RESOLVED That the disposal by way of the grant of a long lease (not less than 125 years) of The Grove, Grove Park (“the Property”) to Sutton Living Limited at the best consideration reasonably obtainable on the basis of dwellings for sale on the open market also by long lease be authorised That it be noted that the Council's intention to dispose of the Property in accordance with section 123(2A) of the local Government Act 1972 has been advertised without any objections being raised. That authority be delegated to the Assistant Director (Assets), in consultation with the Chair of the committee, to agree the final terms for disposal at best consideration (supported by a valuation of the property by an external firm of chartered surveyors) and subject to such conditions he considers reasonable in consultation with the Monitoring Officer.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
1.1Strategy and Resources Committee on 1 April 2019 agreed to grant a long lease of The Grove, Grove Park for conversion back to residential use by way of a scheme of apartments for letting. This was to be carried out by Sutton Living, the Council’s wholly-owned development company.
1.2The Grove is a surplus asset which is no longer used as a council office. Disposal will generate a capital receipt and contribute to provision of housing. The recommended decision helps to deliver the council’s ambitions for Sutton through the corporate plan with new, additional housing and seeking the optimum use of a surplus asset.
1.3Following some detailed analysis and extensive due diligence, Sutton Living has since confirmed that a scheme for letting is not financially viable and this report seeks consent to a change of strategy to allow the dwellings to be sold on longer leases.
Recommendations
2.1To Authorise the disposal by way of the grant of a long lease (not less than 125 years) of The Grove, Grove Park (“the Property”) to Sutton Living Limited at the best consideration reasonably obtainable on the basis of dwellings for sale on the open market also by long lease.
Report page 1 Agenda Item 12 Page 160 Update on The Grove, Carshalton
2.2Note that the Council's intention to dispose of the Property in accordance with section 123(2A) of the local Government Act 1972 has been advertised without any objections being raised.
2.3To delegate authority to the Assistant Director (Assets) to agree the final terms for disposal at best consideration (supported by a valuation of the property by an external firm of chartered surveyors) and subject to such conditions he considers reasonable in consultation with the Monitoring Officer.
3. Background and Key Information
3.1Strategy and Resources Committee on 1 April 2019 agreed the disposal of the Property by way of the grant of a long lease of The Grove to Sutton Living subject to planning consent for conversion to residential use. The building was originally a large dwelling before becoming an office and the headquarters of Carshalton UDC.
3.2The committee agreed that properties to let would be developed and that officers would agree to final terms, subject to external certification. It was noted that a letting scheme would reduce site value possibly below full market value and the Committee also agreed a disposal at less than best value reasonably obtainable on that basis.
3.3Sutton Living submitted a planning application to the Council as the Local Planning Authority (LPA), for a change of use of the existing office building to provide 10 self contained residential units. Planning permission has been approved, subject to a Section 106 Agreement.
3.4Viability of a scheme for Sutton Living or any other developer depends on values attained over the cost of conversion. Build costs have increased significantly. Schemes for letting, often known as build to rent, are usually on a much larger scale than 10 dwellings for economies of scale and management.
3.5This combination of factors has meant Sutton Living is no longer able to deliver a scheme for letting at an acceptable return. External valuation advice has confirmed that a scheme for letting assuming delivery by a private developer/landlord would not carry enough return to be of interest.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.