are accessible and inclusive. The Strategy also commits the Council to: o Manage wastes as resources, using the waste hierarchy as a guide: to prevent wastes arising in the first instance; then reuse; then recycle / compost; then recover energy, and finally, to dispose of waste as a last resort. o To reduce the amount of waste landfilled, working towards zero waste to landfill. o Continually seek to reduce carbon emissions to improve performance and contribute to the City and Council ambitions on carbon emissions. o ‘Lead from the front’ and improve the environmental performance of activities within Council buildings and via services it provides, including the management of waste and resources. o Work in partnerships with the community sector, private sector or other public sector bodies to expand the resource and expertise available to the municipal waste management service and engage with the residents and the customers of the service to promote environmental awareness and improve participation in waste reduction, re-use and recycling schemes. o Ensure that options facilitate / integrate the management of commercial, industrial and other wastes where it is environmentally, socially and economically feasible to do so. o Seek efficiencies and economies of scale through partnering and procurement to retain a cost-effective service. o Utilise and improve existing infrastructure where it can contribute to sustainable waste management and innovate in the development of new infrastructure where required. o Develop local solutions wherever practicable to minimise transport impacts of the service. The value of secondary raw materials / energy should be used locally where practicable. · Alongside the ambitions within the Strategy there are national drivers which require the Council to review how it collects and disposes of waste, both domestic and commercial: o The Environment Act 2021 presents new obligations on councils to deliver new minimum standards in delivery of their waste services. o The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) has produced statutory guidance under its “Simpler Recycling” plans which obligate councils to introduce weekly food waste collections, extend the range of waste materials to be separately collected for recycling, and encourage adoption of a minimum frequency of collections of residual (non-recyclable) waste in return for New Burdens funding to support the delivery of the improvements set out. o District Heating growth opportunities through DESNZ appraisal to be completed · Local Drivers include: o Need to drive a Waste Policy that clarifies service standards and expectations of residents, on how waste is to be presented. o Review of where subsidy exists within the service, for example, exploring charging arrangements where there is not a duty to collect such as garden waste. o Disposal contract arrangements and expiry dates (incinerator contract expires 2030) including option reviews for service independencies such as district heating. o Requirement to understand procurement needs for future disposal options – green waste, recycling, Household Waste Recycling Centre (HWRC). o Workforce Transformation and Culture. o Behavioural Change to optimise waste collections (the right waste in the right waste stream). o Member visibility of waste services. o Future resourcing requirements, fleet, training, depot. o Financial position of the Council. o Market Testing delivery options across the range of waste and district heating services. o Infrastructure investment is necessary as the existing District Heating Network heat station approaches the end of it’s economic life and parts and maintenance skill approach obsolescence. o To mitigate potential financial risks associated with the long term delivery of the city’s District Heating Network and our obligations to the network’s existing commercial and domestic customer base. · The financial position of the Council requires a fundamental review of the waste service provision to ensure that ambition and delivery deliver best value and are best use of public funds. · A primary strategic driver for the programme will be mitigating the significant financial challenges that the execution of our statutory waste duties and obligations to customers to deliver District Heating will present to the Council in the next decade. · The recommendations will require dedicated project teams, with the assistance of appropriate expert advisors, to develop improvements in the delivery of key Council waste services within a robust governance framework to ensure that the Council secures Best Value in the future delivery of those services. · The establishment of a Waste Transformation Board will ensure that there is appropriate assurance that the options available for future service delivery have been robustly developed and reviewed in the context of the financial, construction and technical risks of each option in the short, medium and longer term. · The strategic drivers for improving waste services resonate directly with the “One-Council” philosophy, requiring significant cultural change in the way that services are delivered and the way that service users access these essential services. Financial impact has traditionally driven decision making in the provision of waste services, such that whilst waste service costs are bottom quartile across English unitary authorities, service quality and recycling performance is also bottom quartile (least expensive per head of population). Consultation shows that 67% of customers are either very satisfied or fairly satisfied with all forms of household waste collections, whilst 71% are either very or fairly satisfied with the services received at the Household Waste and Recycling Centre. · The requirement to transform waste services to achieve Best Value will have direct implications for fleet and depot management, particularly the waste collection and street cleansing services currently operating out the Eastcroft Depot. Changes to the delivery model for waste collection, and the contracting arrangements for its disposal, require consideration of collection vehicle types and numbers, their associated fleet maintenance requirements and identification of other essential depot infrastructure required to ensure services are transformed to meet the objectives and principles set out in the report. Other options considered: · The option to not form a Waste Transformation Board was rejected on the basis that significant decisions would not be developed with appropriate corporate oversight and governance. The scale and significance of the decisions required for the services in scope are critical for the short, medium and long-term development of the Council’s statutory waste service functions and for decisions to be taken regarding the longer-term future of district heating in Nottingham. · Not allocating the appropriate resources to develop business cases for Waste Transformation options will not enable the Council to make informed decisions regarding the future of these services, potentially exposing the Council to unknown and unsustainable future costs without the security of appropriate arrangements in place to deliver Best Value.
Word for word from the decision Nottingham published for this meeting.
Source: committee.nottinghamcity.gov.uk