CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Southend-on-Sea Borough Council
Development Control Committee, Wednesday 7 February 2018 at 2.00pm

17/01738/FULM - 193 Thorpe Hall Avenue, Thorpe Bay, Essex, SS1 3AP (Thorpe Ward)

Refused Planning 6 papers

Development Control Committee refused this item on Wednesday 7 February 2018. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item718

Resolved

- That planning permission be REFUSED for the following reasons: 01 The proposed development is located within a high flood risk zone (flood zone 3a), and insufficient information has been submitted to demonstrate that the development will be safe for future occupiers over its lifetime. The development is therefore considered to fail the exceptions test and would be unacceptable and contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework, and Policies KP1 and KP2 of the Core Strategy (2007). 02 The proposed development by reason of its height and excessive bulk coupled with its insufficient degree of set back from the site frontages and its bland, overly functional design and appearance including poor articulation and architectural quality, would appear as an overly dominant, obtrusive and incongruous development that is out of keeping with and detrimental to the prevailing character and appearance of the streetscene and the surrounding area. This is unacceptable and contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework, Core Strategy (2007) Policies KP2 and CP4, Policies DM1 and DM3 of the Development Management Document (2015) and advice contained within the Design and Townscape Guide (2009). 03 The proposed development by reason of insufficient provision of on-site parking would cause additional on street parking in the surrounding area to the detriment of highway safety and the operation of the local highway network. This is unacceptable and contrary to guidance contained within the National Planning Policy Framework (Section 4), Development Management Document (2015) Policy DM15, Core Strategy (2007) Policy CP3 and advice contained within the Design and Townscape Guide (2009). 04 The proposal, by reason of the limited useable amenity space provided for future occupants would result in a poor living environment for future occupiers of the proposed development. This is unacceptable and contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework (2012), Policies KP2 and CP4 of the Core Strategy (2007), Policies DM1 and DM8 of the Development Management Document (2015) and National Technical Housing Standards DCLG 2015. 05 The application does not include a formal undertaking to secure a contribution to affordable housing provision to meet the demand for such housing in the area despite it having been found financially viable for the development proposed to make such a contribution. The application is therefore unacceptable and contrary to Core Strategy policies CP8 and KP3 and Policy DM7 of the Development Management Document 2015. The Local Planning Authority has acted positively and proactively in determining this application by identifying matters of concern with the proposal and determining the application within a timely manner, clearly setting out the reason(s) for refusal, allowing the Applicant the opportunity to consider the harm caused and whether or not it can be remedied by a revision to the proposal. The detailed analysis is set out in ... view the full minutes text for item 718.
Word for word from the decision Southend-on-Sea published for this meeting. Source: democracy.southend.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Southend-on-Sea's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Control Committee

Reference: 17/01738/FULM

Ward: Thorpe

Demolish existing dwellinghouses at 193 and 195 Thorpe Hall Avenue and erect a three storey building comprising of Proposal: 33No. retirement apartments, install vehicular access onto Woodgrange Drive, layout car parking at rear and landscaping.

Address: 193 Thorpe Hall Avenue, Thorpe Bay, Essex, SS1 3AP

Applicant: Churchill Retirement Living

Agent: Planning Issues Ltd

Consultation Expiry: 24.11.2017

Expiry Date: 01.02.2018

Case Officer: Janine Rowley

40028-TB-PL10; 40028-TB-PL11; 40028-TB-PL12; 40028- TB-PL13; 40028-TB-PL14; 40028-TB-PL15; 40028-TB-PL16; Plan Nos: 40028-TB-PL17; 40028-TB-PL18; 40028-TB-PL19; 40028- TB-PL20; 40028-TB-Roof

Recommendation: REFUSE PLANNING PERMISSION

Development Control Report 1 The Proposal

1.1Planning permission is sought to demolish existing dwellinghouses at 193 and 195 Thorpe Hall Avenue and erect a three storey building comprising 33 retirement apartments, install a vehicular access onto Woodgrange Drive, layout car parking to the rear and provide landscaping.

1.2The existing two storey dwellinghouses to be demolished are a 5 bedroom property at 193 Thorpe Hall Avenue and a 4 bedroom property at 195 Thorpe Hall Avenue.

1.3The building proposed is ‘L’ shape 35m wide where fronting Woodgrange Drive to the north and 36m in depth fronting Thorpe Hall Avenue to the east. Its overall height is 11.7m to 12m fronting Woodgrange Drive and 11.8m to 12.4m along Thorpe Hall Avenue. The proposed materials include red brick, white rendered bays with a timber effect cedral cladding, upvc white doors and upvc windows

1.4A total of 33 self-contained flats (23 x 1 bed and 10 x 2 bed flats) are proposed to the ground first and second floors of the building. Access to the flats is via two communal entrances on the south-eastern corner of the building via the car park and a pedestrian access from Thorpe Hall Avenue on the east elevation. The internal floorspace for each flat is as follows:

Flat 1 53.8sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 2 56.2sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 3 51.1sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 4 51.4sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 5 53.5sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 6 76sqm 2 bed (4 persons) Flat 7 64.3sqm 2 bed (4 persons) Flat 8 54.2sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 9 76.5sqm 2 bed (4 persons) Flat 10 50.9sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 11 57.1sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 12 75.5sqm 2 bed (4 persons) Flat 12a 50.7sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 14 54sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 15 76.7sqm 2 bed (4 persons) Flat 16 63.2sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 17 53.5sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 18 84sqm 2 bed (4 persons) Flat 19 75.1sqm 2 bed (4 persons) Flat 20 55.3sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 21 52.6sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 22 54.2sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 23 56.9sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 24 94.8sqm 2 bed (4 persons) Flat 25 53.9sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 26 77.2sqm 2 bed (4 persons) Flat 27 64.8sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 28 52.9sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 29 84.1sqm 2 bed (4 persons) Flat 30 71.6sqm 2 bed (4 persons) Flat 31 55.6sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 32 52.9sqm 1 bed (2 persons) Flat 33 53.7sqm 1 bed (2 persons)

Development Control Report 1.5 11 car parking spaces would serve the proposed flats. Two spaces are located to the northwest of the site in front of flat 4 and the remainder of the spaces are to the rear of the site. The vehicle access from Woodgrange Drive would be to the northwest corner of the site adjacent to the eastern boundary of no. 556 Woodgrange Drive. The vehicle access width is 4.5m wide x 45.8m in length.

1.6To the ground floor each flat would benefit from a patio area fronting the car park area or towards Woodgrange Drive to the north and Thorpe Hall Avenue to the east. Two of the flats to the first and second floor would have balconies. The remainder of the flats do not benefit from dedicated amenity space. A communal owners lounge to the ground floor (82sqm) is also proposed with a small patio facing the car park.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
17/01738/FULM: 193 Thorpe Hall Avenue, Thorpe Bay, Essex, SS1 3AP (Thorpe Ward)Report 303 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Distance drawingReport 1.1 MB Download
PDF
Elevation sheet 1Report 936 KB Download
PDF
Elevation sheet 2Report 863 KB Download
PDF
Location PlanPlan 1.3 MB Download
PDF
Site PlanPlan 1 MB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
71817/01738/FULM - 193 Thorpe Hall Avenue, Thorpe Bay, Essex, SS1 3AP (Thorpe Ward)This decision
71917/01489/FUL - Highlands Surgery, 1643-1645 London Road, Leigh on Sea, Essex, SS9 2SQ (West Leigh Ward)Approved 72017/01973/AMDT - Former East Beach Café, Rampart Terrace, Shoeburyness (Shoeburyness Ward)Approved 72116/00231/UNAU_B - 3 New Road, Leigh on Sea, Essex. SS9 2EA (Leigh Ward)Decided 72217/00063/UNAU_B - 7 Canvey Road, Leigh on Sea, Essex. SS9 2NN (West Leigh Ward)Approved 72317/01663/FULM - 69 - 71 High Street, Southend-on-Sea, Essex (Milton Ward)Approved 72417/01495/FULM - Rear of 1 Shoebury Avenue, Shoeburyness, Southend-on-Sea, Essex (Shoeburyness Ward)Refused 72517/00860/FUL, 17/00861/LBC, 17/00862/FUL, 17/00863/LBC &17/00864/FUL - Herschell House, 87 Leigh Hill, Leigh-on-Sea, Essex (Leigh Ward)Approved 72617/01332/FUL - 1A Stock Road, Southend-on-Sea, Essex SS2 5QA (St Lukes Ward)Approved 72717/01648/FUL - Billet Wharf, High Street, Leigh-on-Sea (Leigh Ward)Decided 72817/01946/FUL - 1053 London Road, Leigh-on-Sea (Blenheim Park Ward)Approved 72917/02056/OUT - Land adjacent 5 Shorefield Gardens, Westcliff-on-Sea, Essex (Milton Ward)Deferred 73017/02048/FULH - 8 Cashiobury Terrace, Southend-on-Sea, Essex SS1 1EZ (Milton Ward)Refused 73117/02092/FULH - 36 Leigh Hill, Leigh-on-Sea, Essex, SS9 2DN (Leigh Ward)Refused 73217/02115/FULH - 34 Percy Road, Leigh-on-Sea, Essex, SS9 2LA (West Leigh Ward)Approved 733EN/17/00283/UNAU_B - 176 Brightwell Avenue, Westcliff on Sea, Essex. SS0 9EH (Westborough Ward)Decided

Who was there

19 of 29 attended
FW
Councillor Floyd WaterworthChair, present
DG
Councillor David GarstonVice-Chair, present
BA
Councillor Bernard ArscottCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
BA
Councillor Brian AylingCommittee Member, present
MB
Councillor Margaret BortonCommittee Member, present
HB
Councillor Helen BoydCommittee Member, present
SB
Councillor Steve BuckleyCommittee Member, present
MB
Councillor Maureen ButlerCommittee Member, present as substitute
TC
Councillor Tino CallaghanCommittee Member, present
NF
Councillor Nigel FolkardCommittee Member, present
JG
Councillor Jonathan GarstonCommittee Member, present
RH
Councillor Roger HadleyCommittee Member, present

All 29 on the meeting page

On this subject at Southend-on-Sea

Search all
  1. 17/01738/FULM - 193 Thorpe Hall Avenue, Thorpe Bay, Essex, SS1 3AP (Thorpe Ward)This decision
  2. 20/01199/FULM - Roslin Hotel, Thorpe Esplanade, Southend on Sea (Thorpe Ward)Agreed
  3. 20/00513/FULM - All Weather Pitch, Southchurch Park, Southend-on-Sea (Thorpe Ward)Approved

More from Southend-on-Sea Development Control Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
30 Apr 2025 Minutes of the Meeting held on Wednesday, 2nd April, 2025- That the Minutes of the Meeting held on Wednesday 2 nd April 2025 be confirmed as a correct record and signed. Decided Open
30 Apr 2025 25/00280/AMDT - Garages at Eagle Way, Shoeburyness (Shoeburyness Ward)That PLANNING PERMISSION be GRANTED subject to the following conditions: 01 The development hereby being amended shal... Approved Open
30 Apr 2025 25/00167/FUL - 18 Brightwell Avenue, Westcliff-on-Sea (Westborough Ward)- That PLANNNG PERMISSION be REFUSED for the following reason: 01 The proposed development would result in room 3 bei... Refused Open
30 Apr 2025 25/00358/FUL - 19 Blatches Chase, Eastwood (Blenheim Park Ward)- That PLANNING PERMISSION be REFUSED for the following reasons: 01 The development introduces types and levels of no... Refused Open
30 Apr 2025 TPO 5/2024 - Land Between 89 - 91 Alexandra Road, Southend-on-Sea (Milton Ward)- That Tree Preservation Order 05/2024 be confirmed. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies