Resolved
That the Cabinet would consider the commercially sensitive information contained at item 17 of the agenda before making a decision .
Cabinet decided this item on Monday 24 July 2023. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
That the Cabinet would consider the commercially sensitive information contained at item 17 of the agenda before making a decision .
To confirm settlement to the Notice issued by ForHousing on 28th September 2022, notifying the Council of purported breaches of the environmental warranties in the Transfer Agreement between the Council and Villages Housing Association in 2004.
To authorise the Director of Legal Services or their nominated representative to sign and/or affix the Common Seal of the Council to all documents required to bring effect to the recommendations in this Report. Cabinet 24 July 2023
Environmental Warranty at Fitton Hill
1.1Cabinet approved the disposal of land at Fitton Hill to Countryside in March 2020. The land is being sold in partnership with ForHousing who own 43.28% compared to the Council’s 56.72% holding. Sales proceeds were split accordingly.
1.2Countryside reserved the right to complete further Site Investigations and revise the offer accordingly. An independent report by Savills was commissioned by the Council and ForHousing which confirmed these additional costs were reasonable and justified.
2. Current Position
2.1Part of the land which ForHousing have sold was formerly owned by the Council. This land was acquired by The Village Housing Association Limited from the Council in 2004 via a small-scale stock transfer. In the relevant transfer agreement, the Council provided a warranty to The Village Housing Association Limited which effectively confirmed that there was no contamination in the relevant land. In 2019 The Village Housing Association Limited merged into City West Housing Trust, which was renamed ForHousing Limited.
2.2The claim is based on a report ForHousing commissioned from Arup that concluded certain abnormal costs identified by Countryside could form the basis of a claim under the Warranties (namely those abnormal costs arising in respect of soil contamination and ground gas at the Property).
2.3A Notice of Breach dated 28 September 2022 was served on the Council.
2.4The Council subsequently instructed Ramboll to provide a technical review of the Arup Report (including a review of the e3p Reports), to confirm whether the conclusions reached in the Arup Report can be accepted by OBC (i.e.whether Arup’s identification and valuation of the abnormal costs covered under the Warranties is fair and reasonable). The report issued by Ramboll on 23 March 2023 confirmed that:
The rates applied as mitigation are reasonable; and
The pro-rata calculation applied by Arup on behalf of ForHousing is correct.
2.5The Council has been advised on this issue by Pinsent Masons. After accessing relevant information their assessment recommends that:
The Notice of Breach is valid; ForHousing has the benefit of the Warranties; and the Warranties apply;
The Council ought to satisfy ForHousing’s Notice of Breach by remedying the breach.
3 Options/Alternatives
3.1Option 1 – Settle the Claim
Based on the information above, the Council provided a Warranty when the land was transferred to Villages in 2004. Now that the sale to Countryside has been completed, the
2 claim against the Council has been crystallised. The quantum of this claim has been independently verified as accurate.
3.2Option 2 – Fight the claim
Challenge the claim. The Council has no grounds to defend the claim and would only incur additional legal costs should this option be pursued.
4 Preferred Option
4.1Option 1 is the preferred option for the reasons outlined above.
5.1The Lead Member for Housing has been briefed.
6.1Contained within the Part B Report
(James Postle)
7 Legal Services Comments
7.1Contained within the Part B Report. (Rebecca Boyle, Corporate Group Solicitor).
8. Co-operative Agenda
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Environmental Warranty at Fitton HillReport | 157 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Cabinet at Oldham and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Mar 2026 | MinutesThat the minutes of the meeting of the Cabinet held on 23 rd February 2026, be approved as a correct record. | Approved | Open |
| 23 Mar 2026 | Adult Social Care CQC Assessment OutcomeThat the report be noted and welcomed. 2. That the congratulations of the Cabinet be extended to the Deputy Chief Exe... | Noted | Open |
| 23 Mar 2026 | Extension to the Adult Social Care Service Level Agreement with Miocare Group CIC 2026That the Cabinet: 1. Approves the Service Level Agreement with Miocare Group CIC. 2. Approves the refreshed Service L... | Approved | Open |
| 23 Mar 2026 | Proposal to update Smokefree policyThat the Council revise and update its smokefree policy, in line with the narrative detailed in the submitted report ... | Decided | Open |
| 23 Mar 2026 | Extension of the Current Commissioning Arrangements for Care at HomeThat the Cabinet approves a three-month extension of the current contracts for Care at Home, Extra Care and Night Pro... | Approved | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.