RESOLVED : that authority to agree the award of the works contract by Sutton Living Limited for the development of Wallington Public Hall be delegated to the Shareholder Representative, or their nominee, in consultation with the Chair of the Shareholdings Board.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
1.1This report outlines the procurement and evaluation process followed by Sutton Living Limited to choose a contractor to undertake the building works at Wallington Public Hall and recommends the delegation of authority to agree the award of the works contract by Sutton Living Limited to the Shareholder Representative, or their nominee, in consultation with the Chair of the Shareholdings Board.
Recommendations
The Sutton Shareholdings Board is recommended to:
2.1Delegate authority to agree the award of the works contract by Sutton Living Limited for the development of Wallington Public Hall to the Shareholder Representative, or their nominee, in consultation with the Chair of the Shareholdings Board.
Background
3.1Sutton Living sought tenders for the redevelopment of Wallington Public Hall site using its Procurement Policy, for bids on both a qualitative and financial basis. An original tender Agenda Item 7 Page 6
deadline was extended two and a half weeks until the 8 January 2019, and four tenders were returned.
3.2Sutton Living is outside EU Procurement Rules, being a private company, nevertheless has a procurement policy to ensure transparency in terms of contractor selection.
3.3The tenders had been reviewed by the Company’s Employers’ Agent, Pellings.
3.4Authority to enter into contracts with a value greater than £3m is a matter reserved to the shareholder, and therefore agreement is sought via this report to delegate final approval to the Shareholder Representative, or their nominee, in consultation with the Chair of the Shareholding Board, given that it has not been possible to complete the tender evaluation by the date of despatch of this report.
Choice of Contractor
3.5A number of small to medium sized contractors were considered based on the knowledge and experience of the Employer’s Agent and MD, who has delivered development projects for RPs and Local Authorities elsewhere.
3.6A longlist was reduced to five contractors who were invited to bid on plans produced by the scheme architects, Bell Phillips, and a set of “Employer’s Requirements” drawn up by Sutton Living in collaboration with Pellings. Before the invitation to tender was sent out one contractor withdrew, leaving four, which still complies with the Company’s Procurement Policy.
Form of Contract
3.7A JCT (Design and Build) form of contract was chosen as being typical of those used by RPs and Local Authorities. It passes a significant degree of development risk to the contractor, but requires the requirements of the employer to be clearly set out. The form of contract, and subsequent amendments were agreed by Devonshires, the Company’s solicitors
Basis of Evaluation
3.8Tenders were invited on the basis of both quality and price, using price for 60% of the evaluation and 40% for quality. Quality was assessed by responses to how the contractor can deliver a successful scheme working in a restricted environment, and its logistics plan and flow chart, detailing how it will undertake the work in the most efficient way. Finally, tenderers were required to provide examples of similar completed schemes, demonstrating value for money.
Tender Returns
3.9Tenders were returned from:
● Kind & Co ● Lifebuild Page 7 Agenda Item 7
● PA Findlay ● SDB Contractors
Tender Analysis
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Cognus Business Plan and BudgetThat the progress made by Cognus Limited against its 2025/28 Business Plan be noted. That the update on Cognus Limite...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.