CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Oldham Metropolitan Borough Council
Cabinet, Monday 22 July 2019 at 6.00pm

Library Fines

Decided Executive 1 paper

Cabinet decided this item on Monday 22 July 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item8

Resolved

RESOLVED that library fines be abolished.
Word for word from the decision Oldham published for this meeting. Source: committees.oldham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Oldham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Reason for decision

The proposal to remove library fines would impact on library services in all wards and remove barriers to information, resources and opportunities for some of the most deprived communities in Oldham.

Executive summary

There is a current debate within public libraries concerning the negative impact of charging fines for the late return of books. Evidence suggests that fines can become a barrier to accessing library services rather than an incentive to return books on time and that those that can afford to pay the fines continue to use the service, whilst those that are arguably in most need of the service, from deprived communities, are then barred and discouraged from using the service.

This report outlines the arguments for and against the employment of library fines.

Recommendations

This report recommends that Cabinet consider the arguments for and against the removal of library fines and approves Option 2a To abolish library fines. Cabinet 22nd July 2019

Library Fines

Background

1.1Fines have been used in libraries for many years primarily as means of controlling stock by ensuring that books are returned, and returned on time, for the benefit of other users. However, recent investigations in to the impact of library fines show that financial penalties might not be an effective influence on behaviour and that, for some sections of the community, fines might in effect become a deterrent to library usage.

1.2It is common practice in libraries across the country not to apply fines for children and, in some cases other groups such as the elderly and library amnesties take place, whereby outstanding fines are removed for the return of over-due stock. Although amnesties can lead to a considerable amount of stock return, they are expensive and time consuming to undertake and there is no evidence that users who had accumulated fines will not do so again.

1.3It is universally accepted that reading is critical to personal development and wellbeing. The positive impacts on educational attainment and consequent economic benefits are well known but reading can also engender empathy and lower rates of stress and depression (Appendix 1 Benefits of reading and references). Nowadays, libraries are not just about reading and learning. Welcoming and accessible and based in our communities, they are now portals to a wide range of other services, information and opportunities.

2 Current Position

2.1The national picture: A growing number of Libraries in the UK have abolished fines altogether over the last couple of years.

Angus – Abolished overdue fines in December 2015 with no reported negative impact on return of stock (source: Fiona Dakers, Senior Manager, who also says “The positive impact has been enhancing our public image as a progressive and inclusive service and our teams no longer having the negative interactions with customers “).

Halton – have abolished fines for a trail period of one year from 8th Jan 2019. https://hbcnewsroom.co.uk/library-fines-abiolished/

Kirklees – library fines removed from 29th Dec 2018. https://kirkleestogether.co.uk/2018/12/19/not-quite-finished-that-book-our-libraries-are-stopping- fines-for-late-returns/

Rutland –The first in the UK to abolish fines.

Trafford – Abolished April 2018. “In a first for a UK borough, the council said in a statement that fines can be “off-putting for customers”, and it hopes the change, which will see library fines eliminated across Trafford for all ages from April, will lead to “a further increase in usage of libraries across the borough”.” Trafford were taking £31,000 in fines 2016/17.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Library FinesReport 1.2 MB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

7 of 22 attended
AC
Amanda ChaddertonCommittee Member, present
ZC
Zahid ChauhanCommittee Member, present
LD
Liz DroganSecretary, expected
PE
Paul EntwistleOfficer, expected
SF
Sean FieldingChair, present
LG
Lewis GreenwoodOfficer, expected
AJ
Abdul Jabbar MBECommittee Member, apologies
MJ
Merlin JosephOfficer, expected
HL
Helen LockwoodOfficer, expected
EM
Ellen Marchbank-SmithOfficer, expected
SM
Shaid MushtaqCommittee Member, present
JR
Justine RaceOfficer, expected

All 22 on the meeting page

More from Oldham Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
23 Mar 2026 MinutesThat the minutes of the meeting of the Cabinet held on 23 rd February 2026, be approved as a correct record. Approved Open
23 Mar 2026 Adult Social Care CQC Assessment OutcomeThat the report be noted and welcomed. 2. That the congratulations of the Cabinet be extended to the Deputy Chief Exe... Noted Open
23 Mar 2026 Extension to the Adult Social Care Service Level Agreement with Miocare Group CIC 2026That the Cabinet: 1. Approves the Service Level Agreement with Miocare Group CIC. 2. Approves the refreshed Service L... Approved Open
23 Mar 2026 Proposal to update Smokefree policyThat the Council revise and update its smokefree policy, in line with the narrative detailed in the submitted report ... Decided Open
23 Mar 2026 Extension of the Current Commissioning Arrangements for Care at HomeThat the Cabinet approves a three-month extension of the current contracts for Care at Home, Extra Care and Night Pro... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies