RESOLVED : that 1. Sutton Living Limited establish a Design and Build Development Subsidiary (“Sutton Living Design and Build Limited”) for the purposes of VAT recovery be agreed. 2. Authority to finalise the appropriate company structure and put in place all necessary contractual and governance arrangements be delegated to the Shareholder Representative, or their nominee, in consultation with the Chair of the Shareholdings Board.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
1.1This report presents proposals for establishing a separate development subsidiary to enable the recovery of VAT by Sutton Living Limited. Establishing a subsidiary is a reserved matter for the Sutton Shareholdings Board.
Recommendations
The Sutton Shareholding Board is recommended to:
2.1Agree that Sutton Living Limited establish a Design and Build Development Subsidiary (“Sutton Living Design and Build Limited”) for the purposes of VAT recovery.
2.2Delegate authority to finalise the appropriate company structure and put in place all necessary contractual and governance arrangements to the Shareholder Representative, or their nominee, in consultation with the Chair of the Shareholdings Board.
Background
3.1Sutton Living, like other Council wholly owned subsidiaries, has to pay VAT on services on all professional fees and currently cannot recover all of this money due to the nature of some of its Agenda Item 6 Page 2
supply. To provide a context, the estimated VAT likely to be payable on the Wallington Public Hall project alone amounts to nearly £80,000, and the project is not yet on site. This places Sutton Living Ltd, a wholly owned company of the Council, at a disadvantage when compared with projects delivered by the Council directly.
3.2In discussing with Devonshires (solicitors acting on behalf of Sutton Living for Wallington Public Hall), they suggested that by setting up a Development Subsidiary (or DevCo) and letting all professional and build contracts through this body, VAT could be recovered.
3.3Other local authority wholly owned development companies have set up development subsidiaries for VAT recovery purposes, and this advice was also given previously to the Council by EY in 2016 following their engagement on tax advice for the Council’s wholly owned companies.
3.4Consideration was given to the the option of the DevCo being a subsidiary of Opportunity Sutton Ltd to be able to used by the other OSL subsidiary, SDEN. This evaluation has been completed, and it has been concluded there is no financial advantage to this course of action.
4. Issues and Options
4.1The process followed in pursuing the establishment of a Development Subsidiary is as follows:
(1) Framework Development Agreement Sutton Living and the Design and Build Development Company (Sutton Living Design and Build Limited) will enter into a Framework Development Agreement (to allow multiple contracts to be set up and novated to it). The D&B Co (as developer) will undertake developments for Sutton Living (as employer). This allows the recovery of VAT.
(2) Governance The Directors of D&B Co will be the same as those of Sutton Living Ltd. The internal governance arrangements between Sutton Living and D&B Co will be dealt with through an internal governance agreement to demonstrate to HMRC that the D&B is a proper company for tax purposes. The terms of reference for subsidiary boards, delegated authorities/financial regulations and a protocol setting out matters needing parent consent and who gives that consent internally, will be part of the governance agreement.
(3) Service Level Agreement (SLA)/Cost Share Arrangements Sutton Living D&B Limited will require certain services e.g. staffing, and Sutton Living can provide services either under a SLA or Sutton Living can agree to share costs with Sutton Living Design & Build Ltd under a cost sharing agreement. Devonshires view is that tax accountants tend to favour cost sharing, though this requires further investigation.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Cognus Business Plan and BudgetThat the progress made by Cognus Limited against its 2025/28 Business Plan be noted. That the update on Cognus Limite...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.