RESOLVED The Audit Committee: (i) Noted the issues highlighted as part of the certification work for the Housing Benefit subsidy claim for 2016/17, as well as the subsequent actions taken; and (ii) Requested to receive an update on progress against these actions within the next 6 months.
Word for word from the decision Solihull published for this meeting.Source: democracy.solihull.gov.uk
1.1To update Audit Committee on the report on the 2016/17 Housing Benefit subsidy claim.
2. Decision(s) recommended
2.1To note the issues highlighted and subsequent actions taken.
3. What is the issue?
3.1Grant Thornton has certified the Housing Benefit subsidy claim submitted by the Council for the financial year 2016/17 relating to subsidy claimed of £57.5 million as confirmed by their report.
3.2Housing Benefit entitlement is calculated using a set of guidelines that are open to interpretation for each individual claim. With a Housing Benefit caseload of 11,000 which generate a high volume of changes it is not feasible to check every change and we had a 5% checking regime in place. However in light of this report we have reviewed this as detailed at point 3.7
3.3Their testing of 276 individual claims identified 94 errors (34% error rate). Whilst this is an increase on previous years, it does not mean that 34% of all cases are incorrect. The sample of cases tested by our internal auditors last year identified no errors and we gained an Audit assurance level of 2 which is substantial.
3.4Each year the auditor will target the type of errors identified in the previous years audit and ask us to test a larger sample of those types of claims. In this case the errors were in two areas, how we calculate average wages for those customers who are working and what type of overpayment we create if someone’s circumstances change.
3.5The errors relating to how we calculated average earnings are shown below (please note these figures relate to the lifetime of each claim and are not weekly figures) and it is worth noting that the majority of the errors on these cases relate to one individual assessor who no longer works for the Council. All cases have been corrected and any adjustments have been paid
11 overpayments of benefit ranging between 13p and £120.00 11 underpayments of benefit ranging between £15.94 to £360.57 3 errors had no effect on the amount of benefit due
3.5DWP in conjunction with HMRC have recently automated the process for informing Housing Benefit teams of changes to customers’ earned income and this will reduce the risk of errors on these cases.
3.6The 69 errors associated with how we classify the reason for an overpayment did not result in any over or under payments of benefit but did result in a reduction of housing benefit subsidy claimed. The result of all errors identified was that the 2016/17 claim was overstated by £8,956 which is a 0.02% of the total £57.5 million claimed. As a result a reduction of £8,956 has been made to the amount to be paid for the interim 2017/18 subsidy. This is because different categories of overpayments attract different subsidy rates.
3.7In order to ensure these areas are resolved before we submit next years Housing Benefit subsidy claim and to ensure appropriate controls are in place we have
a) appointed a full time Housing Benefit subsidy officer with expert technical knowledge and experience b) increased the amount of cases checked within this financial year across all areas c) increased the amount of checks to new and existing claims with earned income d) retrained all of the benefit assessors in the calculation of earned income and correct classifications of overpayments e) checked all overpayment classification cases created
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Annual Report on Internal AuditRESOLVED Audit Committee: Noted the work of Internal Audit for 2025/26, detailed within the report, including the Hea...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.