CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Southend-on-Sea Borough Council
Development Control Committee, Wednesday 5 June 2019 at 2.00pm

18/00087/UNAU_B - 81A Silverdale Avenue, Westcliff-on-Sea (Westborough Ward)

Refused Planning 7 papers

Development Control Committee refused this item on Wednesday 5 June 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item52

Resolved

- That ENFORCEMENT ACTION be AUTHORISED for the following reasons: 1. The proposal, by reason of the external staircase’s form, excessive size and scale and the rear dormers weak ratio of glazing to solid elevation constitutes poor design that would be excessively prominent and incongruous in appearance, resulting in material harm to the character and appearance of the host building and the wider rear garden scene. This harm is unacceptable and contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework (2019), Policies KP2 and CP4 of the Core Strategy (2007), Policies DM1 and DM3 of the Development Management Document (2015) and the advice contained within the Design and Townscape Guide (2009). 2. The proposed external staircase, as a result of its size, siting and proximity to the north and south boundaries with the neighbouring properties would result in an unacceptable level of both actual and perceived overlooking and resultant loss of privacy to the occupants of Nos. 83, 81 and 79 Silverdale Avenue. This material harm to residential amenity is unacceptable and contrary to the National Planning Policy Framework (2019); Policies KP2 and CP4 of the Core Strategy (2007); Policies DM1 and DM3 of the Development Management Document (2015); and the advice contained within the Design and Townscape guide (2009). 3. The Committee resolved that the enforcement notice would include the unauthorised outbuilding which by virtue of its size, design and position appears as an excessively bulky and overbearing feature in the rear garden scene harmful to neighbour amenity which is unacceptable and conflicts with the National Planning Policy Framework (2019), Policies KP2 and CP4 of the Southend-on-Sea Core Strategy (2007), Policies DM1 and DM3 of the Southend-on-Sea Development Management Document (2015) and the advice contained within the Southend-on-Sea Design and Townscape Guide (2009). The Local Planning Authority has acted positively and proactively in determining this application by identifying matters of concern with the proposal and determining the application within a timely manner, clearly setting out the reason(s) for refusal, allowing the Applicant the opportunity to consider the harm caused and whether or not it can be remedied by a revision to the proposal. The detailed analysis is set out in a report prepared by officers. In the circumstances the proposal is not considered to be sustainable development. The Local Planning Authority is willing to discuss the best course of action. Informatives You are advised that as the proposed extension(s) to your property equates to less than 100sqm of new floorspace the development benefits from a Minor Development Exemption under the Community Infrastructure Levy Regulations 2010 (as amended) and as such no charge is payable. See www.southend.gov.uk/cil for further details about CIL.
Word for word from the decision Southend-on-Sea published for this meeting. Source: democracy.southend.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Southend-on-Sea's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Control Committee

Reference: 18/00087/UNAU_B

Ward: Westborough

Without planning permission the installation of an external Breach of Control staircase to the rear elevation and erection of rear outbuilding

Address: 81a Silverdale Avenue, Westcliff on Sea, Essex. SS0 9BB

Case Opened: 23rd March 2018

Case Officer: Steve Jones

Recommendation: AUTHORISE ENFORCEMENT ACTION

81a Silverdale Avenue, Westcliff on Sea, Essex. SS0 9BB

Development Control Report 1 Site Location and description

1.1The site contains a two storey semi-detached dwelling which has been converted into two flats. The property has a rear outrigger and the rear garden is split between the two flats. The flat subject of this report is on the first floor.

1.2The surrounding area comprises terraced and semi-detached dwellings of similar style and design. There are a few external staircases present within the surrounding area. The nearest is located in a similar location at the adjoining property, No 79 which is a simple straight staircase with a small platform to the top outside of the rear door at first floor.

1.3The site is not subject of any site specific policy designations and is not within a Conservation Area.

2 Lawful Planning Use

2.1The authorised use is as a dwelling - Use Class C3 of the Town and Country Planning Act Use Classes (Amendment) Order 2005.

3 Relevant Planning History

3.118/02349/FUL – Install external staircase to rear and erect outbuilding (Retrospective) and install dormer to rear. – Refused (Copy of officer report attached as Appendix ‘A’)

4 The alleged planning breaches and the harm caused

4.1The unauthorised installation of a wooden rear staircase.

4.2An external staircase extends the full width of the rear wall of the outrigger and is some 4.4 metres high. The flat has no Permitted Development Rights and the staircase in any event represents development requiring express planning permission which has not been obtained. The unauthorised staircase has timber vertical supports and wooden railings, with a platform at the upper level some 2m wide and 1.75m deep which facilitates the opening of the rear door outwards. The formation of a storage area within the area under the staircase considerably reduces the openness to the rear and has the appearance of a permanent ‘extension’ at ground floor with the staircase above. Therefore, as explained in the appended officer report, the staircase structure forms a visually harmful, bulky, incongruous and excessively dominant and oppressive feature which is out of scale and character with the rear garden scene.

4.3The outrigger currently extends some 4.6m beyond the rear wall of the neighbouring dwelling at No. 83 (to the north). The neighbouring property has been extended at ground floor, with a rear conservatory present. The staircase extends another 1.75m beyond the end of the outrigger. From the top platform of the staircase it is possible to gain a full view of the rear garden and the rear of the neighbouring property, into the conservatory.

Development Control Report 4.4 From the southern side of the top platform and to some extent the lower levels of the staircase, a full view of the rear garden and rear elevation of the neighbouring flat and the side elevation of No. 79 is obtained. 1.8m high privacy screens could be added to each side of the top platform of the staircase to mitigate the overlooking, however this is considered to be unacceptable in design terms as this would add even further to the unacceptable prominence and bulk of the staircase and would be out of keeping the rear garden scene.

4.5The unauthorised external staircase therefore results in material harm to the living conditions of the occupiers of No.83, 81 and 79, in terms of dominance, an overbearing impact, loss of privacy and both actual and perceived overlooking.

4.6The unauthorised construction of an outbuilding measuring 4.4m deep by 3.45m wide with a flat roof with a maximum height of 2.5m.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
18/00087/UNAU_B: 81A Silverdale Avenue, Westcliff-on-Sea (Westborough Ward)Report 1.3 MB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Platform area south sideReport 472 KB Download
PDF
VIew of stairs showing storage areaReport 401 KB Download
PDF
View to east from platformReport 488 KB Download
PDF
View to south from platformReport 421 KB Download
PDF
View up towards platformReport 375 KB Download
PDF
Void under stairs showing extent of platformReport 370 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
31Minutes of the Meeting held on Wednesday, 6th March 2019Decided 32Minutes of the Meeting held on Wednesday 3rd April 2019Decided 3419/00086/FULM - 277 Prince Avenue, Westcliff-on-Sea (St Laurence Ward)Refused 3519/00420/BC4M - Chalkwell Hall Infants School, London Road, Leigh on Sea (Chalkwell Ward)Approved 3619/00565/FULM - Rear of 95, Prince Avenue. Southend on Sea (St Laurence Ward)Refused 3719/00600/FUL - Land rear of Highlands Court, London Road, Leigh on Sea (West Leigh Ward)Refused 3819/00467/FUL - 1373 London Road, Leigh-on-Sea, Leigh on Sea (Belfairs Ward)Refused 3919/00528/FUL - 169 Manchester Drive, Leigh-on Sea (Blenheim Park Ward)Approved 4019/00369/FUL - 1053 London Road, Leigh-on-Sea (Blenheim Park Ward)Approved 4119/00502/FULH - 64 Mount Avenue, Westcliff-on-Sea (Chalkwell Ward)Refused 4219/00376/FULH - 44B Glendale Gardens, Leigh-on-Sea (Leigh Ward)Approved 4319/00373/AMDT - 129 Leigh Hall Road, Leigh-on-Sea (Leigh Ward)Approved 4417/00219/UNAU_B - 101 Broadway, Leigh-on-Sea (Leigh Ward)Refused 4519/00384/AMDT - Garages, Rochford Road, Westcliff on Sea (St Laurence Ward)Approved 4618/02007/FUL - Cockethurst, Eastwoodbury Lane, Southend on Sea (St Laurence Ward)Refused 4719/00597/FUL - 194 Leigh Road, Leigh-on-Sea (Leigh Ward)Approved 4818/00839/FUL - Land rear of 106 -112 High Street, Shoeburyness (Shoeburyness Ward)Decided 4919/00663/FUL - 28 Bellhouse Crescent, Leigh-on-Sea (Belfairs Ward)Approved 5019/00675/FUL - The Trinity, 3 Trinity Avenue, Westcliff on Sea (Milton Ward)Refused 5119/00598/FULH - 67 Branksome Road, Southend-on-Sea (Kursaal Ward)Approved
5218/00087/UNAU_B - 81A Silverdale Avenue, Westcliff-on-Sea (Westborough Ward)This decision

Who was there

16 of 29 attended
NW
Councillor Nick WardChair, present
MB
Councillor Margaret BortonVice-Chair, present
DG
Councillor David GarstonCommittee Member, present
AC
Councillor Anne ChalkCommittee Member, apologies
AD
Councillor Alan DearCommittee Member, present
FE
Councillor Fay EvansCommittee Member, present
SH
Councillor Stephen HabermelCommittee Member, present
HM
Councillor Helen McDonaldCommittee Member, present
PV
Councillor Paul Van LooyCommittee Member, present
CW
Councillor Chris WalkerCommittee Member, present
BA
Councillor Brian AylingCommittee Member, present
JB
Councillor Jennifer BeckCommittee Member, present

All 29 on the meeting page

More from Southend-on-Sea Development Control Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
30 Apr 2025 Minutes of the Meeting held on Wednesday, 2nd April, 2025- That the Minutes of the Meeting held on Wednesday 2 nd April 2025 be confirmed as a correct record and signed. Decided Open
30 Apr 2025 25/00280/AMDT - Garages at Eagle Way, Shoeburyness (Shoeburyness Ward)That PLANNING PERMISSION be GRANTED subject to the following conditions: 01 The development hereby being amended shal... Approved Open
30 Apr 2025 25/00167/FUL - 18 Brightwell Avenue, Westcliff-on-Sea (Westborough Ward)- That PLANNNG PERMISSION be REFUSED for the following reason: 01 The proposed development would result in room 3 bei... Refused Open
30 Apr 2025 25/00358/FUL - 19 Blatches Chase, Eastwood (Blenheim Park Ward)- That PLANNING PERMISSION be REFUSED for the following reasons: 01 The development introduces types and levels of no... Refused Open
30 Apr 2025 TPO 5/2024 - Land Between 89 - 91 Alexandra Road, Southend-on-Sea (Milton Ward)- That Tree Preservation Order 05/2024 be confirmed. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies