Resolved That the Council in its capacity as sole Trustee of the Charity of John Seears for an Open Space and Recreation Ground, grant Sutton Living a 125 year lease at market value to convert Quarry Cottage into two residential flats, or retain as a single family dwelling, subject to consent of the Charity Commission. That, subject to Charity Commission consent, the Strategic Director - Resources be authorised to agree suitable terms for the lease of Quarry Cottage to Sutton Living. That it be noted, if Sutton Living were unable to proceed with the refurbishment, offers to refurbish the cottage for re-use is sought through an open marketing process.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
1.1In accordance with committee procedure rule 23.4 Requisitions, Full Council was asked to consider a requisition relating to item 7 from the Strategy & Resources Committee Meeting of 31 October 2016 on the Buildings Utilisation Implementation Board Report relating to Quarry Cottage, Seears Park. The reasons for the requisition were that the option relating to Yourspace.compost proposals for the site was not properly presented to Committee and that the social value of the proposals was incorrectly valued.
1.2Council resolved that the matter be reconsidered by the Strategy & Resources Committee, following a review that takes into consideration the social value of the proposals.
1.3In undertaking the review, Yourspace.compost has come to the view that it does not require use of Quarry Cottage to achieve its social enterprise objectives for the site.
Recommendations
The Strategy & Resources Committee is recommended to agree:
2.1In its capacity as sole Trustee of the Charity of John Seears for an Open Space and Recreation Ground, that the Sutton Living is granted a 125 year lease at market value to convert Quarry Cottage into two residential flats, or retain as a single family dwelling, subject to consent of the Charity Commission. Agenda Item 9 Page 228
2.2That subject to agreement of 2.1 above, and to the Charity Commission consent, the Strategic Director Resources be authorised to agree suitable terms for the lease of Quarry Cottage to Sutton Living.
2.3That if Sutton Living were unable to proceed with the refurbishment, offers to refurbish the cottage for reuse is sought through an open marketing process.
Background
3.1Strategy & Resources Committee of the 31 October 2016 considered a report which included as recommendation 2.5 that a 125 year lease be granted to Sutton Living to convert Quarry Cottage into 2 residential flats.
3.2The report included a summary of a review of options for the future use of the building which in addition to the Sutton Living proposals also included the option put forward by Yourspace.compost to convert Quarry Cottage for a mixed use that includes a cafe on the ground floor and a residential flat on the first floor. The option would also require Quarry Cottage and its gardens to be added to the existing plant nursery adjacent to Quarry Cottage that is run by Yourspace.compost.
3.3The decision made by Committee was requisitioned to Full Council on the basis that the history and progress of Yourspace.compost proposals had not been properly presented to the Committee and that the social value of what Yourspace.compost provides to the community had been given insufficient weight. Rather than debate the requisition, Full Council resolved that the proposals be reviewed, allowing for the social value of the proposals, and then reconsidered by Strategy & Resources Committee.
4. Issues
4.1In conducting the review, further information was requested for both options, including a detailed social value assessment using the Council’s standard methodology. In further discussions with the proprietor of Yourspace.compost to review the financial viability of the proposals and the social value assessment, a number of assurances were sought from the Council regarding the future operation of the plant nursery and how access to the Cottage could managed with tenants in occupation.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.