That the harm is outweighed by the benefits and the application be minded to approve and be brought back to committee for appropriate conditions. (Brian Sumner spoke in favour of the above application. Cllr Mark Hindle was given permission to speak on the above application)
Word for word from the decision Ribble Valley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.ribblevalley.gov.uk
DEMOLITION OF EXISTING BRICK BUILT LEAN-TO AND REPLACEMENT WITH NEW EXTENSION, FENCING TO CREATE OUTDOOR PLAY AREA FOR PRE-SCHOOL, INTERNAL ALTERATIONS TO PROVIDE DISABLED LIFT, FIRST FLOOR CLASSROOM, IMPROVED TOILET AREAS, PRE-SCHOOL LEADERS OFFICE AND ASSOCIATED WORKS. RESUBMISSION OF 3/2021/0006 AT OLD GRAMMAR SCHOOL COMMUNITY CENTRE STATION ROAD WHALLEY BB7 9RH
CONSULTEE RESPONSES/ REPRESENTATIONS MADE:
PARISH COUNCIL:
Appreciates that listed buildings must be protected from unnecessary changes. Hope that revised plans accommodate RVBC concerns. Building serves the whole of the Ribble Valley and wish to see facility last. HISTORIC AMENITY SOCIETIES:
Consulted, no comments received.
LCC ARCHAEOLOGY:
No objection. Proposed changes to the interior and exterior will continue the cycle of alterations and adaptions to keep the site in educational use. With exception of the proposed external play area, none of the changes appear to have a substantial impact on significance.
Outdoor play area - proposed glass barrier is not an improvement on railings and may be more obtrusive against the historic stonework and thus have a bigger impact on the setting of the listed building. Suggest reconsideration (height; justification of design and visual impact). Also – any play equipment, games, decorations, planters or storage painted on or fixed to the building.
Planning condition unnecessary if Heritage Statement and Schedule of Architectural Features formally submitted to the Historic Environment Record.
HISTORIC ENGLAND:
Do not wish to comment. Suggest seeking the views of the RVBC specialist conservation adviser.
LCC HIGHWAYS:
Consulted, response will be reported verbally to Committee.
RVBC COUNTRYSIDE:
Consulted, response will be reported verbally to Committee.
RVBC ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH:
Consulted, response will be reported verbally to Committee.
ADDITIONAL REPRESENTATIONS:
None received.
1. Site Description and Surrounding Area
1.1‘Old Grammar School’ is a Grade II listed (13 March 1986) former grammar school (now ‘adult education centre’ – list description), prominently sited within Whalley Conservation Area. The Ribble Valley Core Strategy Housing and Economic Development DPD Proposals Map identifies the site to be ‘Existing Open Space’ (Policy DMB4) and to adjoin (but be outside of) the ‘Main Centre Boundary’ (Policy DMR2).
1.2The Old Grammar School is immediately adjacent to and within the setting of Whalley War Memorial (Grade II listed; list description identifies “An elegant example of the type, the war memorial has group value with the school behind and possesses civic presence”). It is also within the setting of 82 King Street (Grade II).
wall” (Whalley Conservation Area Management Guidance: Boundary Treatments). 2. Proposed Development for which Consent is Sought
2.1Planning permission is sought for:
Demolition of existing modern brick-built extension (built 1882 – 1912) to the west elevation and replacement extension. The proposal (stone walls and slate roof) is wider than existing and similarly conjoins the two plain historic gables and has the highest part of its roof in the recess between historic gables. Its windows have a horizontal emphasis at odds with the historic build.
A rooflight is proposed to the roof within the recess.
Glazed screen to create outdoor play area for pre-school at the original 1725 south front. This is shown to be 1.8m high and to obscure views of three of the 5 ground-floor bays/cruciform windows to the 1725 front. No details submitted of fixture to the ground or walls.
Reinstatement of the window in the east elevation and reinstatement of a doorway in the south elevation.
The submitted plans show that the car park historic gateposts will be removed to widen the entrance. However, no information justifying this is submitted.
3. Relevant Planning History
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.