Sutton Civic and Town Centre Regeneration - Update
AgreedCommittee1 paper
AI summarySutton Council has terminated the procurement for its Civic and Town Centre regeneration scheme after the preferred bidder's proposals were judged unaffordable, but will continue developing housing on the current civic centre site.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedContinue housing on civic centre site
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextDevelop housing, review relocation optionsOfficers to notify bidders of abandonment
Who it affectsCouncil, residents, preferred bidderSutton town centre services and users
What was decided
The procurement process for the regeneration scheme has been terminated because the overall scheme, including the new Civic Hub, is unaffordable to the Council.
The Council will continue to develop proposals for housing on the current civic centre site.
The Council will continue to review options to relocate services within the Town Centre.
Why
The revised estimated cost of the preferred bidder's proposals creates a borrowing requirement for the Council that significantly exceeds initial estimates. Report P9
Forecast revenue budget savings from the scheme are no longer enough to offset the cost of financing the higher level of borrowing, creating a pressure in the Medium Term Financial Plan. Report P9
Value engineering with the preferred bidder failed to bring the scheme back within the affordability envelope and would have presented alternative risks. Report P14
What happens next
Officers will notify everyone who tendered or applied to tender of the decision to abandon the procurement, with reasons, as required by Regulation 55 of the Public Contracts Regulations 2015. Report P29, P30
The Council will continue to develop housing proposals for the current civic centre site and review options for relocating services within the town centre.
Future reports will set out the statutory powers available to the Council for any alternative development or disposal options. Report P16
Options considered
Rejected: Continue with the preferred bidder's scheme (GKRL). Revised costs create unaffordable borrowing requirement and revenue budget pressure. Report P9, P14
Rejected: Status quo (do nothing). Considered as a comparator in the financial assessment, not selected. Report P8
Rejected: Refurbish the current civic centre. Considered as a comparator in the financial assessment, not selected. Report P8
Rejected: Long term rental of alternative premises in Sutton Town Centre. Considered as a comparator in the financial assessment, not selected. Report P8
Chosen: Terminate procurement, continue housing on current civic centre site, review relocation options. Scheme unaffordable; alternative approaches to be explored. Report P14
Implications
Financial: Continuing the scheme would have required a significant increase in borrowing, with revenue costs exceeding forecast savings. Report P9, P13
Financial: Ceasing the scheme now avoids further costs in pursuing an unaffordable option. Report P14
Legal: The decision not to enter a development agreement and to terminate the procurement is supported both contractually and under procurement law. Report P30
Legal: Notification of the decision to abandon must be given to all tenderers and applicants under Regulation 55 of the Public Contracts Regulations 2015. Report P29
Climate: A full Climate Impact Assessment will be undertaken as future options develop, with opportunities for renewable energy, green space and biodiversity on the civic centre site. Report P1
Risk: Future inflation and further development costs could have pushed estimated costs even higher, with no guarantee of delivery within affordability limits. Report P11, P13
Who and where
London Borough of Sutton (as landowner, procuring authority and future service provider) Report P9
Unsuccessful bidders at final tender stage Report P18
Residents and users of council services in Sutton Town Centre Report P1
Timeline
7th November 2022: Strategy and Resources Committee approved preferred option of a comprehensive mixed-use scheme including a new Civic Centre. Report P15
October 2024: Detailed financial analysis of the preferred bidder option presented to the Strategy and Resources Committee. Report P7
7th October 2024: Results of the procurement exercise reported to the Strategy and Resources Committee. Report P15
10th October 2024: Preferred bidder letter issued to GKRL. Report P25
11.11.2025: Finance and Legal consultations completed on the report. Report P42, P43
8 December 2025: Strategy and Resources Committee decided to terminate the procurement.
Plain English for the jargon
GKRL: The preferred bidder selected for the regeneration scheme.
Civic Hub: The proposed new civic centre complex to be built as part of the scheme.
PDA: Pre-Development Agreement between the Council and GKRL covering work before any development agreement.
DA: Development Agreement, the full contract the Council chose not to enter into.
CFR: Capital Financing Requirement, the Council's underlying need to borrow for capital spending.
PCR: Public Contracts Regulations 2015, governing the procurement process.
ITT: Invitation to Tender document issued to bidders.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item29
Resolved
That the procurement process be terminated on the basis that the proposals for the overall scheme including the Council’s new Civic Hub are unaffordable to the Council. That it be agreed to continue to develop proposals for housing on the current civic centre site and to continue to review options to relocate services within the Town Centre.
Word for word from the decision Sutton published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.sutton.gov.uk
Page 117 Agenda Item 8 Sutton Civic and Town Centre Regeneration - Update
Report Title Sutton Civic and Town Centre Regeneration - Update
Committee Strategy and Resources Committee
Meeting Date 8 December 2025
Chair Councillor Barry Lewis - Leader of the Council
Lead Member Councillor Sunita Gordon - Lead Member for Resources
Report From Richard Simpson - Strategic Director of Resources and S151 Officer
Report Author(s) Lucy Taylor - Programme Manager - Sutton Civic and Town Centre Regeneration
Ward(s) Affected Council Business Sutton Central
Ambitious for Sutton Action on climate change priorities An inclusive place for everyone Quality and affordable housing Strong and fair economic growth An efficient and well run Council
Open/Exempt Open, with the exception of Appendices A and B by virtue of paragraph 3, Schedule 12A of the Local Government Act 1972
Signed Date 25 November 2025
1 Summary
1.1 This report sets out an update on the Sutton Civic and Town Centre Regeneration programme which includes creating alternative premises for council offices and library; disposing of the existing Civic Centre site, Gibson Road Car Park and Secombe Theatre site for comprehensive development of housing; and improving the retail and leisure offer in the St. Nicholas Shopping Centre.
1.2 Following a procurement process, the Council selected the developer Genr8 Kajima Regeneration Ltd (GKRL) as preferred bidder at its Strategy and Resources Committee meeting in October 2024. The aim of the preferred bidder stage was to undertake further work to quantify and understand the costs of creating a new civic hub in more detail as the Council was to pay for the Civic Hub. As a result of the further work it has become apparent that there would be further costs and risks associated with the project which the
Report page 1 Agenda Item 8 Page 118 Sutton Civic and Town Centre Regeneration - Update
Council considers to be unaffordable.
1.3 It is recommended that the Council does not proceed to enter into a development agreement with GKRL. Alternative options are being explored that will deliver the Council’s objectives, be affordable to the Council and enable the development of new housing including a significant proportion of affordable housing on the existing Civic Centre Site, Secombe Theatre and Gibson Road Car Park sites that will contribute to the Council’s housing ambitions and relocate services within the Town Centre.
2 Recommendations
2.1 To terminate the procurement process on the basis that the proposals for the overall scheme including the Council’s new Civic Hub are unaffordable to the Council.
2.2 To agree to continue to develop proposals for housing on the current civic centre site and to continue to review options to relocate services within the Town Centre.
3 Background and Key Information
3.1 In 2022 the Council considered the future potential of some of its land and property assets in Sutton Town Centre focussed on the St Nicholas Shopping Centre and the current Civic Centre site, Gibson Road Multi-Storey Car Park and the vacant Secombe Theatre sites. It was recognised that the existing civic centre site is reaching the end of its asset life requiring significant repairs and refurbishment and is costly to run. The building is too big for the Council following the change to working patterns after the Covid-19 pandemic and plans to relocate Sutton College to the heart of the High Street had also been developed.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.