Item77
Resolved
Resolved to (1) agree that Sutton House be decommissioned from use as Independent Living accommodation; (2) agree that the outcome of consultation with tenants regarding decommissioning be considered; (3) agree that Sutton House be repurposed for use to provide temporary accommodation for homeless families; (4) note that the conversion works and decommissioning costs totalling £1,143,781 will be funded by the HRA Capital Programme and revenue respectively, and that this expenditure has been approved by the Section 151 Officer; (5) agree a Registered Provider (RP) be procured to lease the building from the Council for less than 21 years to manage the temporary accommodation (lease terms to be agreed by the Director of Economic Development & Property). Reasons for decision: · The Council has a statutory duty to provide TA to people in priority need who are facing homelessness and while they have their application for permanent housing assessed. Currently the Council utilises over 441 units of temporary accommodation (not including Bed & Breakfast). All this accommodation is full and there are currently an additional 185 households in B&B or Nightly Paid Temporary Accommodation (NPTA). · The demand for IL accommodation at Sutton House has been declining over recent years and therefore has been identified as needing an alternative use or declared surplus. Its current use means that it lends itself easily for conversion for use as temporary accommodation, which will keep costs to a minimum and can be provided relatively quickly. Other options considered: · Deliver a new build scheme instead of a refurbishment – this option has been discounted as this would be too costly and would take too long to deliver - B&B costs will be expended in the meantime. The existing building is in good condition so to demolish and rebuild would not only be expensive but would also have a significant carbon impact. · Sale of Sutton House on the open market for capital receipt – Although this option would benefit the Council with a capital receipt, the costs for providing TA through the use of B&B accommodation will still need to be found and the costs to decommission Sutton House will still need to be paid. There is also a risk that due to current market uncertainty the property may take time to sell, incurring holding costs. · Sale of the site to a developer with the requirement to deliver TA. This would likely result in an impairment issue due to the value of the site being less as TA reducing the amount of capital receipt compared to the value site for alternative development. · Do nothing – This option would result in a) the property continuing to operate even though demand is declining b) severe financial implications for the Council to continue paying B&B and NPTA costs c) the detrimental impact on families by placing them in unsuitable TA.
Word for word from the decision Nottingham published for this meeting.
Source: committee.nottinghamcity.gov.uk