It was RESOLVED that: a) the findings of the Bingham Leisure Centre options appraisal and feasibility study and the associated significant financial implications, be noted. b) detailed investigations of the feasibility of constructing a new leisure centre at Chapel Lane, Bingham on land owned by the Council as part of a wider commercial development of the site, be commenced. c) £40,000 be allocated from the investment and regeneration project budget to undertake a business case feasibility study, site investigations, and design works for an integrated leisure and commercial development of the site. d) a further report be brought to Cabinet before the end of financial year 2018/19 covering the financial, business and community outcomes of an integrated leisure and commercial development at Chapel Lane.
Word for word from the decision Rushcliffe published for this meeting.Source: democracy.rushcliffe.gov.uk
1.1In June 2017, Cabinet approved the Rushcliffe Borough Council Leisure Facilities Strategy 2017-2027. This contains the strategic objective to ‘retain five indoor leisure facilities and ensure they are fit for the future’. The strategy prioritises Bingham Leisure Centre as the facility in greatest need of major improvement.
1.2Specialist leisure consultancy Knight Kavanagh and Page (KKP) was appointed in November 2017 to undertake a detailed feasibility study and options appraisal of potential locations for a new leisure centre and the associated financial, operational and technical implications.
1.3The feasibility study involved consultation with key stakeholders and sports clubs operating from the current facility and dovetailed with the wider Bingham master-planning process which aims to set a vision of how the town should develop over time and proposals for how this could be achieved.
1.4The feasibility study considered four potential alternative locations on the Toot Hill School site and concluded that all of the identified locations have significant challenges such as access, proximity to housing, topography and impact on curriculum delivery/school bus parking, all of which impact on the cost of development. The only option not specifically considered in detail is to develop a new stand-alone facility off the school grounds. It is recommended that this is tested further and given the planned housing growth within the town the available Council owned land adjacent to Chapel lane (north of the railway line) should be considered.
1.5The capital construction and fit-out cost (including professional fees and contingency) was estimated for two different facility mixes. Facility mix 1 includes a 5-court sports hall, community hall, swimming pool, fitness gym, exercise studios, changing and office space and replacement athletics track/infield. The high level cost estimate for this facility on the school site is £20.5m to £21.4m dependent upon location, increasing by around £1.9m when inflation is accounted for over a period of 2 years.
Facility mix 2 includes the above facilities minus the sports hall and replacement track and infield. The high level cost estimate for facility mix 2 off the school site is £16.1m plus inflation estimated at £1.4m over 2 years. It is anticipated that provision of the existing sports hall, track and pitches would remain on the school site.
1.6The financial outturn for facility mix 1 is estimated to return a surplus of £188,000 per annum including an annualised maintenance replacement cost, which acts as a sinking fund to replace all equipment and plant, ensuring the ongoing high quality of the facility. Facility mix 2 is estimated to return an annual surplus of £104,000 including annualised maintenance replacement cost.
1.7The Council has diminishing capital resources and borrowing would be required. Based on a PWLB loan at 2.82% over 40 years (for the full cost of development) annual repayments would be in the region of £944,000 for facility mix 1 or £709,000 for facility mix 2. Assuming the retained surplus was retained by the Council for facility mix 2 this would give a net cost to the Council of £605,000 and place significant financial pressures on the Council’s budget going forward. It is expected the wider commercial development of Chapel Lane may offset at least some of these costs, with further work required to determine this. These costs would reduce in line with any external funding secured such as section 106 developer contributions or Sport England grant.
Recommendation
It is RECOMMENDED that Cabinet:
a) Note the findings of the Bingham Leisure Centre options appraisal and feasibility study and associated significant financial implications;
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.