Resolved That the Enforcement Officer will not take any further action at this time but as it is clear from the Company’s website that there is to be an increase in the level of activities when the current lockdown comes to an end a planning application should be requested. This should help control the frequency and scale of the activities occurring. If no application is received within 4 months then a Planning Contravention Notice should be served to ascertain the actual activity levels at that time. Then depending on the outcome of the investigations a further decision on whether or not enforcement action should be taken would be made within 6 months.
Word for word from the decision Teignbridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.teignbridge.gov.uk
1.1This case is referred to committee at the request of the local ward member.
1.2It concerns a site originally part of the Mamhead House estate which has been separated off and is now occupied as a separate residential unit with its own garden and associated parkland (“the Site”).
1.3In June 2019 the Council received a complaint about a sculpture park being created at the Site that was advertised as being open to the public. The complaint referred to marketing information and signage at the Site entrance encouraging members of the public to turn up unannounced to view the Site and such having a detrimental impact on the amenity of nearby residents. It has also been alleged that the Site has changed from a residential unit with its own gardens and associated parkland, to commercial garden / Sculpture Park; including a café for visitors. Reference was also made to the Sculpture Park within the Site being advertised publicly for viewing.
2. ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATION APPROACH
2.1In response to the complaint, information was sought and obtained from site visits, the site owners and from complainants. Further advice has been sought on the impact of the use of the Site from Highway Authority (in terms of traffic generation) and Historic England and the Conservation Officer (in terms of the impact of the use on the historic fabric of the Site). The Council’s Tree Officer and the Landscape Officer have also provided comments.
2.2This evidence has been considered within the context of the relevant planning law which provides:
(i) Has there been a material change of use which amounts to development. Under planning legislation you are entitled to operate a business from a residential property without requiring planning permission subject to there not being any material impact on the surrounding area and nearby residential properties. This may potentially permit the public to view private gardens without requiring planning permission. Indeed, private garden showing can also take place either as an ancillary activity or through schemes such as Devon Open Studios or the National Gardens scheme.
(ii) If there has been a material change of use, is the development permitted development so that planning permission is not required? Permitted development rights exist which allow land to be used for the temporary / occasional change of use of non-residential land.
(iii) If not, planning permission is required. This could cover for example a situation where the use as a visitor attraction becomes the dominant use of the Site.
Page 2 of 5 Report Writing Guidance – February 2021
3. ENFORCEMENT TEAM’S FINDINGS
(i) Has there been a Material Change of Use?
The Nature of the Activity at the site
3.1Tours and events relating to both re-wilding and the sculpture park are being offered and / or carried out on the land. The landowner suggests that the majority of the tours / events that are taken up related to the various agricultural activities that are carried out on the land. There is no established “drop in” café on site. Those involved in tours are provided with refreshments as appropriate using the existing kitchen associated with the house.
The Level of Activity at the site
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.