- 1. That the revised costs associated with the repair of the Old Rectory and its enhanced conservation status be noted; 2. That the grant of a long lease of the Old Rectory to Sutton Living Limited (SLL) for residential use only, by conversion to apartments for letting, subject to planning and Listed Building consent, be agreed; 3. That the grant of a long lease of The Grove to Sutton Living Limited (SLL) for conversion to apartments for letting, subject to planning consent, be agreed; 4. That it be noted that the Assistant Director (Asset Planning, Management and Capital Delivery) will agree terms and take all steps necessary to effect the above recommendations, including arranging for the sale price agreed with Sutton Living to be reviewed and certified by an independent firm of chartered surveyors; 5. That it be noted that in the event that Sutton Living Ltd cannot discharge the work set out in the report and referred to in recommendation 2.2, further proposals which reflect the character of, and ambitions for, the buildings be brought to this committee 6. That it be noted that leasehold transfers of either or both properties which restricts their use to rented apartments only impacts upon their values and that transfer to Sutton Living enables the provision of additional rented housing, ensures the retention of the Council’s freeholds and enables a more effective control of the buildings. Committee is consequently requested to agree that either or both properties are transferred at less than the best consideration reasonably obtainable if necessary to effect the above recommendations.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
1.1This report on two of the principal heritage buildings of Carshalton sets out the latest progress and recommendations in relation to the Old Rectory and the proposed strategy for The Grove now it is no longer in use by the Council.
Recommendations
The Strategy and Resources Committee is recommended to:
2.1Note the revised costs associated with the repair of the Old Rectory and its enhanced conservation status;
2.2Agree the grant of a long lease of the Old Rectory to Sutton Living Limited (SLL) for residential use only, by conversion to apartments for letting, subject to planning and Listed Building consent;
2.3Agree the grant of a long lease of The Grove to Sutton Living Limited (SLL) for conversion to apartments for letting, subject to planning consent;
2.4Note that the Assistant Director (Asset Planning, Management and Capital Delivery) will agree terms and take all steps necessary to effect the above recommendations, including arranging Agenda Item 9 Page 50
for the sale price agreed with Sutton Living to be reviewed and certified by an independent firm of chartered surveryors;
2.5Note that the Assistant Director (Asset Planning, Management and Capital Delivery) will carry out marketing, negotiate and agree long leasehold transfers of either or both properties to an alternative purchaser competent to deliver an appropriate scheme should it not be possible to secure a viable outcome through Sutton Living Limited; and
2.6Note that leasehold transfers of either or both properties which restricts their use to rented apartments only impacts upon their values and that transfer to Sutton Living enables the provision of additional rented housing, ensures the retention of the Council’s freeholds and enables a more effective control of the buildings. Committee is consequently requested to agree that either or both properties are transferred at less than the best consideration reasonably obtainable if necessary to effect the above recommendations.
Background
The Grove
3.1The Grove is a large former dwelling house built around 1840 and locally listed. Previous occupants include the Rector of Carshalton, who laid out the grounds forming the centre of what is now Grove Park. In 1924 the house and grounds were acquired by the then Carshalton Urban District Council. The Grove became the UDC headquarters and its grounds became Grove Park.
3.2Carshalton UDC was merged into the London Borough of Sutton in 1965 and plans began to be formulated for the current Civic Centre. The Grove continued to be used as a satellite Council office. This has now ceased as part of workspace rationalisation and it is necessary to find an alternative use.
The Old Rectory
3.3Reports on the Old Rectory have been presented to Committee on several previous occasions. Most recently Strategy and Resources Committee in October 2016 authorised transfer to SLL for a mixed use scheme consisting of four residential apartments and a unit for commercial letting.
3.4Since that time, SLL has struggled to secure a financially viable scheme in light of increasing build costs and, most recently, the change in the building’s listed status from Grade II to Grade II*. This is a considerably higher level of protection and afforded to less than 10% of the country’s listed buildings. It means a greater level of scrutiny of any development proposals, and with that, higher risk and expenditure for a developer.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.