CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Shropshire Council
Cabinet, Wednesday 30 June 2021 at 10.00am

Whitchurch Swimming Centre Options Report

Approved Executive 4 papers

Cabinet approved this item on Wednesday 30 June 2021. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item9

Resolved

to I. Approve that option 6 is the emerging preferred option and should be taken forward to the next stage of feasibility and due diligence. II. Delegate to the Executive Director of Place, in consultation with the Leader and the Portfolio Holder for Communities, Place, Tourism and Transport , the ability to progress the feasibility and due diligence on the emerging new build option, including: · Project requirements prepared. · Accommodation Schedule. · Further review of the business case. · Undertake site appraisals to develop opportunities and constraints diagrams to identify opportunities and initial key project risks. · Strategic appraisal of planning considerations. · Prepare project brief including outcomes. · Commissioning relevant surveys. · Development of block plans. · Quantity Surveyor costings. · Programming. · Prepare initial block massing 3D views and sections to explain relationship with the existing building and scale of proposal/s. · Prepare precedent image and concept images for the proposal. · Developing Project Strategies · Pre-application Planning Advice. · Implementation of a public/stakeholder engagement/consultation exercise. III. Approve that the additional feasibility work includes a needs assessment for a new library facility in Whitchurch and, also explores the potential for and, cost/benefits of co-locating the library in any new leisure facility development on the site. Noting that if co-locating the library emerges as part of the preferred option a specific public consultation on this will be required. IV. Agree that the findings of the additional feasibility work be reported back to a future cabinet meeting. to I. Approve that option 6 is the emerging preferred option and should be taken forward to the next stage of feasibility and due diligence. II. Delegate to the Executive Director of Place, in consultation with the Leader and the Portfolio Holder for Communities, Place, Tourism and Transport , the ability to progress the feasibility and due diligence on the emerging new build option, including: · Project requirements prepared. · Accommodation Schedule. · Further review of the business case. · Undertake site appraisals to develop opportunities and constraints diagrams to identify opportunities and initial key project risks. · Strategic appraisal of planning considerations. · Prepare project brief including outcomes. · Commissioning relevant surveys. · Development of block plans. · Quantity Surveyor costings. · Programming. · Prepare initial block massing 3D views and sections to explain relationship with the existing building and scale of proposal/s. · Prepare precedent image and concept images for the proposal. · Developing Project Strategies · Pre-application Planning Advice. · Implementation of a public/stakeholder engagement/consultation exercise. III. Approve that the additional feasibility work includes a needs assessment for a new library facility in Whitchurch and, also explores the potential for and, cost/benefits of co-locating the library in any new leisure facility development on the site. Noting that if co-locating the library emerges as part of the preferred option a specific public consultation on this will be required. IV. Agree that the findings of the additional feasibility work be reported back to a future cabinet meeting.
Word for word from the decision Shropshire published for this meeting. Source: www.shropshire.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Shropshire's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Summary

1.1Built in 1972, Whitchurch Swimming Centre comprises a 25m x 5 lane pool and changing facilities. The facility is currently operated by Shropshire Community Leisure Trust.

1.2This report provides an update on the condition of the centre and options for consideration regarding the future provision of this important community facility. The centre has been closed since March 2020, initially due to the national lockdown as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic, and further to that as a result of the structural problems identified whilst investigating the cause of a leak from the pool tank which include underpinning issues and deterioration in the fabric of the building.

1.3Property Services Group has commissioned investigation work to identify the immediate, medium and, longer term maintenance requirements and costs associated with these to be able to re-open the existing facility and maintain it to an acceptable standard. The maintenance requirements report is attached at Appendix 1. Further structural investigation work has also taken place which has resulted in the structural engineer stating:

“We caution that the swimming pool is likely to continue to settle due to the inadequate foundations to the swimming pool and structure. Further cracking and lifting of tiles to the pool and pool surround will continue to occur. Whilst further remedial works can be undertaken to address issues at movement joints, lifting tiles, etc we advise that this is not considered cost effective due to the inadequate foundations and the age of the structure Consideration should be given to the whole life cost of a replacement building and pool over the ongoing running and maintenance costs of the existing facility”.

1.4Alongside the maintenance investigation works an outline feasibility study was commissioned, through Strategic Leisure Ltd, to review the business case for investment in a new facility to be able to compare this option with carrying out the necessary repairs on the existing facility. The study is attached at Appendix 2. (Please note that Strategic Leisure used a capital borrowing rate of 4%. Table 2 in this report contains the cost of borrowing calculation via the Public Works Loan Board at 2.5%).

1.5The following options have been considered and are reviewed in more detail in this report:

1. Option 1 - Do nothing 2. Option 2 - Instigate the required repair and maintenance works 3. Option 3 - New traditional build – 6 lane x 25m with moveable floor, Café 15 covers 4. Option 4 - New traditional build - 6 lane x 25m with moveable floor, 35 station fitness suite, Café 20 covers 5. Option 5 - New traditional build – 6 lane x 25m with moveable floor, 35 station fitness suite, dance studio, Café 20 covers

1 6. Option 6 - New alternative build - 6 lane x 25m with moveable floor, 35 station fitness suite, dance studio, Café 20 covers

1.6The development of a new leisure facility on the current site has the potential to co-locate the town’s library within the development and it is recommended that this be considered in more detail as part of any additional feasibility study agreed for the site. It should be noted that if co-locating the library emerges as part of the preferred option a specific public consultation on this will be required.

1.7Based on their ability to meet the strategic outcomes, option 6 looks to meet the greatest range, but officers need to test the deliverability and affordability of the new build options to further understand the potential to meet the outcomes, costs and ability to generate increased participation and income.

Recommendations

2.1Cabinet is therefore asked to:

I. Approve that option 6 is the emerging preferred option and should be taken forward to the next stage of feasibility and due diligence.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Whitchurch Swimming Centre Building Survey Report April 21 Rev 2.0Appendix 1 4.6 MB Download
PDF
Whitchurch Cost EstimateAppendix 2 719 KB Download
PDF
Shropshire Council: Whitchurch Swimming Centre: Outline Feasibility StudyAppendix 2 1.2 MB Download
PDF
Whitchurch Swimming Centre Options ReportReport 938 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 16 attended
LP
Lezley PictonLeader, present
SC
Steve CharmleyDeputy Leader, present
GB
Gwilym ButlerCommittee Member, present
DC
Dean CarrollCommittee Member, present
RG
Rob GittinsCommittee Member, present
KH
Kirstie Hurst-KnightCommittee Member, present
CM
Cecilia MotleyCommittee Member, present
IN
Ian NellinsCommittee Member, apologies
EP
Ed PotterCommittee Member, present
JW
James WaltonOfficer, expected
MB
Mark BarrowOfficer, expected
AB
Andy BegleyOfficer, expected

All 16 on the meeting page

On this subject at Shropshire

Search all
  1. Whitchurch Swimming Centre Options ReportThis decision
  2. Whitchurch Swimming Pool - Agreement for CIL FundingApproved
  3. Whitchurch Swimming and Fitness CentreAgreed
  4. Whitchurch Swimming and Fitness CentreAgreed
  5. Whitchurch Swimming Centre Feasibility StudyNoted

More from Shropshire Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
18 Nov 2026 MinutesThat the minutes of the meeting held on 14 October 2026 be confirmed as an accurate record. Decided Open
18 Nov 2026 Crisis & Resilience Fund – 6-month Progress UpdateThat Cabinet: 1. Endorsed the summary of the wider economic environment and the Council’s borrowings and investments ... Decided Open
18 Nov 2026 Council Tax Support - Proposed Changes 2027-28 Consultation ResponsesThat Cabinet: 1. Considered the responses received to the statutory consultation. 2. Agreed the following changes to ... Agreed Open
18 Nov 2026 Financial Monitoring Report Quarter 2 2026/27That Cabinet: A. Supported the Q2 favourable revenue outturn forecast of £0.051m. B. Supported the significant advers... Noted Open
18 Nov 2026 Treasury Management Update Quarter 2 2026/27That Cabinet: 1. Endorsed the summary of the wider economic environment and the Council’s borrowings and investments ... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies