- 1. That the residential development of such parts of the grounds of Hill House as can satisfactorily be developed, subject to planning consent, as set out in this report and assuming that part or all of the current building remains in use, be approved; 2. That the development of new housing by the Council, subject to feasibility studies, or should that not reasonably be possible, the long leasehold transfer of land to a developer be approved; 3. That the efforts to secure an alternative management structure for Hill House to retain community use and agree to allow the voluntary sector until September 2019 to develop viable proposals, be noted; and 4. That it be noted that the Assistant Director (Asset Planning, Management and Capital Delivery) will agree terms and take all steps necessary to implement the above recommendations, in consultation with the lead members for Resources and the Voluntary Sector.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
1.1This report sets out the recommended future proposals for the use of Hill House and its grounds in light of the anticipated closure of St Helier Community Association.
Recommendations
The Strategy and Resources Committee is recommended to:
2.1Approve the residential development of such parts of the grounds of Hill House as can satisfactorily be developed, subject to planning consent, as set out in this report and assuming that part or all of the current building remains in use;
2.2Approve the development of new housing by the Council, subject to feasibility studies, or should that not reasonably be possible, the long leasehold transfer of land to a developer;
2.3Note the efforts to secure an alternative management structure for Hill House to retain community use and agree to allow the voluntary sector until September 2019 to develop viable proposals; and Agenda Item 8 Page 42
2.4Note that the Assistant Director (Asset Planning, Management and Capital Delivery) will agree terms and take all steps necessary to implement the above recommendations.
Background
3.1Hill House is a Grade II listed former residential property in wooded grounds of around one hectare. It has been managed by St Helier Community Association (SHCA) for some years. Rooms within the main building are hired to local charities as office accommodation and a large 1960s extension is rented out for weddings, activities and other functions.
3.2The directors and trustees of SHCA wish to cease their activities after many years of service in the locality.
3.3The grounds of Hill House are identified as having potential for development, albeit there are trees which are considered worthy of protection and any scheme would need to reflect this.
3.4It would be preferable not to have to relocate the present occupiers and users of Hill House. This however depends upon identifying a viable future management structure and appropriate measures to deal with all costs.
3.5The property was originally acquired by London County Council as part of the development of the St Helier Estate. It became a community centre prior to WW2 and later passed into the ownership of Surrey CC before transferring to LB Sutton as part of the local government reorganisation of 1965.
4. Issues
4.1SHCA notified the Council that it intends to cease operations on or shortly after April 2019. This has subsequently been extended to end of September following a request by the voluntary sector for more time to develop proposals for Hill House. The occupiers of the building are local charities and community groups who hire accommodation on a fully inclusive basis and would ideally need to find alternatives were it not possible to continue to operate Hill House.
4.2The function hall extension is used for classes and functions including weddings on an ad-hoc basis. While there are numerous bookings each year, the hall is not used full-time. It is however the only community hall in the area with capacity to host large functions. This area was a much later extension to the main building, constructed in the 1960s. As the hall is not in keeping with the original listed building it is felt the loss of that space is unlikely to be contentious in design terms should it be necessary.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.