Resolved
Resolved to (1) provide approval to procure LCVs for Housing Services Vehicle Replacement Programme (VRP) HRA capital spend of £10m over a 2-year programme; (2) delegate authority to the Corporate Director for Growth and City Development to procure and award contracts as set out within NCC Light Commercial Vehicle framework to the value of £10m. Reason for decisions: · Delegation of authority to purchase vehicles under the VRP will ensure the ongoing, cost-effective procurement of vehicles to support the Council’s front [1] line services and contribute to the wider low emissions targets being developed for the city. Other options considered: · Do not give approval to procure vehicles from the VRP. Not replacing Nottingham City Council’s fleet of vehicles would result in a false economy as capital savings realised in the first few years would be outweighed by increased services disruption to tenants, inability to meet our statutory and regulatory responsibilities as a social housing landlord, greater maintenance costs and downtime, higher emissions, non-compliance with operator’s licence conditions, lower sale income when the vehicles are sold and higher vehicle purchase costs when the current vehicles reach the end of life. The aging fleet is having a direct impact on tenant satisfaction measures (TSMs). Q3 2024/2025 report shows that dissatisfaction rose by 5p.p since the previous survey, from 15% to 20%. When tenants were asked to explain why they were dissatisfied they gave comments surrounding outstanding repairs and timescales for repairs. The outcome of the inspection by the Regulator of Social Housing in October 2024 concluded that “…there are serious failings in Nottingham City Council…and significant improvement is needed.” The aging fleet is having a direct negative impact on the issues raised in the report, in particular “reduce waiting times for new repairs requests”. · Lease rather than purchase. Long term lease has been considered but it not deemed value for money. On average, a LGV vehicle is leased for 9.5k per year which equates to an equivalent cost of approximately £29,070,000 for 340 vehicles over 9 years at today’s prices. This does not include associated costs expected for wear and tear at the end of the lease. On average, indicative costs show purchase price for a fully spec’d vehicle is 42k which equates to an equivalent cost of £14,280,000 for 340 vehicles which would have a residual value at the end of its expected 9-year life. · Procure an EV fleet. Consideration has been made to introduce a fully electric fleet but has not been deemed value for money due to Housing Services vehicles being “home start” which brings the following challenges. It would have a negative impact on the service provided to tenants to move the housing fleet to be a depot-based fleet. This is due to downtime required between depot and first/last appointment. Furthermore, there is a logistical and environmental impact to require parking for 300+ fleet/personal vehicles. Smart home charging units would need to be installed (average cost £1200 per unit) – anticipating an additional cost of 450k. A “home charging policy” would be required to determine ownership of the unit, insurance risks, taxable benefits, and who would be responsible for repairs and maintenance. 25% of housing services drivers do not have a driveway at home to allow the installation of a home charger. Installation of chargers for new starters and removal for leavers would need to be factored into onboarding and budgets as an ongoing cost. There is no method of re-imbursing drivers for the electricity used to charge their works vehicle. Lack of availability of rapid chargers to support charging a 300+ EV fleet during working hours, there are zero rapid D2N2 network charging points within the Nottingham city boundary available for fleet use. All other chargers within the network are 4hr charge times. There is no single charge card accessing the myriads of EV networks. · Do not delegate authority to the Corporate Director for Growth and City Development to approve procurement of vehicles. This option would result in ongoing inefficiencies and delays in providing vehicles by not streamlining the day-to-day management of the approved VRP budget to the appropriate level of senior management, risking delays to replacement process, service disruption and incurring additional costs and potential increase in maintenance or external hire costs.