What was decided
The council noted that it entered the Phase 2 main works contract with BY Development Limited (Bouygues) in March 2026. It approved using the break clause to defer the F blocks to Phase 3. These blocks contain 41 council homes. Report P12, P13
The council noted that the updated Phase 2b main works cost is £66,601,435, rather than £88,458,598 in the February 2026 executive update. Report P76
The council confirmed that the land shown edged red in Appendix A is no longer required for housing purposes. It approved changing the land from housing purposes to planning purposes under section 226 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 and section 122(1) of the Local Government Act 1972. After that change is complete, it approved changing the land back to housing purposes under section 9 of the Housing Act 1985 and section 122(1) of the Local Government Act 1972. Report P46
Why
The updated strategy lets the council and Bouygues continue the estate renewal while maintaining commitments to residents [P1] [P8]. Phase 2b forms part of the council's housing delivery programme [P3]. If Phase 2b did not proceed, 133 new council homes for social rent would be delivered at another time, likely at significantly more cost [P3]. Report P1, P3, P8
Concerns about the design and viability of the F blocks led to their deferral [P29]. Moving them to Phase 3 allows time to redesign and reassess them and to finalise long term plans for Pilgrims' Way Primary School [P30]. Further efficiency savings for Block H are unlikely, so proceeding with it helps prevent delays and keeps the programme on schedule [P31] [P32]. Report P29, P30, P31, P32
Where section 203 applies, affected parties cannot seek an injunction to delay or stop the development, but they can seek compensation [P4]. The council considered appropriation proportionate and justified because it reduces delay and cost risk and gives greater certainty [P10]. Report P4, P10
What happens next
Use the Phase 2 main works contract break clause to defer the F blocks and their 41 council homes to Phase 3 [P13] [P88]. Report P13, P88
Formally submit Phase 2b to the Building Safety Regulator through the Building Safety Gateway [P14]. The target for Block H is February 2027 [P16]. Report P14, P16
Carry out the change from housing to planning purposes, then change the land back to housing after completion [D] [P46]. Make budget provision for any compensation claims for reduced property values [P84]. Report P46, P84
The money
- £66,601,435 Updated Phase 2b main works cost following removal of the F blocks from Phase 2b. The F block sites will be left with piling mats and require further work. Report P76, P77
- £142,642,780 Updated total for Phase 2 main works. Report P75, P76
- £88,458,598 Earlier Phase 2b cost recorded in the February 2026 executive update.
- £26.6m Greater London Authority grant funding attributable to Phase 2b. Report P110
- £47.6m Greater London Authority grant funding for Phase 2. Report P80
- £73m Total Greater London Authority grant allocated across all phases. Report P80
- £164,499,943 Estimated Phase 2 main works contract approved in February 2026. Report P74
- £76,041,345 Phase 2a cost. Report P76
Options considered
- Chosen: Proceed with Block H in Phase 2b and defer the F blocks to Phase 3. Concerns about design and viability led to deferral. It allows redesign and reassessment and time to finalise long term plans for Pilgrims' Way Primary School. Report P29, P30
- Chosen: Change the land to planning purposes and later change it back to housing. This enables section 203 where its conditions are met, reducing injunction risk while preserving compensation rights. Report P4, P10, P24
- Rejected: Do not appropriate the land, insure against claims and accept potential injunction delays. This could cause lengthy delays and significantly increased costs. An injunction might also succeed and stop the development. Report P10
- Rejected: Do not proceed with Phase 2b. The 133 new council homes for social rent would need delivery at another time, likely at significantly more cost. Report P3
Implications
- Financial: The revised strategy improves short term affordability by reducing immediate financing requirements and Housing Revenue Account borrowing pressures. Report P109
- Financial: Phase 2 is funded from resources supporting the Housing Investment Programme and a Greater London Authority grant. The grant is expected to reduce the council funding required. Report P78, P110
- Financial: The F blocks remain part of the wider programme. Future reports must determine their funding and affordability. Report P111
- Risk: Viability depends on regulatory approvals, construction inflation, asbestos and ground condition risks, together with compliance with grant funding conditions. Material cost pressures must be managed through approved project contingencies, compensating savings or future budget approvals. Report P112
- Financial: The two appropriations cause no net debt transfer because they occur on the same day. The budget must provide for compensation claims for reduced property values. Report P84, P85
- Legal: Appropriation enables section 203 to override certain third party rights when its conditions are met [P4] [P24]. Where it applies, affected parties can claim compensation instead of seeking an injunction, and the council will pay their professional adviser fees for rights of light claims [P40] [P44]. Report P4, P24, P40, P44
- Equalities: The updated Equality and Health Impact Assessment identifies positive and negative differential effects for groups with protected characteristics [P64]. Relevant mitigation measures are embedded in the programme, and impacts will continue to be monitored [P63] [P64]. Report P63, P64
- Climate: The Phase 2 proposals provide more energy efficient housing [P70]. They reduce carbon emissions by 85% beyond Part L 2021 Building Regulations [P71]. Report P70, P71
Who and where
- Residents of the Tustin Estate Report P17, P18
- People needing 238 council homes for social rent Report P34
- Returning leaseholders needing 5 shared equity homes Report P34
- Owners or lessees of properties with potential rights of light impacts Report P44
- People claiming loss of value from interference with a right Report P45
- People needing 53 council homes and 7 homes for returning leaseholders in later phases Report P37
- Council Housing Revenue Account and General Fund Report P85
- Pilgrims' Way Primary School Report P30
Timeline
- October 2022: Development agreement entered with Bouygues for all four phases. Report P19
- December 2025: Phase 2 changed to 100% affordable housing and split into two sub phases. Report P21
- February 2026 and March 2026: Phase 2 main works contract approved, then entered into. Report P12, P74
- 10th and 17th September 2026: Public appropriation notices appeared in Southwark News. Report P47
- 1 October 2026, 4.00pm: Deadline for representations or objections, with none received to date. Report P47
- February 2027: Building Safety Gateway submission target for Block H Phase 2b. Report P16
- September 2027: Phase 2b site start target. Report P16
- April 2030: Phase 2b practical completion target. Report P16
Plain English for the jargon
- Appropriation: Changing the purpose for which a council holds land [P24].
- Break clause: A contract term allowing the council to exclude, delay or change remaining blocks [P12].
- Building Safety Gateway: The route for formally submitting Phase 2b to the Building Safety Regulator [P14].
- Section 203 of the Housing and Planning Act 2016: A power allowing development despite interference with certain rights, subject to conditions, with compensation instead [P4].
- Rights of light: Rights that affected owners or lessees may claim have been interfered with [P44].
- F blocks: The Phase 2b blocks deferred to Phase 3, containing 41 council homes [P13] [P29].
- Block H: The Phase 2b block that the council will proceed with [P29].
- Phase 2b: The sub phase containing Block H after the F blocks are deferred [P29] [P35].